7 ms·
I love it, although one thing bothers me a bit: this whole concept of "my biggest enemies are other teenagers" doesn't just apply to girls, yet the article kind
by vanderZwan 12y ago
I love it, although one thing bothers me a bit: this whole concept of "my biggest enemies are other teenagers" doesn't just apply to girls, yet the article kind of makes it sound like it does. This man must either have forgotten large parts of his own childhood, or have had an unusually carefree one. I mean, yes, the "flavour" of nasty, backstabbing social politics is different accross gender roles and cultures, but it's everywhere.
Having said that, it's a worthy subject to build a game around and hope it will tackle the subject in a proper way.
- sliverstorm 12y agoNo kidding. The implication seems to be that boys play video games with zombies is because the biggest thing boys are afraid of is zombies. Or wild pokemon. Or what have you.
- SkyMarshal 12y agoMaybe zombies are a proxy for sociopathic, unfeeling bully automatons.
- Liesmith 12y agoThey aren't, though. Zombies are vastly inferior in all ways (including destructive potential) to their videogame-playing foes. You shoot them down in their thousands.
- mturmon 12y agoPerhaps (in line with the opening comment) having a formidable foe that activates real fears and buried pain would no longer be amusing. Indeed, perhaps it is concealment and forgetting that we long for by playing video games where thousands of zombies are slain.
- megablast 12y agoIf you compare one zombie to one bully. But if you think that one bully = all the zombies in the game, then it is not so easy to overcome all the zombies.
- slurry 12y agoI think zombies are a proxy for other teenagers. They travel in packs.
- vacri 12y agoNothing of the sort. As already said by Liesmith, you shoot them down in the thousands. In the vast majority of personal combat games, a huge amount of enemies come at you, in an endless procession. Zombies are an easy plot point to explain why so many, and there's no moral question about killing lots of them - no-one is seriously going to write an article complaining about zombie feelings in light of such a game. They're implacable foes that just keep coming, and people don't care as much if the AI is very simple. Why would a human foe just come at me without considering cover? Oh, hang on, it's a zombie, no need to ask the question.
- saraid216 12y agoZombie games build self-esteem. Because the zombies are all the other people in the world, who aren't you. It's a judgement on how we look at others.
- danielweber 12y agoAs the father of only boys, I just took the article to heart without trying to feel excluded. It's not my exact experience, but nothing is.
- oddevan 12y agoAgreed. The article doesn't have to mesh with our own personal experiences in order for us to learn from it.
- shanusmagnus 12y agoThanks for saying that. These days I have kind of a thin skin for the implication, which seems to be increasingly prevalent, that the interests and struggles of boys/men are not only perfectly understood, but are too simplistic and trivial to be concerned with; just give the fuckers enough Red Bulls and handguns and watch them party their way to social media startups! Just don't forget to throw a rasher of half-cooked bacon onto the cage floor from time to time. And so on. Apparently most of the males I've met in my life are incredibly, incredibly dysfunctional.
- Dewie 12y agoA stereotype of a father with only (or many) daughters is that he will grow "soft" towards them and in turn emphasize with their problems, and in turn perhaps also the problems more specific to women in general. A stereotype of a father and a son is that they will both suffer through their own problems, individually, in silence.
- jobu 12y ago> A stereotype of a father and a son is that they will both suffer through their own problems, individually, in silence. The trick for me has been to find things to do with my son. My daughter's will randomly unleash a torrent of emotion to me, but my son only talks when I do things like take him fishing or flying kites.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoYeah, we're really, incredibly dysfunctional. We separate stimulants from depressants, don't like guns too much, and have emotions. Oh, and we only bench-press 2/3 of our body weight (so far... working on it). May macho-God have mercy on our limp-wristed souls.
- Spooky23 12y agoGuys are less subtle -- we're wired to be more attracted to the binary good/bad aspect of things. The male power dynamic is powerful/weak. Girls sweat the details. I think any teacher or person who deals with kids around middle school age would tell you that girls have more sophisticated social constructs and very different ways of undermining each other than boys.
- nilved 12y agoYour comment is sexist and pseudoscientific.
- seunosewa 12y agoIs it incorrect, though?
- acornax 12y agoYes.
- quantized 12y agoNo.
- nilved 12y agoYep.
- ShirtlessRod 12y agoSolid argument, especially after throwing around insults instead of discussing (or refuting) the points brought up in the original comment.
- jeffreyrogers 12y agoIt's neither sexist nor pseudoscientific, but rather well supported by evidence. Just because you wish a fact weren't so doesn't make it any less true.
- anon4 12y agoI'm male and I never was part of any political machinations in high school or college. It's definitely not everywhere. Every behaviour obviously exists in every gender, but playing nasty political machinations at an early age is definitely girls' forte and almost never observed with boys.
- vanderZwan 12y agoYour personal anecdote is not conclusive evidence for the statement in the second sentence, and to inappropiately attempt to counter it with my own: I've been a misfit for the the first two decades of my life, and been on the receiving end of "let's pick on the weirdo to establish dominance and decide our own internal pecking order" far too often to accept that nasty political machinations are "almost never observed with boys" - if anything that just shows you haven't really looked.