Theres a common theme in this discussion. We're stuck discussing analogies. Instead, we should be reasoning from "first principles" as Musk suggests. If we do

Theres a common theme in this discussion. We're stuck discussing analogies. Instead, we should be reasoning from "first principles" as Musk suggests. If we do that, we find that physical link speeds of any variety have improved by many many magnitudes over. As this statement suggests, 10GBit is absolute jellybean in the networking world. Yet, last mile bandwidth available to customers has stagnated. Imagine a perfectly paved autobahn, and here we are discussing if we should be able to drive 20 mph on it, and who should pay for the extra damage that will cause to the surface. Incredulous. There are some regulatory systems, where in a goldilockes moment, these basic truths are recognized and acted upon. Consider the EU drastically cutting roaming charges. What was so blatantly obvious that even the senile, crooked decision makers at the EU couldn't miss it? All the providers already roam over the internet, at basically zero cost for both parties if you consider that speeds are limited by the over-the-air interface at either end. Yet they kept charging customers the price for a specially erected microwave link from 1960.