3 ms·
No. Not all sites exchange data worth the SSL-layer...let's say, 30-50% of the sites...that means for roughly half a user's non-email/social-networking web-bro
by danso 12y ago
No.
Not all sites exchange data worth the SSL-layer...let's say, 30-50% of the sites...that means for roughly half a user's non-email/social-networking web-browsing, they're going to either be saturated with a warning message that, if psychology research is to believed, is going to be promptly ignored like your apartment's super-sensitive smoke detector or the boy watching out for wolves.
What's the actual reasoning in OP's mind here? That the average web user is someone who, when the computer gives some warning sign that is disconnected from any kind of discernable threat, that the user will automatically take it seriously? That they'll demand to know why they're in danger, and then will rise up and petition the Internet regulatory commission to make all sites do what it takes to make that red icon go away, and the web will be more secure?
I don't want to be overtly negative towards well-intended idealism, but this is such a bizarrely naive viewpoint that it must be openly challenged. That, and it just blithely ignores all the research showing what happens when humans are overloaded with impotent warning signs. This is the kind of idealism-without-consequences that can end up causing more harm than good.
- scrollaway 12y agoThis is not a user-oriented proposal, this is clearly directed at the website owners which are not going to want their users to see red stuff on the URL bar.
- danso 12y agoNot a bad strategy. Until the website owners take the path of least resistance between: A. Reconfiguring their stack to use SSL. B. Putting a Javascript-powered banner helpfully informing all Firefox users that their browser has a security flaw ("that's why that red icon is there") and they should follow the included hyperlinks to install the latest versions of Internet Explorer or Chrome and then delete Firefox from their systems.
- briansmith 12y agoRegarding (B): A few years ago Mozilla did some user research that showed that a significant percentage of people do perceive the passive[1] negative security indicators as indicating a problem with Firefox instead of the web page. Thus, such a change does have to be done carefully. But, I think it is worth trying to find a way to do it that users can understand. [1] Passive indicators are things like the red/broken lock icon. Active indicators the the things that stop the page load, like the "Stop! This is probably a phishing page!" error page. IIRC, users overwhelmingly appreciated the active indicators but tend to misunderstand the passive ones.
- scrollaway 12y agoThat B strategy might have worked a few years back for grandmas that got Firefox installed by their geeky grandson, but Firefox is popular now. And people (geek or no geek) don't like being told the stuff they use is not good. Here's an experiment you can do at home: Try telling an emacs user Vim is better.