8 ms·
The problem here is that it could create a huge loophole. I'd love to be able to write off my donations to open source groups, but so would big companies. Ima
by jedberg 12y ago
The problem here is that it could create a huge loophole. I'd love to be able to write off my donations to open source groups, but so would big companies.
Imagine a situation where a company that develops their software as open source, like reddit for example, setting up a 503(c) and putting all the developers and all the reddit gold revenue into the 503(c), thereby getting a massive write-off for the "donations" and not having to show profit on reddit gold.
Or worse, someone like IBM putting all their consultants into a 503(c) and taking all their consulting revenue as donations.
- sheetjs 12y agorelevant: http://www.cnet.com/news/mozilla-gets-lucky-settles-irs-audit-for-1-5m/ http://www.cnet.com/news/mozilla-gets-lucky-settles-irs-audi...
- DoubleMalt 12y agoAnd you know what: That would be absolutely fine. It would create a huge incentive for companies to develop at least parts of their software as open source. Think of how much reinventions of the wheel we could avoid if run of the mill components for companies would be in the open. The IBM case is unrealistic because IBM would still need to make profits for it's shareholders. If IBM was to transform into a huge non for profit that uses consultants' fees to develop open source software (think of open source Watson), That would definitely a net plus for society that would outweigh the loss of double dutch diminished corporate taxes by several orders of magnitude.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- trhway 12y ago>It would create a huge incentive for companies to develop at least parts of their software as open source. Think of how much reinventions of the wheel we could avoid if run of the mill components for companies would be in the open. one can also imagine that the "open-source non-profit IBM" would have much more troubles trying to enforce its patents thus resulting in even more open innovation and bigger benefit for the society.
- zanny 12y agoHow would it be open source with patent restrictions? I guess they could write their own false foss license that gives them an excemption on it, but it would not be gpl compatible.
- olefoo 12y agoYou are assuming that the patent-holding organization is the same as the open-sourcing organization; they could be legally separate and controlled by the parent corporation. In this case; you would be worried about software that was widely used and had both infringing and non-infringing uses. Especially if the patent-holding org waited for several years before they started enforcing. The software license and patent grants are orthogonal; and while it's not a good look for an organization to give with one hand and take with the other it's certainly a legally plausible strategy.
- malandrew 12y agoIANAL, but I would imagine that in such a situation you may be able to get the case thrown own because you could demonstrate that the licensing organization and the patent-holding organization are related and that the license was not offered in good faith.
- olefoo 12y agoActually you wouldn't be able to show any such thing. The license is a grant of one set of rights ( to use the software, make copies, resell it, incorporate it into products, etc. ) but the Patents would be the enforcement of another set of rights ( to prevent infringement of the protected idea ) the two sets of rights are orthogonal, and although you might have rights to use the software from a copyright licensing perspective; doing so might be an infringement on their patent rights. And those two sets of rights need not inhere in the same organization. Remember when Microsoft was threatening to use it's patent portfolio against any company that used linux...?
- trhway 12y ago
- mhp 12y agoWhile there may be something to your concern, the example you give confuses the idea of how taxes work for companies. Reddit is already getting a "massive write-off" for its developers salaries. It's called a payroll expense and it's directly deducted from any income the corporation makes before calculating it's profit. Formula: Reddit's revenue - all of its expense (including payroll) = profit that it has to pay taxes on. In that same way, corporations that are paying IBM for their consulting services already deduct those payments from their revenue. The payment doesn't need to be a donation. It's a legitimate business expense.
- jedberg 12y agoThe developers are already a write off, but they wouldn't have to count the reddit gold "donations" as income.
- icebraining 12y agoBut then they couldn't actually give the profits to the owners/shareholders, right?
- TylerE 12y agoOfficially? No Unofficially? Look how many "charities" pay their founders/presidents 6-figure salaries.
- nknighthb 12y agoLook at how many companies pay their founders/presidents 8-figure salaries. What's the problem?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- hrjet 12y agoBut then, the founders / presidents would need to pay income-tax on their salaries. The only benefit in this arrangement is that sops given to individuals might be higher than that to companies.
- acjohnson55 12y agoThat sounds fine, as long as developers in the 503(c) aren't making proprietary software. Imagine if your typical software company went this route instead of pursuing software patents. Two birds with one stone!
- mseebach 12y agoAny business expense on developing software for your business is 100% deductible already. Channeling it through a charitable organization would just add complexity, not save any money in taxes. Also, if the arrangement did create some tax savings, your profits would now be stuck in a non-for-profit organization which is probably not what you wanted. > someone like IBM putting all their consultants into a 503(c) and taking all their consulting revenue as donations. If you provide goods and services in exchange for a charitable donation, the value of these must be subtracted from the value of the donations, negating any benefits from that arrangement.