4 ms·
When ever we read new articles about Sweden vs Assange, we have to keep in mind that the wishes of the two women in the dcase is not represented by any side. T
by belorn 12y ago
When ever we read new articles about Sweden vs Assange, we have to keep in mind that the wishes of the two women in the dcase is not represented by any side.
This does make this case a bit strange. The woman in this case went to the police in order to ask them if it was possible to force a person to take a HIV test. While there she explain how she was half-asleep when Assange initiated un-safe sex, and when she heard about his other sexual partners a few days later she became concerned. When she contacted Assange about a HIV test, he brushed the concept off, which is why she were there at the police station asking them for help.
The result was by all reports (ie news papers), not what she wanted. They charged Assange for rape, which resulted in that she broke of any communication with the police and prosecutor, and refused to sign the written report from the police station.
Now, criminal case do not need that the woman agree with the charges, but it makes for a strange case. It also makes one ask for whose benefit this case is all for. All the men and women who is half-asleep when initiated by sex from a partner they previously that day/night had sex with?
- parfe 12y ago>It also makes one ask for whose benefit this case is all for Other people Assange, or others in society, may want to violate without a condom for his own pleasure at the expense of his partner's well being. >All the men and women who is half-asleep when initiated by sex from a partner they previously that day/night had sex with? As per the accusation, Assange purposely penetrated her without using a condom against her wishes while she slept. Previous sex isn't permission for future sex. And certainly not unprotected sex because he doesn't like condoms but managed to catch her with her guard down.
- rmc 12y agoThis isn't only some funny "sex without a condom" case. He's charged with holding a woman down and having sex with her http://jackofkent.com/2012/09/the-detail-of-the-accusations-against-assange/ http://jackofkent.com/2012/09/the-detail-of-the-accusations-...
- higherpurpose 12y agoThere is no charge.
- parfe 12y agoThere are multiple offenses for which Assange will be charged when he is delivered to Swedish custody. Being pedantic about how Sweden charges suspects will not change the fact that two separate women accused Assange of sexual assaults and Swedish authorities extradited him.
- adityab 12y agoThe two women have not accused Assange of sexual assault. Ever. They merely went to the police and asked if it was possible to pressurize him to submit to STD testing. The accusations of rape are done by an overzealous prosecution office that has hijacked the case later; it seems they have the right to do that. That the office chose to make the accusations augmented by descriptive statements from the two women gives the impression that the two are the accusers. Both (or at least one, supported by the other) have since requested that the issue be dropped. To see the entire arguments of the prosecution and the defense in today's session, read the liveblog[1] by Falkvinge (now ended, of course). [1] http://falkvinge.net/2014/07/16/live-detention-lift-hearings-for-assange-stockholm-district-court/ http://falkvinge.net/2014/07/16/live-detention-lift-hearings... EDIT: Minor nits.
- parfe 12y agoJul 16 18:08 - VERDICT: Julian Assange is to REMAIN in detention in absentia. Just announced. Looks like an overzealous persecutor found himself in front of an overzealous judge. Combined with the English courts agreeing as well that he be extradited. Quite an international conspiracy! Or maybe professionals doing their job can see enough evidence exists supporting the accusation that he raped and assaulted women to bring him before a court for trial. >The two women have not accused Assange of sexual assault. Ever. The two victims described sex crimes for which the Swedish government has chosen to accuse Assange of committing. >They merely went to the police and asked if it was possible to pressurize him to submit to STD testing. If merely walked into a police station and said someone stabbed me with a dirty syringe and I'd really just like to know if he's HIV positive it wouldn't be up to me if the police device to go find him and the prosecutor decides to charge him with assault. Replace dirty syringe with penis. Victims don't get to dictate justice.
- rmc 12y agoIn the 1990s, Micheal Jackson was being investigated for child sexual abuse. He settled out of court with the family of a boy, and they dropped the charges, meaning the case fell apart. California (/USA?) changed the law so that the child/family cannot choose to drop charges like that, and they went after Jackson again. If the victim of a crime can often be pressured/forced into dropping cases, there can be good reasons to prevent the victim from doing it, to ensure justice is done.
- belorn 12y agoIf pressure or force is applied, then yes that would server justice. But this case is not about a woman that got pressured or forced to dislike the case. Her objective, and her statements has so far been very clear on that point. We have to actually admit that a woman can, as a person, disagree with the decision of the prosecutor. A child sexual abuse is distinctly different in that a child is normal not held to be able to make that decision. We assume that either the family or the state will do it for them. I strongly object bunching together women and children as individuals that need to have their decision been made by someone else, as that reeks of old-style sexism.
- notahacker 12y ago> Her objective, and her statements has so far been very clear on that point. Yes. They very clearly made accusations in statements to the police, hired a high-profile lawyer to very aggressively press the case after the initial decision to close it and did not retract the allegations. One of them (the one the Assange defense team claims expressed reluctance to pursue the case in unseen correspondence) got fed up with that lawyer, fired him, and ended up with another one who issued the following very clear statement of her position: My client has the right to her day in court for the rape she's reported to the police and for which Assange is today suspected of. She has the right as a plaintiff to have her case tried in a customary way in accordance with the Swedish judicial system. The rape Assange is suspected of has left deep scars and meant a serious violation of her personal integrity. The violation is especially serious and the psychological symptoms are there every day. Assange's behaviour and prolonging of the preliminary investigation in this case exacerbate the suffering of my client when the preliminary investigation does not move forward. The wait is long and the suffering great. Speculations in the media have been many and directly erroneous. This preliminary investigation is about suspicion of rape for the part concerning my client. There is no form of conspiracy as has been claimed by the media. My client is both a plaintiff and a crime victim just as many others I represent daily in numerous cases. Her rights as a plaintiff shall not be forgotten in the process. [Pro-Assange] source for the statement: http://rixstep.com/1/20130526,00.shtml http://rixstep.com/1/20130526,00.shtml
- rmc 12y ago> "While there she explain how she was half-asleep when Assange initiated" The charge is that she was asleep, not "half-asleep", and woke up when he was penetrating her. "She fell asleep, but was woken up by his penetration of her. She immediately asked if he was wearing anything. He answered to the effect that he was not. She felt it was too late and, as he was already inside her, she let him continue" http://jackofkent.com/2012/09/the-detail-of-the-accusations-against-assange/ http://jackofkent.com/2012/09/the-detail-of-the-accusations-...
- belorn 12y agoThat must have been lost in translation, because the quoted part which got "leaked" to newspapers had the word "half-asleep" in them. The alternative would be that the news papers edited the direct quotes of the woman. I do however find that unlikely. If I have to speculate, I would think that the prosecutor makes no distinction between half-asleep and asleep. It easier just to leave that part to the courts.
- rmc 12y agoThat quote is from the UK high Court judgement. This isn't a journalist with an axe to grind, but a UK high court judge.
- belorn 12y agoI think its high likely that the UK high court judgment is based on the accusations made by the prosecutor, which, like I said previous, might have simply made no distinction between half-asleep and asleep. The distinction is less important when deciding arrest warrant, but still relevant when discussing the charges. If you want to read the quotes: http://nyheter24.se/nyheter/utrikes/525270-advokaten-kvinnorna-ville-hamnas-pa-julian-assange http://nyheter24.se/nyheter/utrikes/525270-advokaten-kvinnor... Alternative, you could locate the leaked document and read the original document itself.