6 ms·
Wrong -- I'm paying Verizon for access to the internet -- more specifically, for access to Netflix. If I can't get Netflix, I don't pay Verizon. I either get a
by Alupis 12y ago
Wrong -- I'm paying Verizon for access to the internet -- more specifically, for access to Netflix. If I can't get Netflix, I don't pay Verizon. I either get a new ISP, or don't have internet at all.
It's rather simple. Verizon's customers are consuming traffic, and it's Verizon's job, as a consumer network, to facilitate consumption of said traffic.
- rayiner 12y agoThere is no such thing as the "internet." What appears to be the "internet" is just a mesh of interconnected but private networks all running the same protocol. The Cisco article I linked to above shows you what you're actually buying. What you're talking about is an illusion that only exists in software.
- Alupis 12y agoYou are arguing over the semantics of the word "internet" and completely missing the bigger picture. I only pay Verizon so that I can have access to Netflix content. No access to Netflix, then I'm not a Verizon customer any longer. Verizon is a Consumer Network -- so by definition, almost all of their traffic will be ingress. Level3 has a great blog post detailing the issues at hand. Specifically, they state the consumer networks are refusing to upgrade their networks, and this is shifting the burden to Level3. Level3 knows they are refusing, because they have discussed the matter with the "Big 5" ISP's here in the states. Level3 has even offered to split the cost with the Big5, which as they pointed out, is a win-win for everyone involved. Yet, the Big5 still refused. http://blog.level3.com/global-connectivity/chicken-game-played-child-isps-internet/ http://blog.level3.com/global-connectivity/chicken-game-play...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deeviant 12y agoThat's funny, why does verizon call their service "high speed internet service", when the is no thing as the internet. And if you go to the landing page for high speed internet access on the verizon homepage, it becomes immediately obvious that they are selling it as a internet service. Should we now start talking about there is no such thing as a video, just 1's and zero's, or, there is no such thing as 1's and 0's, just timed voltage oscillations. Or perhaps in verizon's case, there is no such thing as customer service, just opportunistic moneymaking leveraging monopoly and an army of lobbyists.
- rayiner 12y agoI mean to say that there is no such thing as what software folks think of as the "internet": the sort of idealized network that you think of when you're dealing with sockets instead of edge routers. Obviously "internet" exists as a marketing term, but it refers to what's described in the Cisco article, not to the idealization. Do you get upset when you sign up for a United flight and one of the legs is operated by a codeshare partner? It's the same thing: there's an idealized abstraction of a "flight from New York to Burkina Faso" and the actual reality that the underlying physical service is a distributed one.
- Alupis 12y agoAbstraction or not, you are missing the bigger picture. 1) Level3 has offered to split the cost with the Big5 ISP's of upgrading their infrastructure.[1] * This would increase throughput and capacity for both Level3 and the consumer networks. 2) Netflix has offered free Open Connect Appliances to all major ISP's.[2] * This would allow consumer networks to only download a video once, then serve it up locally within their network to all their customers. In-network traffic is almost free for the ISP's. 3) Netflix has offered to change their entire distribution model into a P2P model.[3] * This would allow consumer networks to only download a video once, then serve it up locally within their network to all customers. In-network traffic is almost free for ISP's. . All of these options have been flat-out refused. The Big5 ISP's are purely after the money. There is no other compromise for them. [1] http://blog.level3.com/global-connectivity/chicken-game-played-child-isps-internet/ http://blog.level3.com/global-connectivity/chicken-game-play... [2] https://www.netflix.com/openconnect/hardware https://www.netflix.com/openconnect/hardware [3] http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/04/netflix-researching-large-scale-peer-to-peer-technology-for-streaming/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/04/netfli...
- rayiner 12y agoIn a world where everyone watches Netflix, the traditional peering arrangements dramatically favor companies like Verizon. Unsurprisingly, they're fine with the existing peering arrangements. Companies like Level 3 are offering to "share the cost" of upgrading the networks, because under the traditional arrangements, they would have to bear the full cost of the upgrades. Everyone in this discussion is just looking out for their own bottom lines.
- DanBC 12y ago> Wrong -- I'm paying Verizon for access to the internet -- more specifically, for access to Netflix. If I can't get Netflix, I don't pay Verizon. I either get a new ISP, or don't have internet at all You might not like the logical conclusion: the ISPs charge people for what they actually use.
- Alupis 12y agoNot necessarily. If Level3 is be believed (and they are credible imho), the Big5 ISP's here in the states are just flat-out refusing to make any network upgrades. Level3 has even offered to split the costs with them, since it benefits Level3 as well. What happened to all that "National Broadband Act" funding the Big5 ISP's got? What about annual infrastructure upgrades? These guys are not coping with the data-driven society the wold is now, and are trying to stretch their buck the furthest (I don't fault for that, it's business). However, when they wrongly shift the blame to others, it really fires me up.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 12y agoWhy is Level3 particularly credible to you?
- trevelyan 12y agoBecause the cost of Internet access in the United States is higher, and quality of service lower than what it is in other markets serviced by Level3?
- Alupis 12y ago1) Because they aren't a last-mile carrier, but instead a backbone provider and thus don't have chips on the table. 2) As trevelyan said, they operate around the world, and state that this situation, and mindset of last-mile carriers, is unique to the US. 3) One would think a backbone provider would share the same views as the last-mile carriers, since it would mean more money for them too. However, they state that big content providers such as Netflix are very much so not a problem, but instead it's the last-mile carrier's refusal to make necessary network infrastructure upgrades to augment capacity. This information is available on their blog. This post in particular worth a read: http://blog.level3.com/global-connectivity/chicken-game-played-child-isps-internet/ http://blog.level3.com/global-connectivity/chicken-game-play...