4 ms·
How the Other Half Works: an Adventure in the Low Status of Software Engineers
- webmaven 12y agoA fascinating analysis. Anecdotal, of course, as a controlled double-blind test is hard to do for in-person interviews on behalf of a single person, but this presents some interesting possibilities for further research, along the lines of these: http://www.nber.org/digest/sep03/w9873.html http://www.nber.org/digest/sep03/w9873.html http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2012/09/14/1211286109#aff-1 http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2012/09/14/1211286109#aff-... http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/49392/2/MPRA_paper_49392.pdf http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/49392/2/MPRA_paper_49392.pdf
- x0x0 12y agoThis is bloody depressing to read, and rings true in my experience. One of my pet peeves is relocation costs. Companies in nyc try to hire me at least every six months, particularly since I used to live there. You can tell who is an asshole by asking about relo packages. If they start at $5k my wanker detector goes off. Assholes offer maybe up to $10k, often as a hiring bonus, so it's taxed; maybe $6k might land in my checking account. That's a joke for a mid-30s data scientist. A trip to nyc for me plus partner to shop for apartments alone is $2.5k (2 airline tickets, taxis, meals, boarding a dog, 3 nights in manhattan hotels). Then the costs of apartment rental, job search for partner, winding down an apartment lease here, selling a car, and moving a grown up apartment -- ie I own a real bed and dressers and a couch and a table -- across the country. A relocation would cost me on the order of $15-$20k after taxes. Yet ceos whine endlessly about the lack of good employees. You never see them in a bwm dealership bitching they won't sell a 5-series for $30k though.
- virtue3 12y agoWhat? You don't love the 6month contract offers to relocate to 3 states away even though you're current employed? :/
- yuhong 12y agoMichaelochurch has another blog post about exactly this.
- greenyoda 12y agoIt's called "Never relocate unpaid", and I posted it on HN a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8003073 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8003073
- michaelochurch 12y agoI've had a number of offers die on relocation. It's a surprisingly high percentage. In addition to the shitty DIY lump sum packages that never cover more than a fraction of the expenses, you see the shitty clawbacks. It's nuts. I feel like being a programmer is like being an 18-year-old girl on a college campus: so easy to get activity, but so hard to get respect. Relocation is a great filter against activity-without-respect jobs.
- hcho 12y agoMaybe there's a much less sinister reason for companies shying away from relocation. We had a few applicants that we were willing to offer relocation and all of them flipped at the last moment. They all said their significant others had a change of heart. I suspect the changes a relocation will bring, hits home really late. Once bitten twice shy; I am not considering people who are not in my geographical area anymore.
- forgottenpass 12y agoYou have provided a reason for not offering relocation. Not an explanation for offering a bad relocation deal. You and OP are talking about very different things. If that was the case, why would you extend a job offer with a bad relocation deal rather than not offering the job at all? Are you hoping the applicant sees how bad your deal is and turns you down? Why wouldn't you just not make the offer?
- incision 12y agoAs I move further and further beyond 30 I encounter the assumption or at least question as to whether I am or am aiming to be a manager more and more often. I've actually been thinking about whether I should try and remake myself in the same way for the same sort of reasons related. For instance, bits like this... >'...praise for doing things that would just have been doing his job if he were a managed person.' ...and... >'It’s far better, unless you’re applying for a junior position, to start at 70 and get credit for everything you do know, than to start at 90 (or even 100) and get debited for the things you don’t know.' Read as pure truth in my experience. Coming off a period where my final title was 'Program Manager' my technical credentials seemed to be treated as gospel and an incredible bonus. Later, with a purely technical 'Engineer' title and no less responsibility those same credentials are heavily scrutinized and interviewers seem puzzled by an inability to fully categorize my experience. I've come to think there's a lot to be said for and gained by properly managing titles / signals of status and managing the sort of interactions that are easy to dismiss or deride as 'playing the game'.
- badman_ting 12y ago> Instead of being a programmer auditioning to sling code, he was already “part of the club” (management) and just engaging in a two-way discussion, as equals, on whether he was going to join that particular section of the club. Hmm! The latter is typically how I approach interviews (I'm a developer). I feel that if that's not the case then why am I here? Sometimes you get people that are smart in a dumb way, like the last interview in the story here. Just looking to be intellectually dominant, the "winner". But you just have to recognize those situations for what they are and not get discouraged. Developers are in demand, we get to act like it. And sometimes people get treated like shit because they allow it to happen.
- dwd 12y agoMost programmers seem to avoid conflict at all costs, which is a bad trait in a corporate environment. But you can minimise the discomfort by standing your ground at the right times. The best time is when accepting the employment offer and not signing anything that will put you in a position of having to stand your ground against shitty conditions later. Things like non-compete clauses (and relinquishing all IP rights), no side projects (because you have to be 110% for the job) or mandatory overtime with inadequate or no compensation shouldn't be accepted as-is. Otherwise you will have zero status because you signed it away at the start.
- PeterisP 12y agoConflict avoidance is pretty much always a losing strategy and a very bad habit. It makes you less efficient in a company (as flawed decisions aren't challenged until to late), but more importantly, it makes you vulnerable and ensures that you often get unreasonably bad deals. It can be fixed, as almost everything else, it's a trainable skill/habit.
- dwd 12y agoIt's a better skill to be teaching our children than simple conformity to authority that seems to be core to school curriculum.