3 ms·
The evidence shows that DRM in the service of corporations and businesses tends to be nasty. But there are reasons to believe that DRM, if used to protect the d
by stcredzero 12y ago
The evidence shows that DRM in the service of corporations and businesses tends to be nasty. But there are reasons to believe that DRM, if used to protect the data and privacy of individuals would be very valuable, with the caveat that it would have to be implemented in a trustworthy way.
What if there was a way to provide access to your medical records to people who need them, only for as long as they need them? What if even the provider of the service couldn't easily circumvent this?
- shmerl 12y ago> But there are reasons to believe that DRM, if used to protect the data and privacy of individuals would be very valuable, with the caveat that it would have to be implemented in a trustworthy way. DRM can not be trustworthy by its mere definition (because trust is a mutual thing, and those who deploy DRM don't trust you - the user. So you have every reason not to trust them in return). And it never can be valuable since it's not only unethical and insulting towards users (since it uses presumption of guilt and police state ideas), but it's also completely ineffective and all it does is punishing paying customers, while the vast majority of actual pirates don't deal with it. DRM should just die out for good. > What if there was a way to provide access to your medical records to people who need them, only for as long as they need them? Authentication and information security has nothing to do with DRM, even though both can have features like encryption. Let's not mix unrelated subjects.
- stcredzero 12y agotl;dr - Let's please think about the economics! Let's not just believe emotionally charged Internet aphorisms, but examine things thoughtfully. Authentication and information security has nothing to do with DRM, even though both can have features like encryption. Let's not mix unrelated subjects. What is the limiting of who can have my personal data and when, but Digital Rights Management, or DRM? One cannot stop at authentication, because to be complete, one has to prevent copying data. Without this, it becomes problematic to trace who has released information, and without some legal support, nothing at all is practical. DRM can not be trustworthy by its mere definition Sorry, but this is fluff. You could apply this "logic" to authentication as well. DRM has to involve some mutual trust and cooperation to the same extent that any protocol involves mutual trust and cooperation. The key is to realize that DRM as practiced by corporations is evil and unworkable because the economics were utterly unrealistic. Really, where DRM could help individuals would be the elimination of trivial deniability on the part of corporations. Right now, when your data privacy is breached, there is no cost to "break" anything and it's very hard to pin this on a particular corporation. Add a DRM mechanism, and then there is something tangible to apply protection laws to and a labor cost with definite intent to breach an individual's privacy. In aggregate, the cost and potential legal liability becomes too high to for virtually any corporation to contemplate. We would arrive at a situation where corporations could afford to violate the privacy of a few select individuals, but could no longer do so to the public wholesale. Ordinary citizens would enjoy a measure of protection, though rich individuals and corporations would not. Sounds pretty good to me. Underlying everything, I'm not so much advocating DRM, as I'm calling to question emotionally charged "magical thinking" combined with naive induction. Let's not just leave things at "DRM is bad" devoid of real examination of what's happening. EDIT: It also occurs to me that the historical factual differences between individuals and corporations should be used to modify the current formulation of "legal persons." "Legal Persons" should be considered as "persons" only in terms of a few specific factors, like the owning of property. The historical difference between actual and legal persons with regards to data privacy abuses would be an important corpus of information in support of this.
- shmerl 12y agoLet me repeat it again. Authentication is OK. DRM is not. If you don't get the difference, let's explain. Authentication is simply ensuring that you are you. Normal security mechanism, nothing wrong with it. DRM can employ authentication in itself, sure. But DRM is not about ensuring that you are you. DRM is about limiting what you can do with your own system in various ways and / or spying on you (even when it already knows that you are you). Simply because DRM is preemptive policing. I have no problem with authentication, same way I have no problems with you using a lock on your door (normal security). I have problems with DRM, same way I'd have problems with police putting their camera in someone's house (overreaching preemptive policing). Hopefully this makes it more clear. I often see people confuse DRM with merely security / authentication / encryption etc. That's plain wrong. > The key is to realize that DRM as practiced by corporations is evil and unworkable because the economics were utterly unrealistic. No. It's evil because it's using police state methodology of treating everyone as potential criminal and employing presumption of guilt, which results in overreaching policing measures which violate one's privacy and security.
- moheeb 12y ago"It's evil because it's using police state methodology of treating everyone as potential criminal and employing presumption of guilt" Isn't that what you're doing when you lock your doors though?
- shmerl 12y ago> Isn't that what you're doing when you lock your doors though? No. You lock your doors to protect your house from external threats. Here it's completely reversed. DRM invades your private digital space (your computer, your system, the programs you run etc.) for the sake of policing you. I.e. it's not like a lock on your house doors. It's like a police camera placed inside your house. That's exactly what makes it overreaching and unacceptable. Policing itself is a not an evil idea in general. But it's evil when it's overreaching. Saying - "let's prevent crime" is OK. Saying "let's place police cameras in everyone's house to prevent crime" is not OK.
- wavefunction 12y agoThat's the same pie-in-the-sky "what if" that loser corps have been pursuing forever. Whatever scheme they come up with, someone else breaks it shortly thereafter, whether it's DiVX, or DVD encryption, or BluRay encryption, or any of that silly bs.
- stcredzero 12y agoThat's the same pie-in-the-sky "what if" that loser corps have been pursuing forever. 1) That's the same kind of half-baked wishful thinking that's been going around the Internet since before the web. 2) I'm not advocating doing what loser corps have been pursuing. I'm advocating flipping the economics around 180 degrees. someone else breaks it shortly thereafter, whether it's DiVX, or DVD encryption, or BluRay encryption It's wishful thinking to ascribe magical powers to anything, even hacking over the vast labor pool of the Internet. Modern content encryption based on VMs gets broken but takes labor to break, and only works as well as it does for mass-distributed media because enough people care about it. (I'm not talking about DVD encryption and earlier. Keeping a single symmetric key secret is fundamentally broken.) Flip around the economics, so equally powerful protections are applied to data only a few people care about, and the addition of a little legal support would be enough to form an effective deterrent. It is fundamentally broken -- for corporate mass distribution. But that's not the only thing it can be used for.
- shmerl 12y ago> It is fundamentally broken What is fundamentally broken is the idea of overreaching preemptive policing (DRM). I.e. the one expressed by Sony execs in the past: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_rootkit#Background https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_rootkit#Background > "The industry will take whatever steps it needs to protect itself and protect its revenue streams... It will not lose that revenue stream, no matter what... Sony is going to take aggressive steps to stop this. We will develop technology that transcends the individual user. We will firewall Napster at source - we will block it at your cable company. We will block it at your phone company. We will block it at your ISP. We will firewall it at your PC... These strategies are being aggressively pursued because there is simply too much at stake." It's as broken and crooked as it gets.