8 ms·
Don’t Blame Malaysia Airlines
- snitko 12y agoAs a Russian, I'd like to say I'm deeply sorry for the losses of passengers' families. Whoever did this is a complete monster. Many russians do not support any war or aggression against Ukraine and many are convinced, that Russian government is in some way responsible for this tragedy. I personally believe we, as people, will never know the truth as to who did it - was it Ukrainians or the rebels or the Russians. However, this is the direct result of the existence of states and governments. We are taxed to build weapons and go to war for some private and corporate interests we have nothing in common with. Those weapons were built for our money. If each and every person was asked separately "would you like to give us 10% of your income to build these deadly weapons and support the rebels in Ukraine or would you like to keep this money for your family" nobody would give it away voluntarily. Taxation and states are at the root of this evil and it is at moments like these that I can see it as clear as ever.
- Svip 12y agoI agree. The point of a state should only be about who has responsibility for building the roads and such in that area. Why anyone would kill people to have more roads to pave alludes me (actually, I do know why, but their reasons are not resonating with me).
- snitko 12y agoI wasn't gonna go into a discussion here, but I'm tempted to say that not everyone believes states should have any responsibilities, including building roads. The problem is, you cannot have one without the other. If you have states and taxation, they're gonna trick you into paying for things you don't want or need or even object.
- foldr 12y agoI know that hacker news has more-or-less descended into self parody already, but do we have to have yet another subthread on how gub'mints are the root of all evil? It's especially ironic given that this has happened partly as a result of a lack of stable government in the region.
- ufmace 12y agoI'm going to take issue with that taxation and states being the root of evil. They are an inevitable result of the way that we humans are. If anything is evil, it's human nature itself. There are always going to be people who want to form organizations, leadership cabals, and have control over things. Even areas already under the control of a strong Government still have corporations, criminal gangs, and various types of civil organizations, all vying for a little bit of that control pie. Essentially, there will always be some sort of government. It can be a single one that's powerful enough to be unquestionably dominant over anything it chooses to touch, or it can be dozens of little ones, all vying for control over various things in various places. That essentially looks like Somalia or Syria or Libya - total chaos, with constant risk of offending one warlord or another or some gang of bandits, and none of them will make the slightest pretense of listening to you. Avoiding that requires having one government with enough power to squash anybody like that. The best we can get is to have one dominant government, set up in such a way that it has some degree of obligation to listen to the population.
- ekianjo 12y ago> The best we can get is to have one dominant government You think that would resolve everything hey ? Don't you think one dominant government would actually have no incentive to listen to the population and could impose its right by might alone ?
- jahewson 12y agoNot really. Look at China, they have a hugely powerful government, yet even they find it easier to engage in popularism than domination. It's much easier to govern a country which supports you: logically any sustainable government should be interested in maintaining enough popularity that their position will not be undermined: but no more than that. European history is an excellent case study in the fall of dominant rulers who failed to satisfy their subjects.
- zenocon 12y agoWow, if you're looking at the Chinese government as a model for governance... Uniting all world governments into a single state scares the hell out of me, and I think it could very well be the worst idea, but suggesting China as a pattern is the icing on the cake, quite frankly.
- jackweirdy 12y ago> I personally believe we, as people, will never know the truth as to who did it - was it Ukrainians or the rebels or the Russians. I disagree. There's a very promising international investigation being planned, and they have an excellent track record of success.
- vecinu 12y agoI am going to have to disagree with you and point you to certain facts that are coming out of the crash site. People are looting personal items and 'evidence' [1] The rebels are blocking access to the investigation [2] The rebel commander has fired warning shots at investigators [2] Now I ask you again, do you really think they will be successful this time? [1] http://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/heartless-looters-raid-malaysian-airlines-flight-mh17-crash-site-article-1.1872047 http://www.nydailynews.com/news/world/heartless-looters-raid... [2] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/18/mh17-crash-pro-russia-rebels-block-access-ukraine http://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/jul/18/mh17-crash-pro-...
- nokiaman 12y agoI agree and disagree. Tabloids are having a field day with claims of looting and corpses left to rot as a "final insult to the dead". Yet there has been no video of looters stuffing Euros into their pockets, despite the presence of 24/7 camera crews. Meanwhile others reporters are confirming that bodies are being recovered and sent to the morgue. So who is right? Another contradiction are claims that "We have compelling evidence that THEY did it" yet at the same time there are headlines saying "THEY'RE destroying the evidence". So which is it? You either have the evidence or you don't, right? What is reported as "fact" is so often just conjecture, opinion or simply made up, either to support a political narrative or boost ratings. Media reporting should have no bearing on an official investigation, but of course, they will have a huge influence in the court of public opinion. The media are so desperate to get their ratings up, they'll literally let anybody have their say. Look how MSNBC got punked on the day of the crash: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEDH2Z2_6Zw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JEDH2Z2_6Zw
- jackweirdy 12y ago
- andrewljohnson 12y agoI doubt you'd be here using the internet at all if humans didn't cooperate and form governments together. For all the atrocities caused by nations, saying we should all live as anarcho-savages isn't a solution.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoThe advantage of states is they abstract anarchy. Without states, it is man on man. With states, it is state on state. It's at least slightly better.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y ago>I personally believe we, as people, will never know the truth as to who did it - was it Ukrainians or the rebels or the Russians. Is this really disputed? There are people with agendas trying to spin it one way or the other, but given that the rebels initially claimed responsibility for it, and the fact the Russians probably wouldn't make this mistake (it's easy to check if something is a commercial aircraft), it looks almost certain it was the rebels mistaking the airliner for a military plane.
- nokiaman 12y agoPeople thought TWA 800 was hit by a missile but after months of investigative work it was determined not to be the case. So let's keep an open mind. The Ukrainians are not infallible. >After 9 Days, Ukraine Says Its Missile Hit A Russian Jet Earlier today, Ukraine's military had taken responsibility after nine days of increasingly vaporous denials. Seventy-eight people, most of them Russian émigrés to Israel, died when the Siberian Airlines flight from Tel Aviv to Novosibirsk exploded and plunged 35,000 feet into the sea off the Russian coast. Four minutes earlier, a Ukrainian air defense exercise fired two long-range antiaircraft missiles at a drone off the Black Sea's Crimean coast. Russian investigators concluded on Friday that one of the missiles, an S-300, struck the drone, but that the second, an S-200, flew 150 more miles and unleashed a warhead of shrapnel balls at the airliner. / http://www.nytimes.com/2001/10/14/world/after-9-days-ukraine-says-its-missile-hit-a-russian-jet.html http://www.nytimes.com/2001/10/14/world/after-9-days-ukraine...
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoMy mind isn't closed on this one, but the case appears pretty clear-cut to me. While it could have exploded mid air, I seriously doubt it crashing in the war zone was a coincidence.
- myth_drannon 12y agoSurface-to-air missile encountering a large body moving at 900km/h which is fully loaded with fuel will cause the body to completely disintegrate mid air at 10000ft. In this case a ball of fire was clearly seen at the time of the impact and bodies were lying intact on the ground. I'm more and more convinced that it'ss an air-to-air missile, exactly like that Spanish air traffic controller in Kiev was telling that 2 Ukrainian military war planes were tailing that Boeing
- eevilspock 12y ago[damn, i up voted before I got to the end. I'll never do that again.] Taxation also does a lot of positive things. Your logic is filled with false conclusions. What do you propose instead of taxation and states?
- snitko 12y agoThere is no my or someone else's logic. There's logic. If you say it's ok that taxation not only sponsored the development of weapons that killed all those people, but they also provided some good things, then it's exactly equal to saying "my husband beats me sometimes, but he's also a provider for my family, so it's okay and we're working on the beating thing". No. Just no. The alternative is free market and free enterprise, of course. I don't propose it though. I know people are very stubborn with the old ways. My only hope is that we are going to see no-state and free market in some places on earth and when people are going to see it's good, they're gonna copy that.
- MisterMashable 12y agoUnless the plane crash was due to a software bug, this story, however important it is, has no place here. I appreciate your interest and concern but this isn't the right forum.
- josephlord 12y agoRules, safety measures, trade offs and system design interest me. Software isn't the only thing that can be hacked or engineered.
- danso 12y agoHN is just about software "bugs" now? This is a systems bug based on an underestimation of a technical bug, i.e. that flying 1,000 feet over a 32,000 feet restricted altitude was considered "safe" given the hardware used. Such an assumption ended up being wrong. OTOH, the OP makes the point that diverting flights isn't as simply as moving the joystick in a different direction, given the nature of crowded airspace and routes. It's also interesting to note, as the OP does, that flights at lower altitudes were routinely conducted over Afghanistan and Iraq. I actually think the OP is overstating his case though...but I posted it here because I know there are flight enthusiasts who care about the details, such as whether 1,000 ft. above a restricted altitude is not much more reckless than speeding 63 mph over 65. HN will be a sad place if it concerns itself only with bugs in pure logic, and not all the bugs and misunderstandings of details and mechanics that exist outside of software code.
- MisterMashable 12y agoThe point is this has nothing to do with software or anything of interest to Hacker news. Why bother reading HN if it's going to be cluttered with posts and comments that clearly belong elsewhere (Huffingtonpost.com, Disqus, Twitter whatever...) then some sour grapes crybaby who seeks attention voted down your Karma to prove a point. I'll still read HN but some participants are just trollish. I'll never hire or work with anyone with the usernames above because in my world civility and good behavior counts, even with the "little things" like respecting HN guidelines (see below) but it's your life and do what you want with it. Sooner or later you'll put your foot in your mouth in the very worst way and panic all day over your mistake. Hacker News Guidelines https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html What to Submit On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. Off-Topic: Most stories about politics, or crime, or sports, unless they're evidence of some interesting new phenomenon. Videos of pratfalls or disasters, or cute animal pictures. If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic.
- chimeracoder 12y agoMy favorite part, right at the end: > After each crash, disaster or terrorist episode, it is natural to point fingers and say, Why didn’t we foresee that specific threat? Thus one attempted shoe bombing leads to a decade of shoes-off orders in security lines. The truth is that air transportation, like most other modern systems, could not operate if it fortified itself against every conceivable peril. Many people like to use phrases like "one $INCIDENT is one too many". In reality, all of life is about balancing and mitigating risks. Just because a single failure happened in one case doesn't mean the entire system is faulty; given enough time, any system that is not 100% foolproof (that is, all of them) is going to have a failure. The question is whether it is actually feasible and/or reasonable to prevent those.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ufmace 12y agoPersonally, I don't see any reason to blame them for either crash. As far as I can tell, pretty much every airline in the world thought that the corridor they were flying over eastern Ukraine was perfectly safe. That flight just had the bad luck to be there at the time some marginally-competent Ukrainian rebel in charge of a high-end anti-aircraft missile system got a little enthusiastic. Could have been any other flight just as easily. We still don't have any idea what happened to that flight 370, either. I don't think this will help them, though. I sure wouldn't buy any stock in anything connected to them. Even if nothing about either crash was their fault in any reasonable way, people remember stuff like that.
- maaku 12y agoMost airlines were avoiding the eastern Ukraine corridor...
- DenisM 12y agoProof?
- brianglick 12y agoSee: http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/07/17/world/europe/maps-of-the-crash-of-malaysian-airlines-flight-mh17.html http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/07/17/world/europe/m... I don't know if "most" is true, but Air France and British Airways were avoiding it at least, and I recall reading Delta had been as well.
- ufmace 12y agoSee this article: http://www.bbc.com/news/business-28356745 http://www.bbc.com/news/business-28356745 Looks pretty heavily trafficked to me. And a lot of airlines are now saying that they will avoid that area, when they were presumably using it before.
- sghodas 12y agoAccording to the linked article, Air France and some other foreign airlines were the only ones to avoid Ukraine.
- danso 12y agoFWIW, the NYT's news section has a more detailed examination of the politics and technicalities here...and the OP (who is writing in the opinion section)...seems kind of weak: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/19/world/europe/downing-of-plane-exposes-defects-of-flight-precautions-over-ukraine.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/19/world/europe/downing-of-pl... I would've posted this link had I seen it earlier...but it is interesting to see how the OP, a pilot himself, thinks MH17 didn't have much cause to change its route. I mean, the OP even acknowledges that the Malaysian Air pilots would've known about the Ukranian cargo plane that was shot down earlier that day...in the NYT news report linked above, the 32,000-ft-restricted altitude left planes exposed to rockets that could strike at twice that height.
- _delirium 12y agoThanks, this article answers some of the questions that were left in my mind from the op-ed, which I was surprised it hadn't discussed. After reading the op-ed, it was unclear to me if lots of airlines were flying through this space, or if Malaysia Airlines was unique in doing so. The way it was written almost made me suspect he was defending Malaysia Airlines for having made an unusual decision to fly through space that other airlines were more prudently avoiding. But the article you link here mentions that flight traffic above 32,000 feet was not much down from pre-restriction levels, so Malaysia Airlines seems to have been doing what was the norm.
- sidww2 12y agoWhile it's nice to think that airlines can just rely on regulators to tell them which flight paths might be unsafe, the reality is that there's no international regulatory agency governing acceptable flight paths. There's a regulatory agency for every country and while one country might have stringent safety measures, another might not. In such an environment it seems naive for an airlines to not include the safety of the flight path in their calculations. If all civilian flights below 32K feet are forbidden by the Ukrainian authorities, that doesn't automatically mean that flying just 1000 feet above would be safe. Also while other airlines are guilty of flying over war zones too, that doesn't mean Malaysian airlines is not.
- jrockway 12y ago> there's no international regulatory agency governing acceptable flight paths I believe the ICAO is this regulatory agency.
- sidww2 12y agoBut with no legal power of enforcement I'm guessing? I mean an airlines can always choose to follow the directives of agencies from other countries that have more stringent standards. I guess what I'm trying to get at is that there should be definitely increased public pressure on airlines to include flight safety in their calculations. Or atleast not fly over active war zones..
- jrockway 12y agoThe threat model was such that they thought the missiles in that region couldn't hit targets above 32,000 ft. MH17 was flying at 33,000 ft. All rules bodies can do is make rules based on the best available information. Their information was wrong, but it's not like they didn't try.
- tommi 12y agohttps://www.eurocontrol.int https://www.eurocontrol.int There is Eurocontrol which apparently hadn't advised before the incident to avoid the airspace in question.
- philjohn 12y agoInteresting report on the flight path on BBC news yesterday - they showed that most European airlines flew directly over Ukraine ... British Airways however, have been skirting the country entirely, either going North or South depending on available corridors. That could just be the usual British "better safe than sorry" mentality, but I suspect they were perhaps given intelligence that suggested unstable rebels had access to SAMs.
- eps 12y agoThere was an even more interesting report (from the FlightRadar) on the flight path of the plane than was downed. It basically veered off its standard course that was going to the left and under the rebel territory and right over the rebel territory. Couple this with some reports that the plane was escorted by Ukrainian fighter jets at some point and it stops looking as a clear cut "stupid rebel monkey" case. After all Ukraine has much more to gain from this incident if it blamed on rebels/Russians. They also got the US keenly interested in the whole mess, offering a wealth of experience in steering geo-politically important conflicts the "right way", so this could very well be a staged provaction.
- vdaniuk 12y ago>some reports that the plane was escorted by Ukrainian fighter jets I am sure those reports are really credible, right? Care to provide an authoritative source on that?
- huhtenberg 12y agohttp://de.flightaware.com/live/flight/MAS17/history/20140717/1000Z/EHAM/WMKK http://de.flightaware.com/live/flight/MAS17/history/20140717... - click on other dates and keep an eye on the flight path http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/ukraine-traffic-controllers-instructed-mh17-to-fly-lower-mas-says http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/ukraine-t... - they were instructed by Ukrainians to fly at 33,000 ft instead of requested 35,000 ft http://en.itar-tass.com/russia/741248 http://en.itar-tass.com/russia/741248 - the warplane escort. The original tweet was removed, but here's a copy - http://i.imgur.com/8YILn3x.png http://i.imgur.com/8YILn3x.png
- MarkMc 12y agoA rebuttal to this argument is found on the last paragraph of this [1] article: "Malaysian officials said an airline could not be expected to have the intelligence information and other resources to make independent determinations to avoid an area where air traffic controllers were still sending planes. But some carriers had already done just that. China Airlines, the flagship carrier of Taiwan, said that it had avoided flying over all of Ukraine since April 4. Korean Airlines and Asiana Airlines also confirmed that they had not flown planes through Ukrainian airspace since March 3." It also looks like Air France and British Airways avoided Ukraine entirely [2] And even if all airlines had made the mistake of flying over Ukraine, it is absurd to suggest that an airline might not have the "intelligence information and other resources" to make an independent judgement about safety. A single person spending half an hour on the internet would determine that (a) the rebels were shooting down planes using surface-to-air missiles; and (b) there are some surface-to-air missiles that can reach an altitude of 40,000 feet. That is all the information you need to conclude that the area isn't safe for commercial airplanes. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/19/world/europe/downing-of-plane-exposes-defects-of-flight-precautions-over-ukraine.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/19/world/europe/downing-of-pl... [2] http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/07/17/world/europe/maps-of-the-crash-of-malaysian-airlines-flight-mh17.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2014/07/17/world/europe/m...
- konstruktor 12y agoThe people gathering that kind of intelligence are a secretive bunch. As a civilian, you don't "have" that kind of information, you are only provided with it when somebody thinks that's a good idea. If the British, Chinese and Korean services, for example, knew about a big risk for commercial aviation (plausible), why didn't they share it with the entire commercial aviation community? Sounds a bit like they gave that information to their national carriers, together with an NDA. If that is the case, the British services will have to answer some very tough questions (9 British are dead).
- spartango 12y agoWhen you say that national intelligence communities are secretive, you're absolutely right. So much so that they would certainly not share any sort of information with commercial/multinational airlines. It sounds ridiculous, given that lives are at stake, but it is important to consider their calculus (taking the US intel perspective for a moment): Knowledge that rebels had active radar-guided SAMs would be derived from a handful of classified assets, from satellite to radar to drone to people. Adversaries to the US are meant to be unaware of these modalities (to prevent countermeasures), but you can bet they are all in use. The challenge is that disclosure of any facts gleaned from classified systems potentially reveals their capabilities. Now disclosure is a continuous spectrum, from "there is a threat" to "here is a multispectral image of a launcher", so perhaps there is some shareable information. In considering that, you weigh the utility (external risk) of the information shared against its credibility (details), and the potential loss of capability incurred by disclosure. When we say "loss of capability", in this case it may mean disclosing the capability to detect missile launches early, which represents a critical piece of US missile defense. For a historical case study in this type of calculus, it's worth looking into the disclosure of images during the Cuban Missile crisis. There, the US had to provide credible information that there was a threat in Cuba, and did so at the cost of the revelation of U-2 images. By the way, this same calculus played into the US President's wording when he spoke yesterday about the tragedy. Obama was careful to say little about how they knew where the missile came from. Unfortunately, from the perspective of an intelligence agency, NDAs are insufficient to protect classified assets, especially where multinationals are involved. Anything that is disclosed would go through several levels of indirection, and would probably end up in a NOTAM (like the one prohibiting flight under FL320 in the region).
- richardwigley 12y agoThe Guardian has a data blog of the airliners flying over the region. Top 5 fliers were Aeroflot (86), Singapore (75), Ukraine (62), Lufthansa (56), Malaysia (48). Really could have been anyone. http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2014/jul/18/mh17-heathrow-top-departure-point-planes-near-east-ukraine http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2014/jul/18/mh17-he...
- chmars 12y agoInteresting titbit: One of the videos that is supposed to prove that the airliner was shot down by pro Russian rebels is one day older than the incident according to the meta data: https://twitter.com/ofehr_en/status/490039740595707904/photo/1 https://twitter.com/ofehr_en/status/490039740595707904/photo... The truth probably is that a major propaganda war is under way and we simply do not know (maybe never will know) who is directly to blame for the incident.
- nacs 12y agoSeems it's just a problem with Youtube's encoding of dates and times according to this post: http://pax-americana.livejournal.com/660.html http://pax-americana.livejournal.com/660.html
- arjie 12y agoLet's nip this in the bud. That's a Youtube bug [1]. The reddit story [2] has some nice comments. 1: https://gist.github.com/klaufir/d1e694c064322a7fbc15 https://gist.github.com/klaufir/d1e694c064322a7fbc15 2: http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/2b4kpg/conspiracy_and_an_offbyone_error/ http://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/2b4kpg/conspira...
- chmars 12y agoThanks, good to know! :)