5 ms·
Let me repeat it again. Authentication is OK. DRM is not. If you don't get the difference, let's explain. Authentication is simply ensuring that you are you. No
by shmerl 12y ago
Let me repeat it again. Authentication is OK. DRM is not. If you don't get the difference, let's explain. Authentication is simply ensuring that you are you. Normal security mechanism, nothing wrong with it.
DRM can employ authentication in itself, sure. But DRM is not about ensuring that you are you. DRM is about limiting what you can do with your own system in various ways and / or spying on you (even when it already knows that you are you). Simply because DRM is preemptive policing.
I have no problem with authentication, same way I have no problems with you using a lock on your door (normal security). I have problems with DRM, same way I'd have problems with police putting their camera in someone's house (overreaching preemptive policing).
Hopefully this makes it more clear. I often see people confuse DRM with merely security / authentication / encryption etc. That's plain wrong.
> The key is to realize that DRM as practiced by corporations is evil and unworkable because the economics were utterly unrealistic.
No. It's evil because it's using police state methodology of treating everyone as potential criminal and employing presumption of guilt, which results in overreaching policing measures which violate one's privacy and security.
- moheeb 12y ago"It's evil because it's using police state methodology of treating everyone as potential criminal and employing presumption of guilt" Isn't that what you're doing when you lock your doors though?
- shmerl 12y ago> Isn't that what you're doing when you lock your doors though? No. You lock your doors to protect your house from external threats. Here it's completely reversed. DRM invades your private digital space (your computer, your system, the programs you run etc.) for the sake of policing you. I.e. it's not like a lock on your house doors. It's like a police camera placed inside your house. That's exactly what makes it overreaching and unacceptable. Policing itself is a not an evil idea in general. But it's evil when it's overreaching. Saying - "let's prevent crime" is OK. Saying "let's place police cameras in everyone's house to prevent crime" is not OK.
- moheeb 12y agoThe previous poster is talking about personal DRM. You keep misunderstanding what they are saying. In the personal DRM case it would not be invading "your private digital space", you would be using it to protect your digital space. It is not like "a police camera placed inside your house." It is the equivalent of the homeowner placing a security camera themselves to protect their property.
- shmerl 12y agoThere is no such thing as "personal DRM". That's what you and the previous poster fail to understand. DRM is always about policing others by invading their digital space. Protecting your own digital space is called security. Let's be clear on terms usage, otherwise time will be wasted because of misunderstanding.
- stcredzero 12y agoNo. You fail to understand that DRM as practiced by Sony et al is just one application. In one way, it's understandable if you had not been exposed to the academic literature early enough, because after a certain point, political activism, popular accounts, and corporate literature swamp anything more academic and general. DRM is always about policing others by invading their digital space. Or about voluntarily giving some autonomy up. In the case of organizations like Facebook, they would be giving up autonomy, such that they would only run certain audited versions of certain software. Given that such companies have large numbers of computers aggregated in a relatively small number of locations, the economics of verifying these mechanisms is much more favorable than the inadvisable "traditional" use of DRM has been. You are not going to be able to process ideas like this properly, if your only background is uneducated Internet backlash. Protecting your own digital space is called security. Let's be clear on terms usage, otherwise time will be wasted because of misunderstanding. Throughout, you have been insistent on an imprecise, popularized usage of terms. I will agree, however, that time has been wasted because of misunderstanding.
- deleted 12y ago
- stcredzero 12y agoLet me repeat it again. Authentication is OK. DRM is not. If you don't get the difference, let's explain. Let me explain AGAIN -- I'm not talking about such a system running on your machine. I'm talking about such mechanisms running in Facebook's, Apple's, Google's, and the NSA's server farms. It's about 4 messages into this thread. Please get a clue.
- shmerl 12y ago> I'm talking about such mechanisms running in Facebook's, Apple's, Google's, and the NSA's server farms. Which is? Security threat for them (same as DRM which runs on your machine is a security threat for you). It doesn't sound sensible.