4 ms·
Trickle down economics have been AFAIK demonstrated to be false. But that will be hard to argue with someone who judging by his HN about section is an Ayn Rand
by adamnemecek 12y ago
Trickle down economics have been AFAIK demonstrated to be false. But that will be hard to argue with someone who judging by his HN about section is an Ayn Rand fan.
- jeffdavis 12y agoUnless you argue that everyone should be taxed 100%, then there is some economically-optimal tax rate schedule. It follows that the current rates might exceed the optimal ones, and therefore a tax reduction may be entirely appropriate. Calling every tax reduction for a higher bracket "trickle down" is simply name-calling. You can say that all the way up to 100%.
- adamnemecek 12y agoNice straw man argument you got there. There is a difference between a tax reduction and a tax reduction with the intent that the tax decrease will propagate to the rest of the society. As in, sure decrease taxes but don't claim that said tax decrease for the wealthiest is in the interest of the poorest.
- megablast 12y agoIt might also follow that a tax increase is appropriate. According to the economic indicators from California, there is some basis for this. Whereas you have not presented anything.
- jeffdavis 12y agoSure, it might. This whole thread is essentially absent of any information (to the extent there is any, it is far below the threshold for making any useful conclusion). I was responding to the implication that a 3% tax reduction is "trickle down" and therefore "demonstrated to be false".
- laughfactory 12y agoIn Economics nothing is ever "demonstrated to be false." There are just various schools of thoughts with their various detractors and supporters. Sure, some of those schools of thought are more popular at one time or another, but none are ever "demonstrated to be false." It is only in politics and news that claims will be made to that effect. There is evidence to support pretty much every school of thought, and evidence to contradict it. Liberals, in particular, like to make this claim--but the jury is still out, and likely will be for...well, ever.
- adamnemecek 12y agoOk, I guess I should have said 'have not been demonstrated to be true'. I'd like to see some recent peer-reviewed study that has shown that trickle down economics does work then. Of course it won't be conclusive.
- javert 12y agoSure, things can be demonstrated to be false. I could make up an economic law or principle right now that would easily be demonstrably false. I do get and agree with your overall point, but let's not throw the baby out with the bath water. There is certainly hope for economics to eventually develop to a better point. > There is evidence to support pretty much every school of thought, and evidence to contradict it. If there were evidence to literally contradict a school of thought, that school of thought is proven wrong. That is not the same as evidence that seems to argue against a school of thought, yet does not do so conclusively.
- javert 12y ago(1) "Trickling down" is not the mechanism by which a growing economy helps everyone, so you're attacking the wrong thing. (2) No credible disproof of Ayn Rand's theories has been offered. (Most serious attempt is Prof. Michael Heumer's and it is a poor attempt.) Why don't you write one?
- dang 12y agoThis comment would be much better with just the first sentence. Please, no personal slights.