2 ms·
> in a morbid attempt at fun That's what I'm basing my comment on and what we're discussing. If the OP is wrong is another discussion but I don't see any room
by Kiro 12y ago
> in a morbid attempt at fun
That's what I'm basing my comment on and what we're discussing. If the OP is wrong is another discussion but I don't see any room for interpretation here.
> maybe he was just throwing a rock to see it jump?
Are you seriously saying it's OK to throw rocks at cows?
> should
According to who? My grandfather was a prison governor and a pioneer in treating prisoners humane. Before his time the general thought was to "throw them in a cell with only water and bread". So I definitely know this discussion very well and I still believe the punishment itself could be an end goal.
- jtheory 12y ago> Are you seriously saying it's OK to throw rocks at cows? There's a lot of space between "OK" and "take the boy's eye out with a rock", which is what I'm arguing is the wrong punishment. (No, it's not OK to throw rocks at cows.) >> should > According to who? According to me, of course, for the reasons I (briefly) gave. You're welcome to continue the discussion with your own arguments, and your grandfather's experiences sound interesting.