3 ms·
> I don't understand your equalization of CPCs with value. CPCs are a proxy for value, especially in the Google case. This is because the way advertising works
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
> I don't understand your equalization of CPCs with value.
CPCs are a proxy for value, especially in the Google case. This is because the way advertising works on Google advertisers bid for position, Google runs an auction, and the highest bid wins (at the next to highest price, it was at least when I was there a dutch auction[1]) So when CPCs fall, they do so because the highest bid has fallen, and the advertiser is setting their bids, so if they set them lower then it means they "value" being at the best position lower and thus "value" that ad placement slightly less.
Now flip your point of view around to that of the advertiser, you've got $1M to spend on internet advertising. Every quarter you advertise with different strategies and campaigns and you measure your business. If you are like many you are constantly tweaking that, some print, some radio, some Internet, vary the mix vary the message, these folks A/B test the crap out of this stuff. When you find bidding $5.00 a click gets you the same business activity as bidding $4.90 a click you say "Great, that gives us more money to spend on some other channel!" You have just reduced the CPC that Google sees from you by 2% and you are still getting the results you want.
When CPC is eroding both quarter to quarter and year to year it means that people as spending less money on buying ads from Google on a per ad basis. They may get more total impressions (and this is what I suspect Pichette thinks is the confounding variable in the paradox) but each impression is worth less. And the interesting thing that Marissa Meyer proved at Google early on was that people valued less intrusive advertising over what Altavista and Yahoo where doing at the time. I believe her insights still hold, and if Google continues to add more 'slots' into their properties they are going to erode value (ad blindness). It is a tough spot for them.
[1] New hires back in 2010 got to do a class called 'life of a dollar' which was perhaps the absolute best introduction to how Google monetizes search you could get.
- nyrulez 12y agoOk, I understand the view point. But here are couple of questions to consider: 1. How do you know that CPCs are falling because of existing advertisers paying less vs. new advertisers in new markets/mobile are paying less ? I.e. what evidence suggests that existing high value auctions are depreciating in CPCs/Value ? 2. CPCs are a proxy for value only if they have reached equilibrium. Since it is an auction as you have explained, it takes time for different participants to converge to the right bid configuration. That can take months or years to mature. So if the mobile market is new, how do you know that it has already reached equilibrium ? Desktop CPCs rose for a long time until they established that for many verticals.