3 ms·
If you (or anyone you know) support the lottery, I urge you to read this analysis of them. http://www.taxfoundation.org/news/show/1126.html http://www.taxfound
by patio11 17y ago
If you (or anyone you know) support the lottery, I urge you to read this analysis of them.
http://www.taxfoundation.org/news/show/1126.html http://www.taxfoundation.org/news/show/1126.html
It breaks down the effect of a lottery when analyzed as a tax. It goes beyond "tax on those who are poor at math" or "a tax you volunteer to pay". And it is very devastating.
Choice bits:
Lottery proponents argue that a tax is a mandatory or compulsory payment, and playing the lottery is voluntary, so lottery revenue cannot be a tax. But they're confusing the purchase of a product with the payment of the tax on the product. True, the purchase of a lottery ticket is voluntary, but the tax portion of the ticket price is not, just as a sales or excise tax is compulsory on a voluntary purchase of alcohol, clothing or books. The voluntary nature of the purchase does not make the tax any less of a tax. Using the lottery supporters’ rationale, we’d have to say that because the purchase of a book is voluntary, the sales tax on the book is not really a tax. Just try to buy a $20 book and hand the cashier a $20 bill, but refuse to pay the $1 sales tax and leave the store with book in hand. The only difference between the lottery tax and sales or excise taxes is that the lottery tax is built into the price of the ticket, rather than reported separately.
On wealth redistribution and tax burdens:
The only thing the Wisconsin lottery really accomplishes is a redistribution of some of the tax burden, shifting it from property owners to lottery players.
On regressive taxation:
The National Gambling Impact Study Commission determined that, during the time period studied, not only were lotteries regressive, but the poor spent more as a dollar amount.
How lotteries support education:
In 1995, after nearly twenty years of earmarking proceeds for education, the [Montana] state legislature began transferring revenue to the general fund instead. The president of the Montana Education Association stated that it was an 'illusion' that lottery funds significantly benefited public schools.
- rjprins 17y agoOf course lotteries do not make sense economically. But what if it buys hope? And entertainment?
- patio11 17y agoMovies also potentially provide hope and entertainment. Would you support a fifty percent tax on cinema tickets? Except, it would be a 50% tax on cinema tickets levied almost exclusively on cinemas situated in poor neighborhoods. Cinemas in rich neighborhoods would pay regular consumption taxes or be tax-free, and not subject to the special one-off inverse-luxury tax.