3 ms·
> Amazon pays taxes in every state where it has a presence, and doesn't in states where it doesn't. Just like every business (and individual) since, well, ever.
by bsder 12y ago
> Amazon pays taxes in every state where it has a presence, and doesn't in states where it doesn't. Just like every business (and individual) since, well, ever.
Um, you do realize that this has also been ILLEGAL forever, right?
You, as an individual, are supposed to pay sales tax on your purchases. Period. That is the law.
The fact that the appearance of Amazon allowed millions of people to break that law when the local businesses could not is why the states went after Amazon directly.
Would you much rather that we start convicting people for not paying sales tax? This is the alternative.
Amazon offering zillions of books in stock is disruption. Amazon offering overnight delivery is disruption.
Amazon enabling millions of people to dodge their sales tax isn't disruption--it's called being a jerk.
- Turing_Machine 12y ago"Um, you do realize that this has also been ILLEGAL forever, right?" Um, no it isn't. "You, as an individual, are supposed to pay sales tax on your purchases." You, as an individual, are an entirely different entity from Amazon, which is a company located in another state. "Would you much rather that we start convicting people for not paying sales tax?" Sure I would. Why are you advocating that the burden be put on the entity that isn't breaking the law rather than the one that is? Why are you advocating that states be able to place the burden of enforcing their local laws on an entity located in another state? "Amazon enabling millions of people to dodge their sales tax isn't disruption" Amazon isn't the first company to sell stuff by mail order, dude. The Sears Catalog first came out in the 19th century. And yes, high-tax states whined about it back then, too.
- Turing_Machine 12y agoPowell's Books: http://www.powells.com/info/salestax.html http://www.powells.com/info/salestax.html does not collect sales tax. AbeBooks: http://www.abebooks.com/docs/BooksellerPolicies/4.shtml http://www.abebooks.com/docs/BooksellerPolicies/4.shtml does not collect sales tax. Apple did not collect sales tax until they started opening Apple Stores in other states.