4 ms·
This is a very bad argument. To add to what 3pt14159 (and the very first blog commenter) said: it's clear that distinct English sentence don't correspond to di
by jessriedel 12y ago
This is a very bad argument. To add to what 3pt14159 (and the very first blog commenter) said: it's clear that distinct English sentence don't correspond to distinct possible programs; that's silly. A much more sensible way to think about it is to consider the mapping between distinct English sentences to the sets of programs that a human speaker would consider to have fulfilled the request embodied in those sentences. Those sets define a partition of the space of all programs (i.e. equivalence classes), and you can think about the challenge of automating programming as creating a function that maps English sentences to at least one member of the corresponding equivalence class.
Of course, that doesn't help you solve the problem much, but at least it will keep you from getting confused like the OP is.
- JoeAltmaier 12y agoInteresting notion; but you quickly get into a situation like those Genie stories, where the Genie is always doing something you didn't expect. Imagine a computer trying hard to optimize its response to a spoken sentence. "Show me all the records with my name in them." {Ok, I'll delete all the records with his name in them, and show an empty list} and so on.
- jessriedel 12y agoA human speaker would not consider that to have fulfilled the request embodied in that sentence. In any case, you're discussing the "do as I mean, not what I say" problem, which is completely different than what the OP is talking about.