4 ms·
I always thought the core service was a pretty good idea, and an exit by selling to a music company seemed feasible...lyrics are fun, more importantly, people a
by danso 12y ago
I always thought the core service was a pretty good idea, and an exit by selling to a music company seemed feasible...lyrics are fun, more importantly, people are passionate about music. So passionate that that they're googling specifically for these lyrics, and also, they have the lyrics mostly memorized. So annotating, and reading those annotations, is a delight.
But everything else? Such as news and literature? That's a different story. Unlike contemporary lyrics, much of the literature that people want to see annotations for -- i.e. the kind of stuff that's studied in literature class -- is already "annotated" by experts, or at least in the form of "Spark Notes", an already popular service. And news? Sorry, as someone who has worked in the news business, there's less of a collective passion in the exact wording and phrasing of a news story than there is for literature/art that captures our collective cultural attention. For obvious reasons.
And this embeddable annotation system, which presumably require the site owner to enable...how is that system different than an inline-version of Disqus?
- ihnorton 12y agoI originally thought it was just a music thing too, but the core use seems to be as a meta-layer for the web. That has existed before, but people apparently use this one - which is the value proposition of every social-web-thing, ever. Look at the comment section of The New York Times, or any other online news source; people are tremendously passionate about the news. This brings them one step closer, interacting with the text in-place rather than at-arm's-length in the comment section. I fully expect to see multiple versions of annotations as the site grows (by region, social network, viewpoint, etc.) Is that worth [$400 million, or whatever]?
- tbcj 12y agoOne area that it probably won't expand to, but I would see value in such a service, is an annotation system on legal texts -- statutes, case law, law review articles, et al. When I was last able to use WestlawNext (almost two years ago), I think it supported personal annotations. Distributed annotations, though, might help me understand the differences in Hong Kong's definition of personal data in Cap 486 versus other definitions in other legal documents. And it could provide some humor when reading the Alabama state constitution.
- nightpool 12y agoIf you're passionate about this kind of stuff, you should take a look at some of the work that's going on at News Genius. Its in very early stages obviously, but for example we worked on the syllabus for the Hobby Lobby case last week: http://news.genius.com/The-supreme-court-of-the-united-states-burwell-v-hobby-lobby-syllabus-annotated http://news.genius.com/The-supreme-court-of-the-united-state.... You can see a list of all our legal articles at http://genius.com/tags/law http://genius.com/tags/law, though a lot of them definitely need some love!
- orbifold 12y agoCollectively annotating scientific texts would be very useful aswell. In certain fields books in libraries usually have hand written pencil notes on their margins. Most math and physics texts would benefit a lot from extra steps in derivations and filling in proofs of "obvious" and "trivial" identities.
- yzzxy 12y agoX Genius[0], the catchall/beta section of the community, specifically mentions tax forms in it's mission statement. So I would look to that community for legal annotation. I'm guessing, however, there's some kind of legal connotation to annotating a legal document - similar to giving investment advice - that could make a legal docs section difficult to legitimize. [0] http://x.genius.com/ http://x.genius.com/
- pmarca 12y agoThe goal is to annotate everything, definitely including legal texts.
- bane 12y agoI almost can't wait for some copyrighted work to get posted and annotated and have "genius" get the pants sued off of them. What is it with recent YC companies and law breaking?
- icebraining 12y agoWhy would they get sued, unlike any other company that hosts user-submitted content? As long as they comply with DMCA takedowns, I don't see why wouldn't they be covered under the safe harbor provisions.
- bane 12y agoUnless people are posting original content or some other category of no longer copyrighted work (or have signed a license agreement), every single work on genius.com is likely to violate copyright. Us hacker/nerd/geek types can pretend copyright doesn't exist or is dumb all we want, but it doesn't make the liability go away. Looking at what's on genius.com right now, they're focusing on either things you can get off of gutenberg (verified to be out of copyright) or excerpts to modern works with a link to a "buy this thing at amazon". Here's the guidelines when you submit: For copyrighted books (published 1923 or later), only add EXCERPTS, not full texts This is going to require quite a bit of curation to resolve and keep right of the law. 13 year old me wouldn't have had any problem copy-pasting an entire e-book. This, Airbnb, and Uber (not YC) and a few other recent startups seem to think making a business model off of out-of-law business ideas is a good model. And I get it, there's a bit of an "the law is wrong let's prove it" going on, and the VCs are using these companies to put pressure on the legislature, but it's pretty dangerous.
- icebraining 12y agoToday the NMPA and Rap Genius today jointly announced "a partnership" that offers NMPA’s music publisher members "the opportunity to enter into a settlement and license with Rap Genius." (...) An NMPA spokesperson emailed, "The agreement allows NMPA members to receive compensation for past use of lyrics and license for use moving forward." http://www.hypebot.com/hypebot/2014/05/rapgenius-makes-nice-with-music-publishers.html http://www.hypebot.com/hypebot/2014/05/rapgenius-makes-nice-...