3 ms·
You get the right answer _modulo_2^N_. In many cases, that is not the right answer. Also, most CPUs will set an overflow bit if addition overflows or underflow
by Someone 12y ago
You get the right answer _modulo_2^N_. In many cases, that is not the right answer.
Also, most CPUs will set an overflow bit if addition overflows or underflows. I don't see how it would be that hard to also force the result to 0b100....000 if that happens.
And 'scarce circuit space'? There are areas where that is still true, but they are getting rarer and rarer. Certainly, for desktop CPUs, x86 shows that one can waste circuit space by keeping around the classical x87 FPU logic, a few variants of SSE that one should not use anymore, a few attempts at vector units, instructions for branching hints that the CPU ignores, etc, and yet be successful.
I think the price paid for the detection of logic errors would be worth it.