21 ms·
No disrespect meant; I don't know either one of you. But is it possible your work is in fact subpar? This has happened to me (I was the one who needed to improv
by tomcam 12y ago
No disrespect meant; I don't know either one of you. But is it possible your work is in fact subpar? This has happened to me (I was the one who needed to improve). I urge you to look at your work in that light and see things from your coworker's perspective.
- wmf 12y agoIf one of my coworkers was doing subpar work I'd still discuss it with them before rewriting it.
- danieltillett 12y agoEven if the work is subpar this is no reason to not speak to the poster. This issue is really one of respect. While we are going down the path of wild speculation in the absence of any evidence, I have found these types of "dissings" are a reflection of the dissee being more competent than the disser.
- greenyoda 12y ago"But is it possible your work is in fact subpar?" That might be the case, but throwing out large pieces of somebody else's code without talking to them about it is not a civilized way to behave. If I saw a problem with somebody's code, I'd try to patiently explain to them what the problem was, and how it could be done better. If they ignored me, I'd make my case to our manager in a rational way and let them decide who was right. If the manager thinks that just throwing out somebody's code is acceptable behavior, I'd agree with the people who advised looking for a job elsewhere.
- justanengineer 12y agoThis is fair enough. I feel that like everyone I do make mistakes and I try to own them. I've agreed somewhat with some of the changes he's made, just not the way he's doing it unannounced and without input from anyone else.
- noodle 12y agoIf his code is sub-par, the professional response would be to make comments on his commits and/or otherwise try to provide guidance/mentorship. Not completely strip out his code behind his back and replace it. The problem here actually sounds like this coworker is used to working alone and doesn't know how to work on a team.