4 ms·
Is this one also vulnerable to people creating fake nodes that "store files" for each other to earn coins for doing nothing?
by wyager 12y ago
Is this one also vulnerable to people creating fake nodes that "store files" for each other to earn coins for doing nothing?
- dutchbrit 12y agoExactly my thought! Seems like a big flaw.
- bdcs 12y agoThe authors address Sybil attacks in the paper. Essentially, there is a PoW style consensus using hashes of files+metadata (as opposed to bitcoin which is hashes of nothing + metadata)
- abc123xyz 12y agowhats to stop the node replying with the hash of the file saying "yes the file is here" when in reality no file is there
- ZitchDog 12y agoHaven't read the paper, but could you ask for a hash of a random offset+byte count of the file?
- slipstream- 12y agoExactly what I was thinking.
- wyager 12y agoThat only works on direct person-to-person systems, not decentralized systems where the entire network has to reach consensus.
- _prometheus 12y agothe proof-of-retrievability. see http://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~hovav/dist/verstore.pdf http://cseweb.ucsd.edu/~hovav/dist/verstore.pdf
- philsnow 12y agoI'm at work and don't want to read either of the papers at the moment, but if A asks B to provide proof of having stored some bytes, could B proxy that request to C and replay the reply to A ?
- justin_ 12y agoAs long as a node you control has the data and can retrieve the file, I don't think there's a problem. If you could proxy the "proof of retrieval" than you could surely proxy the retrieval itself. Pooling resources shouldn't break anything.
- sp332 12y agoBut you could make it look like several computers have copies of the data when there's really only one copy of the data. You would get credit/coins for multiple copies and reduce the redundancy of the files.
- anonymousDan 12y agoI haven't RTFA or any of the papers but couldn't you perhaps add a different nonce to each copy of the file you want stored before encrypting?
- justin_ 12y agoFrom what I read in the paper, it sounds like you _don't_ get paid for providing the data. You get paid for proving you have it when mining a block. Distributing your storage across multiples nodes would simply make it easier to "mine", but wouldn't get coins passively. That is, if I'm understanding the protocol correctly.
- _prometheus 12y agoYou're right that nodes get paid for proving. Though you do also get paid for providing pieces in Get transactions. On outsourceability, Filecoin today makes no effort against it. But see Permacoin for a great (and compatible) solution.
- _prometheus 12y agoNo, files are contributed to the network as a whole, must be distributed, and require payment. See the discussions on mining and on rewards in the paper: http://filecoin.io/filecoin.pdf http://filecoin.io/filecoin.pdf
- JVIDEL 12y agoHey sorry for the OT but shouldn't this be on the new Show section? just saying...
- _prometheus 12y agoWell, it's not something you can TRY yet -- i think those are the guidelines? :)