4 ms·
The actual work must demonstrate creativity, and a mechanically generated works of this sort do not. The law here lags behind the technology. By procedurally g
by stcredzero 12y ago
The actual work must demonstrate creativity, and a mechanically generated works of this sort do not.
The law here lags behind the technology. By procedurally generating something like a landscape, a programmer can creatively define a whole set of possible landscapes. It's fallacious to say that this can't involve artistic awareness and creativity. Here, the law is trying to apply 19th century models to 21st century media.
- ars 12y agoThe program used to generated the landscapes is copyrightable, the landscapes themself are not. > It's fallacious to say that this can't involve artistic awareness and creativity. Here, the law is trying to apply 19th century models to 21st century media. A problem with copyrighting mechanically generated works is there is no end to them. What awareness and creativity is shown by letting a computer make 1 million slightly different images? All the creativity is in the programming, not in the result.
- stcredzero 12y agoThe program used to generated the landscapes is copyrightable, the landscapes themself are not. But this is problematic. Procedurally generated landscapes can still have a definite "feel" or "look." These attributes can be protected as "trade dress." But there is no way to preclude other attributes we haven't thought of yet. A problem with copyrighting mechanically generated works is there is no end to them. What awareness and creativity is shown by letting a computer make 1 million slightly different images? Yes, you're right, there are algorithms that actually don't show much creativity. But this is actually already covered in the "Threshold of creativity" laws -- if the declaration that the output of an algorithms cannot be protected is removed. If you apply most of the same "Threshold of creativity" laws to a notion of meta-creativity, you still arrive at a usable and coherent law. All the creativity is in the programming, not in the result. Clearly, the truth is that creativity can manifest in the result. Also understand that modern technology makes the current formulation of the law problematic. What if I simply used cheap data storage to slurp the output of a program so that I could use the output of someone's copyrighted code without permission? I could imagine doing this to a procedurally generated MMO world. This would seem to make the practical effect of the law quite divergent from its intended effect. Introduce a notion of algorithmic meta-creativity, and the law would protect against that kind of infringement nicely. That said, in many cases, it would be advisable for the copyright holder to not reserve copyrights for such media. But in that case, I think the providing the option is the wiser choice.
- ars 12y ago> These attributes can be protected as "trade dress." That's trademark, not copyright. If you carefully tuned your program to create a single result you found best that might be copyrightable. On the other hand if you wrote a generic program that randomly adjusts the variables to make lots of nice looking landscapes then the landscapes are not copyrightable, even if you did a great job on the program so all the results were beautiful. > Clearly, the truth is that creativity can manifest in the result. That doesn't make it copyrightable. I could plant trees in a beautiful pattern, but I can not claim copyright on photographs taken of the result. > What if I simply used cheap data storage to slurp the output of a program so that I could use the output of someone's copyrighted code without permission? Not following. Does "cheap data storage" make a difference? How are you "slurping" the output? What sort of program is it? > I could imagine doing this to a procedurally generated MMO world. This would seem to make the practical effect of the law quite divergent from its intended effect. And what's the problem? The procedurally generated MMO world is not copyrightable. That's the intended effect - to only copyright what a person actually does. You might be able to claim a dress trademark on the MMO world if it was distinct, but not copyright.
- stcredzero 12y agoThat's trademark, not copyright. I never said it was copyright. Please readjust your mental model of who you're speaking to accordingly. If you carefully tuned your program to create a single result you found best that might be copyrightable. How is this different than carefully tuning your program to create a range of results with specific attributes? Example: All of the generated landscapes are aesthetically pleasing, but have enough open area next to obstacles to enable ambushes and also manage to look creepy at night... Such a result might indeed take That doesn't make it copyrightable. I'm saying that it should. IP laws date from a time where the kind of automation that makes the above possible was unthinkable. The assumption that an act of creation would result in a particular set of data is no longer warranted. Neither is the assumption that the automatic production of art is either not possible or would result in uninteresting and stereotypical output. Not following. Does "cheap data storage" make a difference? How are you "slurping" the output? What sort of program is it? Specifics aren't needed, but "cheap data storage" makes it possible to store the entire content of certain procedurally generated algorithms from earlier computer systems as files of ordinary size on today's typical machines. (Example: The entire Elite universe.) And what's the problem? The procedurally generated MMO world is not copyrightable. That's the intended effect - to only copyright what a person actually does. I'm saying that this very notion dates from a time when procedurally generated output was unimaginable to most people, and that to only copyright what a person actually does is trying to apply 19th century notions to 21st century technology. It's just like the early 20th century arguments for airlines having to pay farmers to overfly their land.