7 ms·
What Is a Bitcoin, Really?
- infogulch 12y agoGood article. It's clear, covers the important points, describes the basic technology reasonably well to a non-expert, debunks some common myths, and, thankfully, steers clear of "mining". Mining is really a terrible term for the layperson that evokes thoughts of real mines that produce resources at a continuous rate. It should be called "Distributed transaction verification. And, oh yeah, by the way, verifiers have a chance to win a prize, lottery-style."
- patio11 12y agoOne of the most fun parts about Bitcoin for me is that there are actually infinite public ledgers available. You and your counterparty have to agree in advance on which one you're using. Bitcoiners have solved this coordination problem by saying "We mutually agree to use the public ledger which a) adheres to all the rules in the Satoshi client and b) is longest of all ledgers satisfying that constraint." From this follows several consequences, like there being an infinite supply of cryptocurrencies which share every advantage of Bitcoin, the Satoshi client being really freaking important relative to the "protocol" (whose only authoritative description is the Satoshi client, since in the case of disagreement with the Satoshi client the network will reject you no matter how "correct" your decisions are), and the fact that the ledger which is anointed as consensus at T1 is not necessarily the same ledger which will be consensus at some future T2 when looking back at history.
- ghshephard 12y agoUseful description, but some not 100% accurate statements: "A private key is nothing but a large pseudorandom number roughly between 1 and 2^256" Not sure how the "pseudorandom" came in there - the private key might be random, or pseudo-random, or entirely deterministic - it's essential property is that it's just a 256 bit sequence that is unknown to others. "It’s perfectly safe to give your Bitcoin addresses to other people, but extremely important to keep your private keys secret. " The essential point trying to be made here is that the Bitcoin Address won't allow people to determine your private key. but there are a lot of reasons why you would not want to give your Bitcoin address to other people - the key reason being that it allows to track you. There is one philosophy that suggests you should change your Bitcoin address on every transaction. Overall, though, a nice introductory article to Bitcoin - I'd recommend it to others.
- leni536 12y agoJust for nitpicking, a number is neither pseudorandom or random. It could be randomly generated though.
- Amsterdam88 12y agoThere is no random number generation.. not before we've managed quantum computing.
- Sammi 12y agoYeah, it should be something like: "A private key is nothing but a number roughly between 1 and 2^256, that is only known by you. This number is usually pseudorandomly generated by your bitcoin client, but it could be generated in any way. The important thing is that it is an uncommon large number, that others will not be able to easily guess."
- jc123 12y ago> "A private key is nothing but a large pseudorandom number roughly between 1 and 2^256 Note: Nearly every 256-bit number is a valid private key. Specifically, any 256-bit number between 0x1 and 0xFFFF FFFF FFFF FFFF FFFF FFFF FFFF FFFE BAAE DCE6 AF48 A03B BFD2 5E8C D036 4141 is a valid private key. The range of valid private keys is governed by the secp256k1 ECDSA standard used by Bitcoin. Source is the Bitcoin wiki, https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Private_key https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Private_key which surprisingly isn't listed as one of the references in the post.
- ap22213 12y agoI am kind of embarrassed to admit that after all these years, I still don't understand Bitcoin. Not the underlying software and algorithms - but the concept, the system. I can maybe see where it'd be useful in minimizing electronic transaction costs. But, most transaction costs (credit card fees) that I pay are already rolled into the price of things, so I don't benefit by purchasing them with Bitcoin. And, I guess I can see that it'd be useful to maintain anonymity, but I don't have that use case. Isn't it just easier to buy things with Dollars? I also don't understand the dynamics of it. Doesn't it require increasingly more capital to mine coins and to maintain the ledger? What happens when the value of a coin is less than the mining costs or ledger maintenance? Or, does the coin just keep continuing to increase in value? And, if so, what's to stop people from just using another crypto-currency? And, what is the 'value' of a coin? The article implies that the value is created by the users' trust in the value. But, is that how currencies generally work? I had assumed that currencies either have tangible value, like precious metals, or that they are abstract derivatives of another's debt (government or people).
- ivanche 12y agoJust to add, regarding value of (real world) coins and their relationship with precious metals one can see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_money https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fiat_money
- gnopgnip 12y agoThe average transaction cost is around $40 right now. You have to consider that each block mines coins, and the miners are getting those at the cost of everyone else. A decentralized system will be more expensive than a centralized one. An bitcoin transaction fee is going to be about 40 cents, plus $40 per transaction for the block reward. The value of bitcoin is that you can trade resources for trust. With traditional money you have to trust that visa or your bank will not just zero out your account.
- autokad 12y agoYou're bank just cant 0 out your account. and if your bank gets robbed or goes out of business, you still have your money. not the same for a bitcoin 'bank' as we have seen. they even resorted to telling clients to put their keys on paper, funny that
- astazangasta 12y agoThey forgot the other, key attribute of a dollar that makes it useful for 'distributing wealth': it has a relatively stable value. Economies rise and fall because of the struggle to control the price of their currencies. The notion that a medium of exchange with no such stability should replace the dollar is bonkers.
- sirsar 12y agoIf by stable, you mean "decreasing steadily," then sure.
- astazangasta 12y agoYeah, I'll take a fairly predictable rate of inflation over an inherently deflationary currency with absolutely no controls on its motion. I guess we're supposed to be excited about currency being able to flit around like a panicking moth?
- oafitupa 12y agoI'll take the deflationary one, ty.
- josu 12y ago>Economies rise and fall because of the struggle to control the price of their currencies Economies that fall have struggles to control the price of their currency. The correlation is there, the causation is not so clear.
- JarekS 12y agoFor me, this was the best intro to BitCoin - http://gendal.wordpress.com/2014/03/27/how-i-explain-bitcoin-and-cryptocurrencies-to-new-audiences/ http://gendal.wordpress.com/2014/03/27/how-i-explain-bitcoin... It doesn't focus on tech - it explains why BitCoin as a platform is so important and what are the killer apps that can be build with that platform.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lisch 12y agoI thought the old NPR podcasts were pretty good introductions: http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2011/07/13/137795648/the-tuesday-podcast-bitcoin http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2011/07/13/137795648/the-tues... http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/04/09/176688096/episode-450-bitcoin-goes-to-the-moon http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2013/04/09/176688096/episode-...
- gaelow 12y agoA bitcoin is a commodity. A small piece of a complicated crypto system you can buy or decipher or even trade for goods (in very few and restricted cases) and has practically no use apart from storing it in the hope to get a benefit in the near future by selling it at a higher price. Have you got an old VCR? Well, a bitcoin is just like that, or it will be soon (Only you can't burn a bitcoin in the hope to get some heat when your bitcoin acquires absolutely no value whatsoever but, then again, you may not want to burn a VCR due to toxic fumes and such...) Some talk about decentralized currency, anonymous payments, money laundry... Shenanigans. All shenanigans.
- micahammon 12y agoBesides ease of international transactions, consider that only 41% of adults in developing nations have bank accounts and only 7% of adults in developing nations have credit cards. With Bitcoin and perhaps technology built around it, they can now have access to banking-like features, but without the credit profile which they probably lack, and importantly they can join the digital age and conduct transactions online without the need for credit cards.
- diminoten 12y agoI became familiar with what Bitcoin actually was via an article posted here about 7 or 8 months ago. It was a very long article, but it started from zero assumptions and worked through designing a crypto currency, bringing up each problem and then explaining how Bitcoin solves that problem. I wish I could supply a link to it - maybe someone else has the article?
- fladells 12y agoYou probably mean this one: https://www.igvita.com/2014/05/05/minimum-viable-block-chain/ https://www.igvita.com/2014/05/05/minimum-viable-block-chain... If so, I agree it's a great intro to the topic. Edit: Nvm that article is only from 3 months ago.
- michael_nielsen 12y agoPossibly you're thinking of my article "How the Bitcoin Protocol Actually Works": http://www.michaelnielsen.org/ddi/how-the-bitcoin-protocol-actually-works/ http://www.michaelnielsen.org/ddi/how-the-bitcoin-protocol-a... It was on the HN front page 7 months ago.
- the_decider 12y agoAn excellent series of introductory Bitcoin lectures are available on Coursmos: https://coursmos.com/course/dive-deep-into-a-bitcoin-bitcoin-term https://coursmos.com/course/dive-deep-into-a-bitcoin-bitcoin...
- jds375 12y agoThis is the FIRST article I have ever read that gave me a no bs explanation on what bitcoins really are. It was a great read. Thanks.
- known 12y agohttps://multibit.org/faq.html https://multibit.org/faq.html