3 ms·
Evidently you either simply didn't read or understand my proposal, and you mistakenly believe I am writing in support of corporations using DRM against individu
by stcredzero 12y ago
Evidently you either simply didn't read or understand my proposal, and you mistakenly believe I am writing in support of corporations using DRM against individuals. That is the complete opposite of the truth.
What is fundamentally broken is the idea of overreaching preemptive policing (DRM).
The record clearly shows that applied to individuals, DRM becomes "fundamentally broken overreaching preemptive policing."
The same record clearly shows that turned around 180 degrees, DRM is entirely appropriate. What's broken for protecting a single piece of information the whole Internet wants becomes viable for protecting information chiefly valuable to the individual. DRM applied in reverse against corporations is "economically viable historically supported policing."
- shmerl 12y agoI think you simply use the term DRM incorrectly. You think DRM means information security. It doesn't. "Turning it around" makes it not DRM anymore.
- stcredzero 12y ago"Digital Rights Management" -- you know, words mean something. If it's digital, and it's used to manage rights to that digital information, then it applies. Also, if you had a clue to the academic and research origins of DRM, you'd know it's also "trusted execution." DRM as you are aware of it in the hands of Sony et al is just one single application of DRM/trusted execution. Just like HTML is just one application of the more general SGML or the abstract notion of markup languages in general. I think you simply use the term DRM incorrectly. You think DRM means information security. It doesn't. "Turning it around" makes it not DRM anymore. I think I've made the mistake of discussing while assuming the wrong level of information background amongst the participants.
- shmerl 12y ago> "Digital Rights Management" -- you know, words mean something. They mean what they were designed for. And that is excessive preemptive policing. About "trusted execution" you are wrong. Original meaning of trusted execution is exactly about security, not about DRM. Actual usage of that term is more than often happens to be about DRM (which is conflicting with security actually, because DRM can be viewed as a security risk). See https://youtube.com/watch?v=XgFbqSYdNK4 https://youtube.com/watch?v=XgFbqSYdNK4 If you constantly mix up security, authentication, trusted execution with DRM, I think you should consider your own level of knowing what you are talking about. I explained everything above.