3 ms·
Cool! Now tell Comcast you want to download 300GB from my server, which I've got connected on a single 300 baud channel. Will they come give me a free 1GE conne
by MichaelGG 12y ago
Cool! Now tell Comcast you want to download 300GB from my server, which I've got connected on a single 300 baud channel. Will they come give me a free 1GE connection?
- azernik 12y agoNope. Netflix, on the other hand, has paid good money for a very fast and reliable connection all the way to the Level3/Comcast PoP. For yet another analogy in this thread - if your server was instead sitting in a data center with an open 10GE ethernet port or two, right next to a Comcast router, yes, they should just install the extra NICs and wire the things up without for the price of supplies and installation.
- wil421 12y agoIt doesnt work like that because Netflix has already paid level 3 who does most of the heavy lifting. Similar to if you had a 10GE connection at your sever but comcast is still running a 300 baud channel on the connection they have to your server.
- MichaelGG 12y agoOK, so I'll buy a 10G port to another random ISP. And they'll go to the ICX and say "hey Verizon, hit me up with the 10G port". Oh wait, it doesn't work like that. It works with peering arrangements, hmm.
- wil421 12y agoWhy should netflix have to pay for last mile when they already pay their backbone provider, who may own most of the wire? We can come up with any scenario or one off situation but still the problem remains. Should net neutrality go away? And is it fair what Verizon and others are demanding from Netflix/Youtube... Also, who should foot the bill, the backbone providers, the content providers or the last mile providers. You talk of peering arguments yet you dont seem to back them. If netflix is a level 3 customer and level 3 has a peering argument with Verizon, then whats the problem?
- MichaelGG 12y agoL3's peering contract with Verizon requires roughly equal traffic. Maybe that's dumb, shouldn't be the case, unfair to Verizon customers, etc., but that's literally the issue at the moment. L3 did the exact same thing to Cogent before, for the same reasons.