9 ms·
Is anyone surprised that so many of those are payed services instead of OSS projects? I understand payroll, analytics and others like such. But things like bug
by rdtsc 12y ago
Is anyone surprised that so many of those are payed services instead of OSS projects?
I understand payroll, analytics and others like such. But things like bug trackers, dashboards, CIs, exception handling, log monitoring. At some level maybe it is a bit like selling shovels during a gold rush. Find what most start-ups need and monetize that. The gold prospector has a high chance of going home empty-handed, but he will surely need a shovel to even start digging.
- cwyers 12y agoThe post that inspired it: "When I first started delicious, we had to host most of the services ourselves. CVS, mail, mailing lists, etc etc etc. These days, lots of that stuff is available as SaaS. What are the tools and services people use instead of hosting their own?" If you want to do self-hosting, there's open source available for pretty much every category. That's not what this list is for, though.
- voltagex_ 12y agoWill you reject pulls adding open source tools?
- cwyers 12y agoNot my repo, so I can't speak to that, all I did was quote from the doc to emphasis what it said.
- rmc 12y agoNot my repo, but there are some open source tools there. Under load testing it has Bees with Machine Guns ( https://github.com/newsapps/beeswithmachineguns https://github.com/newsapps/beeswithmachineguns ), which is MIT licence.
- alexatkeplar 12y agoSnowplow is in there and we are Apache 2.0 :-)
- EvaK_de 12y agoJust submitted a pull request for Collabtive (pm tool): it's both available for self-hosting (FOSS) or reasonably-priced SAAS. We'll see if the request is accepted. :)
- toomuchtodo 12y ago> Is anyone surprised that so many of those are payed services instead of OSS projects? No. Developer time is expensive, whether you're contracting it out or you're paying for it amortized over salary/benefits/etc. If its going to take more than 4-8 hours to setup and/or more than 1-2/hours a month to maintain, I'd rather get a credit card out and just pay for it. Do what you're best at, outsource everything else.
- jiggy2011 12y agoI'd rather use an OSS solution but pay someone else to host and maintain it, that way if they shut down or whatever I can just copy my data and worst case run it myself.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoDoes it need to be an OSS solution as long as the data can be exported at will into a standards compliant format?
- jiggy2011 12y agoYes, because I want to keep the same software and feature set if at all possible.
- rmc 12y ago"Standards compliant format" can be misleading. Sure, an app might give you a zip file of CSV files (which is as 'standard' and 'humanily readable' as you can get), but that doesn't mean you'll be able to import it into another tool/software. The data model could be completly different.
- eli 12y agoGood point... but likewise: just because an app is OSS doesn't mean it's data is portable.
- 12y ago
- patio11 12y agoWorth noting: developer tools companies don't sell primarily to startups, who represent a tiny, tiny, tiny, tiny fraction of the software developer market, frequently are averse to spending meaningful amounts of money, and have business turnover which is higher than the churn rates for many of these tools.
- raymondh 12y ago* Paid services advertise. OSS projects generally don't. * Paid services usually have customer support. OSS projects generally don't. * Paid services have nice on-ramping videos and nice installers. OSS projects have config files, install procedures, tutorials, scattered blog posts, FAQs, mail lists, etc. * In the end, it is all about how much work you're going to do yourself. You can't do it all.
- gioele 12y ago> * In the end, it is all about how much work you're going to do yourself. You can't do it all. In my perfect I would pay for services that take care of setting up FLOSS projects and looking after the daily problems (network, storage, updates, configuration). The code is still free and libre, the people (and their experience) well paid.
- TallGuyShort 12y agoI believe this gets at the core of RMS' goal. I don't believe I've ever heard him say he's against people charging money for services, but even if he had, his point is that non-free software is inherently defective. I would also pay money for many of these services, but once I've paid I want the software to answer completely to me - don't hold it hostage.
- sbarre 12y agoThis is a super important point. My group (the digital services division of a very large advertising agency) pays for Basecamp (pm tool) and Sifter (simple issue tracking) because the features and monthly price were better value than configuring and installing OSS tools, not to mention all the non-technical users who were already familiar with them and wouldn't require training on something they'd never seen before. However, we use Gitlab for our DVCS (kind of surprised that's not on the list!) because that was a) very easy to install and b) better value compared to paid offerings, based on our usage. Also it's for the developers only, so ramp-up is less of an issue even though none of us had used it before. So yeah for a lot of companies it's just about value for money. OSS is certainly free to download but the resource costs for installing/operating/training/supporting are not.
- jsmthrowaway 12y ago> At some level maybe it is a bit like selling shovels during a gold rush. Many would call that a "wise business."
- numo16 12y ago> Is anyone surprised that so many of those are payed services instead of OSS projects? Not surprised, as developer time is expensive. At the same tie, I find it funny and contradictory that many on HN complain about Microsoft's stuff not being OSS.
- CmonDev 12y agoI am a Microsoft fan, but I hate when those bastards kill their products leaving people using them without real alternatives, for example: Silverlight and XNA. XNA is now re-written as an OSS _from scratch_ by very kind people (MonoGame), so even if it falls out of fashion, you could fix bugs yourself.
- _pmf_ 12y ago"Paid service" does not imply "not OSS", however.
- latch 12y agoSurprised? No. Disappointed? Yes. We switched from github to gitlab on a DO instance. Recommend 10x over.
- girvo 12y agoAs another fan of GitLab: gosh yes, I can't recommend it enough. I also use ownCloud for my personal info management and file syncing. The only thing I don't run myself is email, which I pay Fastmail to do, because dealing with all the required things to have a decent reputation score so I don't end up in a spam box is too painful.
- petercooper 12y agoThe only thing I don't run myself is email, which I pay Fastmail to do, because dealing with all the required things to have a decent reputation score so I don't end up in a spam box is too painful. It's a compromise, but you could use a paid SMTP service (e.g. Sendgrid, SMTP2Go) for your outgoing mail and still use your own locally hosted system for the UI and receiving mail. At least that way, you'd have more guarantees over mail safety, etc.
- drdaeman 12y agoI've never mass-sent emails outside of local domain, but I had set up various MTA/MDAs and from I've seen, proper A+MX+PTR records, configured SPF and DKIM, and having proper RFC-compliant emails (and, uh, obviously, not spamming anyone) should be enough to stay way below the threshold.
- sytse 12y agoGitLab B.V. CEO here. Thanks for mentioning GitLab! I was pretty disappointed not to see it in the overview and a pull request from my teammate wasn't merged https://github.com/cjbarber/ToolsOfTheTrade/pull/38 https://github.com/cjbarber/ToolsOfTheTrade/pull/38 It is hearthwarming to see three comments mentioning it here.
- alexatkeplar 12y agoActually, I don't get why analytics should be SaaS. The detailed history of all user interactions with your product since launch day is one of your company's _crown jewels_, far more than your payroll data, or even your ticketed customer support interactions. You should be warehousing and mining that event data yourself, not outsourcing the ownership and analysis to a one-size-fits-all SaaS. (Disclaimer: Snowplow co-founder :-)
- sleepyhead 12y agoNot really. I have yet to find any good OSS GUI software (don't say Firefox - I am using it but still has lots of UX quirks). Let's take bug tracker as an example. There is ErrBit and while it is in active development and fairly good it is still far from as good as SaaS-alternatives. And for high volume bug trackers, exception handling and log monitoring is something that requires a fair bit of sysop-work to handle.
- desigooner 12y agoI see Redmine on the list but no Bugzilla (and Testopia). Oversight or is Bugzilla not used as much anymore?