3 ms·
> I think that's a very impoverished definition of "voluntary." Are you suggesting that it's not voluntary if the choice makes the person better off? So is an
by baddox 12y ago
> I think that's a very impoverished definition of "voluntary."
Are you suggesting that it's not voluntary if the choice makes the person better off? So is an action only voluntary if it makes the person worse off? That doesn't make much sense to me.
- rayiner 12y agoI'm saying that decisions made in the face of economic coercion must be scrutinized and potentially voided, not because they don't directly make the individual better off than they would otherwise be, but because they normalize the coercion and make it harder to prevent a race to the bottom in society as a whole. No transaction is entirely between two individuals. Every transaction happens within and creates signals within a larger market.
- baddox 12y ago> I'm saying that decisions made in the face of economic coercion must be scrutinized and potentially voided But if the person's only options are 1) starve to death or 2) become a prostitute, then prohibiting the second option means the person will starve to death. If there's a third option, like 3) work as a cook at a restaurant, then the person can choose between options 2 and 3, and if they choose 2, then it must not have been economic coercion like you suggest.
- rayiner 12y agoEconomic coercion need not mean having only starving to death as the alternative. It can be any situation which a significant differential in economic resources is involved. There's lots of people who can't get a regular job but don't starve to death, for various reasons, but are still in a desperate situation.
- baddox 12y agoI didn't mean to imply that imminent starvation is the only example of a desperate economic situation. I was just using that as an extreme example.
- rayiner 12y agoYou implied that just because someone could be a "cook at a restaurant" means there isn't any economic duress. But that's not true. Thanks to modern demand scheduling, many of these service jobs are both extremely poorly-paying as well as physically unpleasant. Taking advantage of someone in that position is taking advantage of economic duress. Obviously there's no clean line as to how the alternative courses of action have to be before it counts as duress. But we don't have to draw the line clearly in order to be able to make the distinction.
- baddox 12y ago> Taking advantage of someone in that position is taking advantage of economic duress. Obviously there's no clean line as to how the alternative courses of action have to be before it counts as duress. It sounds to me like your distinction is that if any person makes less money than any other person, then the first person is under economic duress and thus is incapable of making any voluntary choices.
- Crito 12y agoIronically, it sounds like he has in essence devised a clever way of stripping poor people of their autonomy.
- baddox 12y agoI don't think there's any dishonesty behind those arguments, but just economic misunderstanding.
- rayiner 12y agoYou're vastly oversimplifying my argument, and reducing complex human interactions to economic platitudes. Sex is not like every other human interaction. If you forced someone to answer phones for eight hours, it is unlikely they would be traumatized in the same way as if you raped them for eight hours. Its different. Not every transaction between people in unequal economic circumstances is suspect, but we're not talking about every transaction. We're talking about something much more intimate and emotional. Such transactions are far more suspicious.
- thaumasiotes 12y ago> [economic coercion] can be any situation which a significant differential in economic resources is involved This is a pretty benighted attitude. Where you're choosing between a comfortable life and a more comfortable life, why does picking the second option indicate coercion?
- heylefty 12y agoAll decisions are made in the face of economic coercion, because every decision is made to cater to one's reward function. What you are saying is absolute nonsense in light of decision theory.