3 ms·
> So they can cancel rides with few repercussions If there's few repercussions, it's only because the people being cancelled on don't file a complaint. And is
by eridius 12y ago
> So they can cancel rides with few repercussions
If there's few repercussions, it's only because the people being cancelled on don't file a complaint. And is this actually true? I haven't heard any stories of this happening before.
As far as I'm aware, it's a violation of Uber policies for a driver to cancel without a good reason. My believe was that Uber checks up on every driver cancellation, but perhaps they only do that if the customer complains. Certainly I've complained before when I got cancelled on (unrelated to surge pricing).
> That works when the driver is the one who the Uber account belongs to, but if you've ever used Uber in NYC you'll know that a driver will often just rent out his cab + phone to another driver.
Really? Wow, I've never seen that happen before.. I would expect that to be an extremely serious violation of Uber's terms of services, as jljljl said. Certainly if I ever got picked up by a driver that was not the one listed in the Uber app, I'd file a complaint with Uber, and would consider not even getting in the car.
> Also wanted to add that Uber's business model in NYC is that the service is free to taxi drivers
Are you talking about the Taxi calling functionality in Uber, rather than the actual Uber or UberX service? Because that's quite different. I didn't think surge pricing even affected the regular taxi functionality. Of course, my experience with Uber is in SF, so it's certainly plausible that the model works differently in NYC, though I would be surprised to hear that. Also, $4 when they cancel a booking? That doesn't sound like a good model, are you sure that's how it works? In SF with the taxi functionality my understanding was they simply charged a flat fee for each taxi ride (which is taken out of the guaranteed 20% tip to the driver).
- exelius 12y agoTheir business model is different in every city because the laws are different in every city. I only know this because I asked my Uber driver; so I don't know the reasoning behind it in NYC. I would suspect that it's something like dispatch services are not allowed to charge drivers per-ride. NYC in general has a very different attitude towards cab drivers than SF. The city also has rules that the driver is supposed to put his taxi license in the window, and guess what? Half the time it's either not there or it's someone else's license in the window. It's hard enough to get a taxi many places in NYC that if you refused to ride with these guys, you'd just never get a ride. But basically, the city's enforcement of the rules is lax enough that the drivers ignore any rules placed on them and their customers don't expect them to be followed.
- eridius 12y agoNYC already has plenty of taxis. I would expect Uber to only really be used there either as a) a luxury black car service, or b) a convenient taxi dispatch service. It sounds like you're talking about them as if they're purely the latter. Surely they're acting as both? They could also be c) a cheaper alternative to cabs (as UberX), which is what UberX actually is here in SF, but I don't know if UberX exists everywhere or operates the same way everywhere (laws regarding car services are likely to not be that different everywhere, but UberX exists in a much more grey area that I can very much believe doesn't work everywhere; plus, it doesn't make as much sense when there's already enough taxis to go around). As a luxury black car service, everything I've already said stands. Ax a taxi dispatch service, I wouldn't expect really anything I know about Uber to apply. But I wouldn't expect surge pricing to apply either, because when Uber acts as a taxi dispatch service, you're still just paying the regular taxi fare (with the caveat that Uber guarantees a 20% (I think) tip instead of leaving it up to the passenger). And if surge pricing doesn't apply, then neither does the claim that drivers cancel when surge pricing is going up. As far as I'm aware, the main reason for a taxi to cancel is because of laws requiring that taxis can't say no to a street fare, even if they're being dispatched to pick up someone else. This is the same reason why it can take a while to get a taxi to show up when calling the dispatcher directly, and using Uber to request a pickup shouldn't alter that at all. Of course, I could be misinformed about how that law works, but that's my understanding of it. (And of course the taxi driver could have other personal reasons for canceling, but surge pricing isn't one of them). On this note, the $4 for canceling fee actually makes some sense, if we assume Uber was unable to successfully recruit enough cab drivers with the model of Uber being paid a flat fee for each ride. Uber still benefits by having taxi dispatch services in its app, because that means it becomes the one-stop app for people who need car-based transportation, and once you have them in the app you might convince them to go with the real Uber services. And the $4 cancellation penalty encourages drivers to not cancel, which in the absence of a rating system (which I don't believe Uber has for taxis, nor could it really enforce due to e.g. taxis being driven by someone other than the owner) is the only real way to incentivize drivers to not cancel.
- exelius 12y agoNYC may have plenty of taxis, but in the outer boroughs it can be hard to find one when you need one. I don't know it would be fair to call them a "luxury" black car service -- there are plenty of black car services in NYC already, very few of them could be called "luxury". The black car services are basically just pre-negotiated taxis. Uber lets them pick up bookings when they don't have one scheduled. They actually just enabled UberX this week in NYC -- it's been a disaster. A lot of the taxi and black car drivers are boycotting Uber because UberX undercuts their prices (which are largely regulated by the city, so they can't cut prices in response), and they can still get plenty of fares without Uber. So it's been quite hard to get a car via Uber in NYC this week.