3 ms·
> For example, Facebook's facial recognition software now correctly recognizes faces 97.25% of the time. Humans do 97.53%[1]. One could say that is only data,
by paganel 12y ago
> For example, Facebook's facial recognition software now correctly recognizes faces 97.25% of the time. Humans do 97.53%[1].
One could say that is only data, nothing "intelligent" about pattern-matching it.
But I'm biased, I'm a non-believer when it comes to reaching the singularity, as in I don't think we will ever be able to build something that will understand jokes, sexual innuendo or who/which will experience the Madeleine effect (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madeleine_%28cake%29#Literary_reference http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madeleine_%28cake%29#Literary_r...)
- skj 12y agoThe difference between "artificial intelligence" and "automated problem solving" is how much the algorithm designers understand what's going on. Computers will certainly be able to understand jokes or innuendo. At least as well as people do, anyway. As far as the Madeleine effect goes, I'm not sure why you consider that intelligence?
- paganel 12y ago> Computers will certainly be able to understand jokes or innuendo. At least as well as people do, anyway. Serious question, are we close to anywhere on that? I last looked at AI-related stuff around 10 years ago, when "sentiment analysis" as it was then called was only capable of approximating what "good press" and "bad press" meant. > As far as the Madeleine effect goes, I'm not sure why you consider that intelligence? I'm making a generalization in thinking that "intelligence" ultimately means "human intelligence", and I'm also assuming (probably wrong, there's no exact science for it) that things like the "Madeleine effect" sit at the core of us being humans, and the third (and last generalization) in thinking that if you're not experiencing things like the "Madeleine effect" you're not really human-like, so you cannot really be "intelligent". Writers like Asimov and Arthur C. Clarke have written about this problem (what it means to be human when "robots" will come about) way better than I could ever dream of doing, but my favorite presentation of the potential issues when the Singularity will come around remains Stanislaw Lem's "The Cyberiad". Or we could continue focusing on technicalities only and call it a day.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoIntelligent behaviour in humans and other animals shows evidence of wide-scale situational awareness, and independent, unpredictable motivation. Before you use pattern recognition (i.e. pre-defined, remembered, or improvised abstraction for invariants) to solve a problem, you have to understand there's a problem to be solved. ML seems to be doing well at pattern recognition, but that second problem - understanding what needs to be done in a situation, and why, and accurately predicting possible developments and consequences - is possibly more critical for real singularity-style intelligence. It's machine reasoning as opposed to machine learning - in the street-wise sense, not the theorem proving sense.