6 ms·
Continued erosion of the CPC number (down 2% Q2Q, 6% y/y) so for those who haven't been following this like I have here are the last fourteen quarters:
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
Continued erosion of the CPC number (down 2% Q2Q, 6% y/y) so for those who haven't been following this like I have here are the last fourteen quarters:
Paid Clicks Cost Per Click Paid Distribution
Q-2-Q Y-A-Q Q-2-Q Y-A-Q In $M
2011Q1 18 4 8 -1 337
2011Q2 18 -2 6 12 355
2011Q3 13 28 -5 5 383
2011Q4 17 34 -8 -8 442
2012Q1 7 39 -6 -12 468
2012Q2 1 42 1 -16 507
2012Q3 6 33 -3 -15 556
2012Q4 9 24 -2 -6 634
2013Q1 3 20 -4 -4 680
2013Q2 4 23 -2 -6 706
2013Q3 8 26 -4 -8 755
2013Q4 13 31 -2 -11 824
2014Q1 1 26 0 -9 845
2014Q2 2 25 -2 -6 893
Cost per click is the money that Google gets per click, it keeps going down suggesting to me that the "value" of this advertising is going down. Paid Clicks are clicks on Google ads which are up impressively but my observation is that there are a lot more of them in places than before. And lastly Google is paying nearly $900M/quarter (that is a 3.6B% annual run rate) to "buy" traffic to their properties. From that I conclude that Google's "specialness" is losing its luster, and that results from other services are "good enough". Doing this same math on Bing results and you will see that Microsoft is capturing the lion share of the value that Google is losing here. (and while Blekko is a search engine, we figured out earlier that you couldn't buy traffic against a competitor willing to spend billions a quarter) The other observation is that this realistically, this can't go on. Eventually Bing will be getting equal CPC with Google, and at that point trying to buy traffic or force the use of a particular browser that will only go to one search engine reliably, will make you less competitive than the more efficient guy down the street. I can't wait :-)
- jedc 12y agoBut CPC erosion is more likely due to higher % of searches from mobile devices. As Google's ads team works furiously to improve mobile ads, this will likely only go up. (Except that right now growth in the sheer number of mobile ads is outpacing the growth in monetization of those ads.)
- ChuckMcM 12y agoAs I mentioned above, they have CPC erosion in both their AdMob numbers and their Sites numbers. This statement though I've heard a couple of times: > (Except that right now growth in the sheer number of > mobile ads is outpacing the growth in monetization > of those ads.) I don't think I understand it. I get that more and more ads are being shown (growth in sheer number) but this part I don't get (outpacing ... monetization). So Google is throwing more and more ads out there, and at some point they are going to discover how to make them more valuable to advertisers so that the advertisers will pay more for them? I get that this isn't like a commodity good which is racing toward zero margin, but I don't see mobile ads getting more valuable. I characterize what we do at Blekko as 'utility search', which is what a lot of mobile users seem to need. When they search on their mobile for a restaurant name you can give them "perfect" search results by returning, the home pages of the restaurant, a onebox with hours/phone/address, a link to a review site, and an advertisement for a coupon at that restaurant or a competitor in the same food pallete. Google gets that, its pretty much the formula they use, but it isn't special because pretty much a solid businesses database, set of navigation links, and an ad feed for restaurants is all you need to serve that up. And other people are willing to give the phone provider a bigger cut of the ad revenue. That is why I'm having a hard time imagining a way that Google is going to pull higher CPCs here. It feels very commodity to me and that is a margin game. As a margin game that 32% net margin which is funding free food, self driving cars, and moonshots comes under pressure.
- nyrulez 12y agoI don't understand your equalization of CPCs with value. They are not the same thing. In the early days, CPCs were low and advertisers were getting good margins. It doesn't mean those clicks were less valuable, just that there was free lunch to be had and it didn't last. Ultimately the cost approaches an equilibrium where it is a balance between what a vertical or the sector is willing to pay and still make money off the traffic. This upper bound usually doesn't change that much per sector/market segment. So I would say, the value from a click doesn't change for the advertiser as long as they are running the same business - nobody can make those clicks MORE valuable for the advertiser just by charging more. Now, if advertisers are getting cheaper clicks with good margins, its a matter of time when the competitive forces drive the margins down to what's acceptable to survive for that segment. This is true for most advertising channels, not just online. This assumes that there is a fixed tolerance for margins for a sector/device combination. Unless all advertisers collude to keep CPCs down for themselves, the cost should reach equilibrium - think about it, why would other competitors not drive up the cost and get MORE traffic, until they reach their margin tolerance? It is a volume vs. margin question. More volume means less margin, and there is an equilibrium to be had. As you have also stated elsewhere, CPCs going down is hard to understand without a distribution of CPCs bucketed by traffic. As volume grows and new markets are penetrated - it could either mean that it is touching more lower margin businesses OR equilibrium has not been yet established for those new markets. But it is hard to conclude that existing high margin businesses are suddenly paying less for those clicks unless their fundamental business properties are changing i.e. lawyers can't make the same money as they used to anymore and hence margins are squeezed. That may or may not be true - but it is not possible to deduce that from what's given.
- ChuckMcM 12y ago> I don't understand your equalization of CPCs with value. CPCs are a proxy for value, especially in the Google case. This is because the way advertising works on Google advertisers bid for position, Google runs an auction, and the highest bid wins (at the next to highest price, it was at least when I was there a dutch auction[1]) So when CPCs fall, they do so because the highest bid has fallen, and the advertiser is setting their bids, so if they set them lower then it means they "value" being at the best position lower and thus "value" that ad placement slightly less. Now flip your point of view around to that of the advertiser, you've got $1M to spend on internet advertising. Every quarter you advertise with different strategies and campaigns and you measure your business. If you are like many you are constantly tweaking that, some print, some radio, some Internet, vary the mix vary the message, these folks A/B test the crap out of this stuff. When you find bidding $5.00 a click gets you the same business activity as bidding $4.90 a click you say "Great, that gives us more money to spend on some other channel!" You have just reduced the CPC that Google sees from you by 2% and you are still getting the results you want. When CPC is eroding both quarter to quarter and year to year it means that people as spending less money on buying ads from Google on a per ad basis. They may get more total impressions (and this is what I suspect Pichette thinks is the confounding variable in the paradox) but each impression is worth less. And the interesting thing that Marissa Meyer proved at Google early on was that people valued less intrusive advertising over what Altavista and Yahoo where doing at the time. I believe her insights still hold, and if Google continues to add more 'slots' into their properties they are going to erode value (ad blindness). It is a tough spot for them. [1] New hires back in 2010 got to do a class called 'life of a dollar' which was perhaps the absolute best introduction to how Google monetizes search you could get.
- nostrademons 12y agoI think you're seeing a Simpson's Paradox effect with those. CPC for both mobile and desktop is going up (my supposition, I don't have numbers on this). However, mobile CPCs are less than desktop CPCs, and the query mix is continuing to shift to mobile. As a result, aggregate CPC goes down. This also explains the Bing results. Google owns mobile search, so the shift toward mobile (with its lower CPCs) disproportionately affects them. Microsoft continues to flounder in mobile, so their average CPC will be higher right until it becomes nonexistent. Strategically, this is a good trend for Google. They're being disrupted, but they own the primary disruptor.
- IBM 12y agoAndroid has a lot of defensive value, but if you're saying having Android makes up for a new normal with lower CPCs then Google shareholders are in for a rough ride.
- Zaheer 12y agoNot just Android, but AdMob. AdMob consistently beats every other mobile ad network I've tried for my apps by a large margin.
- nostrademons 12y agoSo, here's my hypothesis for what's driving the lower CPCs in mobile. This is based on my observations of what I see myself and other people using Google for, not any inside information (I worked in Search, and they generally kept me away from the Ads numbers). People use desktop search to research big-ticket items: cars, vacations, mortgages, life insurance, mesothelioma, consumer electronics, etc. There's a lot of value in a sale there. A personal-injury lawyer may collect hundreds of thousands of dollars from a client with a solid case. As a result, these keywords get bid up really high, because the profit potential of a new customer is high. People currently use mobile search for day-to-day local needs. What restaurant should I go to? Where can I find parking? What's there to do in this town? Most of these have sale prices in the $10-50 range, and so there's just not as much money coming out of the sale. As a result, the keywords don't get bid up as high, and CPC is lower. These use cases are not substitutes. Just because people are searching for restaurants does not mean they aren't also searching for mesothelioma. We see this in the revenue numbers, which continue to rise. But as a percentage of the total addressable market, high-value keywords like insurance and lawsuits will shrink as the market becomes larger. If you're looking at aggregate CPC numbers this will look like Google is becoming less attractive to advertisers, but what's actually happening is that Google is becoming viable for less attractive advertisers. The total market size is expanding, and with that come more marginal customers. This, BTW, is one reason why I think Wall Street analysts are idiots. They pay attention to the wrong metrics, because those are the only numbers they have to pay attention to. I have my own set of metrics that I use to judge when it's time to sell Google stock, but I'm not going to reveal them here.
- jcampbell1 12y agoI heard that Bing recently rolled out a way to just import your Adwords campaign into Bing. That should help a ton, as many of us just don't have the energy to spend on Bing. I thought Google's buying traffic are payments to Mozilla / Apple / Samsung / etc. for being the default search engine. Mozilla's payment is like $300M/year, so I can't figure out how to get to the $3.6B number. Apple may have a much better deal on iOS.
- jaredmck 12y agoAsk.com & AOL are large chunks of change for the "google search network" syndication partners. This is probably most of the $3B+ in traffic buying.
- jcampbell1 12y agoIt has tripled in the past three years, so that seems unlikely given there is no Ask / AOL growth. Maybe it is YouTube payments. There is talk about YouTube Revenue being $3.5B and I assume that started from nothing about three years ago. I assume about 1/2 of YouTube revenue goes to the content creators.
- nostromo 12y agoIt also may just be that they are capturing more of the long tail. High CPC terms, like class action lawsuit ads, have been saturated for years. Now you see ads for low margin and low cost items as well.
- shostack 12y agoThere's obviously a lot of specifics around contribution of mobile to these numbers, and what impact has come from enhanced campaigns causing advertisers to bid on mobile even if they were not intending to. That said, as an experienced paid search professional, lower CPCs are good for me if overall quality remains the same or improves because it lowers my acquisition costs and improves my ROI. This in turn causes me to spend more with Google. Beyond that though is the notion that while CPCs may come down, Google has been pushing hard on the retargeting front. There has been a lot done to try to educate advertisers about the notion of multiple touch points and cross-channel attribution. With this comes paying for net more clicks since additional touch points may increase the conversion rate significantly, and thus might warrant paying for multiple clicks. They still have a ways to go IMHO...for starters, why the heck isn't display data baked into some sort of search funnel-esque report? And why can't I see revenue associated with view-through conversions? AdWords has the data if conversion tracking is setup... Closing the display loop and enabling advertisers to see the actual INCREMENTAL contribution of display impressions and view through conversions is critical to this IMHO.