2 ms·
Hahaha. This is so blatantly stupid. >In order for SocialCoin to work, we need to figure out a way to create a decentralized ID system that doesn’t rely on gov
by wyager 12y ago
Hahaha. This is so blatantly stupid.
>In order for SocialCoin to work, we need to figure out a way to create a decentralized ID system that doesn’t rely on government issuance like a Driver’s License or a Passport. This is currently an unsolved problem.
It's unsolved because it is literally impossible. There is no rigorous mathematical definition of identity, and no way to construct a generic identity-proof algorithm. Even humans can't agree what constitutes an identity, and we've had many millions of years as social animals to evolve heuristics.
Are clones separate people? Are molecular copies separate people? Are brain simulations separate people? If they are, I can just spawn 1,000,000 copies of my brain and collect their SocialCoin. And then it becomes a competition of computing power, just like Bitcoin!
And, of course, there's no non-blinded automated test that can differentiate a human and a machine, neither in theory nor in practice.
The only people who think up foolish schemes like this are those who utterly fail to grasp the genius of solving voting problems with HashCash style proof-of-work mechanisms.
- dllthomas 12y agoI don't think we need to solve the question of molecular copies or brain simulations before considering this. Clones already exist, of course, in the form of identical twins - and I can't imagine us considering them anything but separate people. I totally agree that this can't be done with math alone, but I've not seen any proof that it's "literally impossible" to produce a system where the incentives work out for enough people to play by - and enforce - the rules with the help of math. I've also not seen credible proposals for such a system, I don't know that such system could exist, and I certainly don't know that we will be able to produce such a system any time soon. These are hard problems. But "literally impossible" is a bold claim - far too bold unless you have more to support it than what you wrote above.