13 ms·
An Appalachian gunsmith’s robot army (2009)
- danso 12y agoFWIW, I posted this story today because of the New Yorker's announcement of their redesign and temporary disabling of their paywall. I remembering reading the abstract of this article in 2009, and then became a subscriber because I wanted to read the full version...I'm not passionately against or for paywalls, but the New Yorker is probably the only single publication that could pull me like that. That said, I did a cursory search for the gunmaker...didn't see any big update, I saw a mention that it's in rotation with the Marines...but no contemporary mention of what sounded like an impending revolution of shotgun-wielding-robots.
- SEJeff 12y agoThis is a remarkable story, thanks for sharing it. As a former Shadow 200 UAV/Drone pilot, I had no idea that they had this type of tech, so it came as fascinating.
- dang 12y agoExcellent. More, please! We added the date. Edit: Perhaps I should clarify. By "more, please" I mean we want substantive articles on unexpected subjects, archival and historical material welcome. Not necessarily more on this topic.
- chillingeffect 12y ago> propels the shell out of a gun barrel What? > his own weapon: a fully automatic shotgun called the AA-12. "Auto Assault-12 (AA-12), originally designed and known as the Atchisson Assault Shotgun, is a shotgun developed in 1972 by Maxwell Atchisson." [0] What? Can someone please explain to me what's going on here? Is this just my own ignorance or are these factual errors? [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atchisson_Assault_Shotgun http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atchisson_Assault_Shotgun
- ephemeralgomi 12y agoThe article covers that. The original design was done by Atchisson, then sold to Baber, who improved on it.
- vwruetag 12y agoRead further in the Wikipedia article, the first sentence in the 'History' section is > In 1987, Max Atchisson sold the rights of the AA-12 to Jerry Baber of Military Police Systems, Inc., Piney Flats, Tennessee Quoting the New Yorker in full >[...]he started producing, from start to finish, his own weapon: a fully automatic shotgun called the AA-12. it is obvious that he was the first to produce a mass market ready model. The article doesn't claim that he invented it.
- nordsieck 12y ago"In 1987, Max Atchisson sold the rights of the AA-12 to Jerry Baber of Military Police Systems, Inc., Piney Flats, Tennessee.[3] MPS in turn developed the successor simply known as Auto Assault-12, which was redesigned over a period of 18 years with 188 changes and improvements to the original blueprint, modifications included changing the AA-12 from blowback- to gas-operated with a locked breech." [0] Looks like there was a bit of exaggeration going on, but not anything terribly out of line. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atchisson_Assault_Shotgun http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atchisson_Assault_Shotgun
- jboggan 12y agoI imagine the recoil would have been ungovernable in the original blowback configuration and the reciprocating mass would have been relatively huge.
- aaronem 12y ago> What? Expecting someone who writes for the New Yorker to understand how firearms work is, I think, expecting rather too much.
- jessaustin 12y ago
- angersock 12y agoSee, this is the sort of thing that I hate reading about. Like, yes, we have drones, and yes, we have firearms, and yes, we can add one to the other--but is it really a good idea? The potential for abuse of such systems is absurd; I cannot believe that any engineer with a shred of morality would voluntarily work on such things without at least a solid explanation of why doing so is permissible. Mark my words: these things will mostly be used against civilians and dissidents--not standing armies.
- mkr-hn 12y agoThe mantra I usually hear around here in regards to tech's harms--like putting people out of work--is to make the advances and let society adapt. It seems very shortsighted.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoBaber decided that the gun was too powerful to sell outside the military. He donated one to his local county sheriff, but turned everyone else away. “I don’t want that on my conscience—something I created going out and killing people all over the damn place,” he said. “I’m not worried about what it does over in Iraq or Afghanistan. That’s fine.” This doesn't sound as though he has really thought this through. Either that or he has a rather nasty definition of "people".
- Afforess 12y agoI hate to be the one to inform you 99% of Americans don't actually care about the middle east.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoThat seems unlikely, given that 73% identify as Christian and not that many of them think Jesus was American.
- aaronem 12y agoThe reading you've given that quote is rather uncharitable, if perhaps heavily implied by the article's author. It's pretty obvious that Baber means he doesn't want his weapon falling into the hands of criminals, but he has no problem selling it to the military, to be put to whatever use they might find for it. Granted, the question remains of whether US foreign policy, inasmuch as it deploys our military, is morally or ethically acceptable to you, but that's a point on which reasonable people can differ, and Baber's opinion on that point appears to differ from yours. If, from that difference, you choose to infer that Baber doesn't consider Afghans or Iraqis "people", that is of course entirely your prerogative.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoI gave two different ways to read it, you chose which one you thought I favoured. That said, he stated he didn't want to sell it to police departments, not the public, who couldn't legally buy it anyway, so I don't see how you think it is obvious that he means criminals when it says police. "Police departments asked for AA-12s, but Baber decided that the gun was too powerful to sell outside the military."
- RadioAndrea 12y ago"On an LCD display behind Baber, I could see an image of my leg, transmitted by a camera under the robot’s gun barrel. The gun then pointed at my stomach. He assured me that it was not loaded." Pointing a firearm an anyone, even unloaded, even (especially?) robot controlled, is a terrible idea. This bothers me to no end, and it's so strange that someone who works with very powerful weapons can act like this. Perhaps he feels that he's smart enough that no mistakes will happen? Perhaps he has confidence in the robot not to fire any rounds? He's a brilliant man, very good at what he does; certainly he's spent lots of time with these things, and understands them more than I ever will. That said: mistakes happen, don't point guns at people you don't want holes in.
- carsongross 12y agoThis guy obviously knows the dictum "never point a firearm at anything unless you intend to destroy it." Apparently writers from the New Yorker fall within that set for him.
- aaronem 12y agoOr maybe he just likes screwing with their heads, and as a fellow Southron well familiar with the oft-condescending ways of Yankees, I don't suppose I can blame him too strongly for that.
- carsongross 12y agoAh, right, I always forget about the "except for people you kinda don't like" clause in the rules of firearms safety.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- crpatino 12y agoOn the other hand, the robot arm might have been carrying an iron rod that just looked like a gun, loaded or otherwise?
- jqm 12y agoWhen the army and police forces get robotic weapons, I can only imagine criminals won't be far behind.
- russell 12y agoThis kind of thing bothers me. I think it makes it easier for the US, or any other government for that matter, to drop a few dozen of these into any kind of local conflict without any debate in Congress or among the public. They are cheap and expendable, no television of troops mobilizing, no flag draped coffins flying home. The operators sit in Lazy Boys at their home bases while the eastern Ukraine (pick your battlefield) is overrun with these things.
- DanBC 12y ago> Armed robots, he believes, could offer crucial assistance in the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan; they could be employed on a street monitored by snipers or sent into a building harboring insurgents. And you hope they don't capture the robot because they then have > the most deadly close-range weapon ever created.