3 ms·
That's really the key problem here. There is lack of choice in the US and Canada. Everyone loves to drum their chest about capitalism but in this case it isn't
by Someone1234 12y ago
That's really the key problem here. There is lack of choice in the US and Canada. Everyone loves to drum their chest about capitalism but in this case it isn't working, and ISPs have clearly colluded to divvy up the territories so they aren't directly competing.
The internet has become a public utility just like electricity, water, or the roads. Businesses and private citizens depend on it day to day, and economic growth is hampered by poor performance in this area (e.g. new types of businesses that depend on bandwidth, like a Netflix competitor, cannot exist if the pipes are slow).
In my view the raw cable and fibre should be confiscated from the big three by the government using eminent domain, and then rented out to competing ISPs (including the big three) on even footing. The rent would pay to maintain the cables/fibre and deploy more network, and the ISPs could add a premium before reselling it to end users to cover support costs and maintaining equipment (e.g. routers, edge connections, etc).
Basically make the final mile public property. It would make real competition as smaller ISPs can now compete with large ones, and there isn't regularly problems for these companies (e.g. getting permits to place new cables).
- ancap 12y ago>Everyone loves to drum their chest about capitalism but in this case it isn't working Your comment assumes that capitalism is in place in the US. It is not. Cronyism, better known as fascism, is.
- ubernostrum 12y agoYour comment assumes that capitalism does not have an inevitable degenerative end state of cronyism and other ills. The balance of history suggests strongly that it does.
- ancap 12y agoIt sounds like you don't know what capitalism is. Here's the definition Google spit out: "an economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state." Seeing as cronyism necessarily requires state influence and capitalism requires the lack of state influence, your conclusion falls on its face.
- ubernostrum 12y agoCapitalism as ideally defined is a period an economy often passes through extremely briefly; one of the exit paths is consolidation of enough power/wealth/influence in a handful of individuals or corporations to begin effectively purchasing government actions as desired. Unless you would like to argue that no true Scotsman would ever abuse a position to make a buck...
- masmullin 12y agoCapitalism is the free and willing exchange of goods. Because the state has colluded with certain companies to remove the 'free' from the above statement, the US internet is no longer a capitalistic system. Your statement about all capitalism eventual collapsing to fascism deserves more evidence. If you could truly prove your point, you'd win a nobel prize.
- ancap 12y ago>one of the exit paths is consolidation of enough power/wealth/influence in a handful of individuals or corporations to begin effectively purchasing government actions as desired. The prerequisite to purchasing government actions is the government having the power/authority to take action. There's a reason lobbyists do not approach you or me.
- caseydurfee 12y agoThe prerequisite to purchasing government actions instead of purchasing mercenaries to enforce ones' will directly is the government having the power/authority to take action. Getting rid of government doesn't change the ability for the powerful to use money to apply coercive force against the powerless. You know that, right? It just means they have to do it themselves. Would you rather $EVIL_CORP own a Senator or own weapons of mass destruction?
- ancap 12y agoThe definition of government is a monopoly on violence/force. Furthermore, no monopoly can be sustained without the force of government. Absent the government I'm not even certain there would be weapons of mass destruction. It is the state who demands these weapons to maintain its monopoly on force. A business, on the other hand, is interested in making a profit. Absent government coercion, a business must provide a worthwhile good/service to make a profit, all while competing in the marketplace. Anything an "$EVIL_CORP" might do pales in comparison to actions we know governments have done. One must only tally up the hundreds of millions of lives lost during the 20th century in senseless wars, democide, etc.
- deeviant 12y agoThe US will implement the very excellent system in which you detailed right after we get single payer health insurance. Never. =/