6 ms·
It's really good that some form of craft programming has spread as "not math". But let's not kid ourselves that math isn't programming, and programming isn't ma
by bediger4000 12y ago
It's really good that some form of craft programming has spread as "not math". But let's not kid ourselves that math isn't programming, and programming isn't math.
It's like finding your way from St Louis to Chicago (in the US) or Rheims to Paris, say. You don't need to know that you're navigating on the surface of a spherical body. You just need to know a little map reading, or listen to Google Navigation giving you apparently planar directions and execute them. Just because your journey looks and feels flat does not mean you live on a flat earth.
You can even keep up a flat earth view of the cosmos, but ultimately, you'll end up re-inventing Geocentrism and embellishing cycles with epicycles. And you'll be mystified by how a few wizards can fly non-straight-line routes from New York to London and get there faster than your flat earth "straight line".
I hereby acknowledge, swear or affirm that the previous is an analogy, and therefore can be carried to far for purposes of building a straw man counter argument.
- mamcx 12y agoYeah, but the problem (as you point) is that you can say that navigating is astronomy, or physics or relativity. But you don't call "traveling is relativity!", you call it traveling. Math, (classic) physics and relativity are ways to understand it, sure, even describe it, but what is more true than the other: classic physics, relativity, math?. Here the problem is not about understanding the foundation of things, is about not apply to all the levels in the abstraction the same label. When you walk in the part you are NOT doing math. Your are walking. This is the point expressed in the blog. It have not argued that programming is totally devoid of math, that math can't be used to formally think about it or something like that. Is that is better to think that programing is programing, and like you don't say "programing is relativity" then teach programming using relativity(!) and dismiss programing as a real, whole thing that only can be explained by relativity(!) and tell everyone that to be a good programmer you MUST understand very well relativity. That is what the article is saying.