4 ms·
While it seems strange Caviar would seek to be acquired so soon after raising funding, it’s possible that the competitive environment is just too much for it to
by gamblor956 12y ago
While it seems strange Caviar would seek to be acquired so soon after raising funding, it’s possible that the competitive environment is just too much for it to handle, and maybe it would do better to be part of a larger company.
In any other environment, a failing or non-competitive company would be purchased for the value of its net assets. In this situation, that would be at most $20 million and likely for less than $10 million. It's silly stuff like this that convinces everyone outside of the SV echo chamber that the tech market is looking at another bubble.
- jasondc 12y agoI'm assuming this acquisition (if it does occur) would be paid for mostly in Square stock. $100 million cash vs $100 million in Square stock have two different values, depending on how you feel about Square's current valuation and future prospects.
- presty 12y agogiven the rise of square, I'd say a $100M in stocks is going to be worth a lot more than $100M in cash
- smtddr 12y agoThat's debatable - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7322642 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7322642 ...and... http://techcrunch.com/2014/05/02/with-ipo-hopes-fading-square-and-box-face-reality-of-commodity-products/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/05/02/with-ipo-hopes-fading-squar...
- hkmurakami 12y agoRemember when Instagram was bought by Facebook right before its IPO, then FB proceeded to tank post IPO? Things have recovered since then of course, but that sort of thing can always happen.
- onewaystreet 12y agoIt's not a bubble when one VC backed company buys another for more than the value of their assets alone. That's how business is done. You can't expect Caviar's investors to sign off on an acquisition where they get no return at all.
- AznHisoka 12y agoI also find it silly. "OOh, we raised $13 million, and we say it's valued at $80 million dollars (even though the assets/product/tech is nowhere never $80 million and we're losing money everyday)! So you're just buying it at a 25% premium, Square! CHEAP! CHEAP!" -investors at Caviar "Hey guys, stocks is virtual money! I mean.. who's gonna repay the public when they buy our stock! Let's buy Caviar for $100 million stock! It's like we paid nothing!" - executives at Square Yup.. it's a bubble alright!
- 2pasc 12y agoIt's silly unless you know the numbers involved (revenues, growth, etc..). As far as I know nobody knows these numbers today (I know the ones from 6 months ago and they were better than most startups hope to ever get to).
- 2pasc 12y agoI don't know anything about this deal, but as far as I know Caviar has been growing leaps and bound, with many new cities launched recently very successfully in terms of order volume, etc... Caviar's growth potential is really strong, (and they are not burning a lot of cash at all - they were operating profitably in SF for almost a year): Grubhub is stuck at the low end of the market, and there is a real opportunity to be a true partner at the high end (which they are doing). Disclaimer: I am a small investor in Caviar and shared an office with them for 4 months
- dmac 12y agoIt's disappointing that a perspective with information from an insider (investor) is down-voted on Hacker News. It's such inside perspectives and unique insight that make Hacker News special.