2 ms·
>Many terrible arguments are for things you should do. Many seemingly perfect arguments are in support of horrible things. That mixes up the quality and sophis
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
>Many terrible arguments are for things you should do. Many seemingly perfect arguments are in support of horrible things.
That mixes up the quality and sophistication of the arguers with general validity.
The problem is more that decision-making - especially political and economic decision-making - isn't evidence-based.
The fact that economists and politicians use rhetoric instead of reason suggests that you can't have a workable democracy without evidence-based policy.
I'd go further and suggest that knowingly lying to or misleading the public should be a serious crime punishable by jail time.
Lists like the one in this book aren't enough, because so few people understand there's a problem.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoYou have a lot of explaining to do to yourself. I would start with the question "What is the difference between evidence and conclusions?" Eventually you should move on to the Bayesian/Frequentist definition of Science, but I'd start with the problems with empiricism. Maybe go on to the problems with induction after that. Might want to ask yourself why so many of the most brilliant people in history believed wrong things.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y ago'Epistemology - we've heard of it.' Are you saying that science should never be used to guide policy, because scientific conclusions are always debatable? As it happens they are - for varying values of 'debatable.' When you get a reasonable level of informed consensus - preferably one that has a reasonable chance of being undistorted by commercial interests - the debatability stops being interesting or relevant. The problem isn't that conclusions aren't certain. The problem is that political decision makers believe their personal opinions about policy and outcomes are at least as valid as those of full-time PhD-qualified professional researchers. And voters believe them. Because rhetoric. You don't need to know who Thomas Bayes was to understand how this leads to policy disasters. You don't even need to believe that experts are always right. You just need to understand that they're more likely to be right than an amateur with a sharp suit, a financial sponsor, and a strong opinion.