2 ms·
>Trying to apply the logic of sets to geology and geography could result in arguing if a particular rock is in North America or South America or if a particular
by wyager 12y ago
>Trying to apply the logic of sets to geology and geography could result in arguing if a particular rock is in North America or South America or if a particular grain of sand is in the Cambrian or afterwards. These are nonsense arguments.
Only if our definitions of geographical locations are ill-defined.
>Furthermore, when you're discussing reality with humans, you're always doing it through the lens of an imprecisely constructed social model of reality that's been passed down and modified by everyone over time
Maybe we should try our hardest to avoid doing that.
That way, we must explicitly state our axioms re. messy stuff like biology and morality.
- stcredzero 12y agoOnly if our definitions of geographical locations are ill-defined. They are. They were invented by non mathematicians to facilitate communication about objects in the real world through human language -- in a non-mathematical field. we must explicitly state our axioms re. messy stuff like biology and morality. Sounds good, but it's kind of hard to do perfectly. Lots of geniuses have been at least peripherally aware of and have been wrestling with precisely this problem for millennia! But if you have it solved, please blog about it and show us the way! Also, don't be surprised when people start poking holes in what you write.