3 ms·
This interesting. There is a story of when people are given from "above" an item without an explanation, they imbue all kinds of meanings to it. Perhaps like i
by rdtsc 12y ago
This interesting.
There is a story of when people are given from "above" an item without an explanation, they imbue all kinds of meanings to it. Perhaps like in the past when a meteorite fell from the sky, all kinds of religious meanings and explanations for it followed.
The second aspect is that Mao recognized this and quickly capitalized on it. The lesson is, if you see a hype starting, regardless if it is irrational or not, it can be taken advantage of easily.
Then there is a third aspect, and that is the "middle managers" if you wish who also took this to a heart and punished and killed people over being irreverent to the "mango". It might have never been about the mango but it was a pretext who punish someone as a scapegoat to keep control and fear going, if it wasn't the mango it could have been another thing (joke about the party for ex).
As I read that I wondered what if you took one of the mango worshipers and ask them why they are respecting this mango object so much? I wonder what they would have said. You might get a different answer depending if they were afraid of repercussion if they seemed irreverent and didn't say "It is a symbol of Chairman Mao's Love or something.
One can draw a parallel here with cargo cult followers of technologies (frameworks, langauges, api, operation systems, products) and so on. When someone decides to pick a technology and you ask them "why did you pick this framework?" or "what made you want to learn that language?" you can learn quite bit by how they answer. Quite often you'll find they don't understand how basics work and you find out they picked it because it a cargo cult. They start repeating "canned" phrases they heard like "it is webscale" or "it is non-blocking so it is better". Or they say "this is slow" and "this is fast". And you ask "have you measured, how did you measure?". And they haven't, they just repeat something a friend with a cool shoes and haircut told them.
Cargo cult and hype following is not always black and white. I can see some validity at least on saying "a big company is sponsoring this toolkit, so I'll pick it because it will probably have enough ecosystem support to move forward". They might not understand the advantages or trade-offs so they use a heuristic. It is not bad, but it tells you something about the person, too.
- dominotw 12y ago>It is not bad, but it tells you something about the person, too. Isn't this basic human psychology to choose ( or fall into) an ideology because it gives us security from the unknown. We choose to get educated, get married and all that because that gives security from fear of unknown. If you ask people why they go married or decided to have kids you would always get "canned" answers, do you seriously expect everyone to deeply examine everything they do? Is it even possible to live without some kind of social/biological conditioning?
- rdtsc 12y agoIt is and it is important to understand that aspect. We live and are dominated by ideology, but is still possible to analyze it and understand how it works at the same time.
- westiseast 12y agoI think it's well understood that the leadership styles of leaders like Mao intentionally involved encouraging the kind of "cargo cult" attitude you're describing. Ambiguous instructions, hints and implications rather than clear directives - all of these create conditions where the leader is never wrong (instead, subordinates make wrong interpretations) and the leader stays flexible to ride any wave of fanaticism like n this article. It's fascinating.