3 ms·
None of this is peer-to-peer, it's all highly centralized. "Jerk" technology is an indicator of gaps in the definition or enforcement or the law. In the case of
by pessimizer 12y ago
None of this is peer-to-peer, it's all highly centralized. "Jerk" technology is an indicator of gaps in the definition or enforcement or the law. In the case of Uber, there probably should never have been any distinction to the law between taxis that can be hailed and hired cars, for example.
There were no gaps in the law when it came to Monkey Parking.
- wmf 12y agoHence the scare quotes around "sharing economy" or "peer-to-peer". They're creating something that appears to be about people helping each other, but it's actually about a middleman sucking money out of those people.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoIt seems more like the middleman sucking queueing time away from third parties and converting it into money, really.
- pessimizer 12y agoEither way, it seems like a middleman.
- thaumasiotes 12y agoSure, but you say that like it's a bad thing in itself. There's a long, long tradition (thousands of years at least!) of despising middlemen because their products aren't tangible. But they get rich because a connection through a middleman is better than missing the connection in the first place.
- fleitz 12y agoMiddle men are hated by those who see no value in human relationships. Otherwise the value is quite apparent.
- pessimizer 12y agoYou're talking about "middle men", I'm talking about "middleman." These services do not have middlemen, they have a particular middleman. Individual actors who choose middlemen to broker a deal with other individual actors is still peer-to-peer: take real estate for an example, or the stock market. Having to go through Bob in particular is centralization, and I don't think you can infer anything about my belief system when I tell you that if everything has to go through Bob, it's the diametric opposite of peer-to-peer. >Middle men are hated by those who see no value in human relationships. Thanks for thinking you know me.
- pessimizer 12y agoI'm saying it like it's not peer-to-peer, and I'm not saying anything else.
- LanceH 12y agoWith Uber and no distinction by law, do you mean only taxi drivers should be allowed as hired drivers, or that all hired drivers should be allowed to be hailed?
- pessimizer 12y agoI mean that hiring a car in advance and hiring a car spontaneously are pretty much the same thing.
- AndrewDucker 12y agoI disagree. Tourists wandering round Edinburgh (or London) can stick out their arm and be guaranteed someone trained, vetted, and able to give them service at a standard price. Locals can decide they want to take a risk and phone up a hire car company for a non-regulated price without guaranteed training, if they so wish. The former is _totally_ worth it from a reputational point of view, as far as London/Edinburgh council is concerned.
- pessimizer 12y agoWhy would a hired car company be non-regulated, and not have guaranteed training? I know that's the current state, but what's the reason for it? The only reason that I can come up with is that people who privately hire a car are expected to have done more due diligence about the company, therefore are more aware of the risks that they're taking. That is not necessarily true, and may not even be commonly true. I say that raising your hand to hail a car and making a call to hire a car are identical acts, and that it was inevitable that someone would come up with a way to make a call that was as simple as raising your hand. Are those cabs being hired or hailed? Does it matter? Why?
- LanceH 12y agoThere is a lot more for-hire business out there than can be anticipated by the taxi industry. The regulation spoken of regarding the taxi industry is typically the medallion allowing hailed fares. There are typically other regulations which may apply, such as a commercial driver's license and commercial insurance. The latter two would be seen for bus, limo, truck and courier services. It is that group where Uber should fall, if anything, not taxi regulation which also includes regulation limiting the number.