11 ms·
> whoever controls the DNS roots effectively controls your certificates This is misleading at best. He who controls the DNS root servers controls absolutely n
by xorcist 12y ago
> whoever controls the DNS roots effectively controls your certificates
This is misleading at best.
He who controls the DNS root servers controls absolutely nothing.
He who controls the DNS root zone could, in theory, re-delegate a whole top domain to a malicious third party and thereby control your domain via this new top domain, thereby get control of your DANE certs.
Don't you think the Internet at large would notice, and immediately route around the problem?
When was the last time you saw an illegitimate top domain transfer? Never, that's when.
- tptacek 12y agoEven if it was true that targeted changes were impossible this would still be a bogus argument. But it isn't true; attacks can be carried out surgically against small targets.
- danyork 12y agoHow? Please explain how an attack can be carried out surgically against small targets from the root?
- xorcist 12y agoPlease elaborate further. You've been alluding to that is a series of comments here. If it's too much for a reply do it in a blog post somewhere. You will find that people take reasonable arguments a lot more seriously.