6 ms·
The problem with Uber surge pricing is that it's not just the drivers who get paid more; Uber gets paid more too. That doesn't make sense because surge pricing
by modeless 12y ago
The problem with Uber surge pricing is that it's not just the drivers who get paid more; Uber gets paid more too. That doesn't make sense because surge pricing is actually indicative of a failure on Uber's part (they weren't able to recruit enough drivers). From an economics perspective, all of the surge price increase should go to the drivers and Uber should be paid the same or even less. That would also make surge pricing much easier for Uber to defend politically.
- UK-AL 12y agoTheres no point recruiting drivers for 1-2 hour surges.
- Phlarp 12y agoBut there is a point in incentivizing a larger percentage of the total number of drivers in a given area into accepting rides during 1-2 hour surges.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoWow.
- bedhead 12y agoNo, Uber didn't fail anyone. To the extent there's a failure somewhere, it's the monopoly the municipality holds on taxi medallions, which artificially limits supply of taxis overall.
- tptacek 12y agoMunicipalities and states hold "monopolies" on licenses of all sorts; the argument that says medallions are bad public policy because they're monopolistic applies equally to many other forms of licensure, for instance zoning.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoYes, yes it does. If Uber could help usher in the end of some of the other government monopolies, we'd be looking at some huge steps forward.
- rayiner 12y agoI think it's time to reconsider a lot of state licensing regimes. But the fact that they're licensing regimes isn't what makes them bad. Licensing regimes are a perfectly reasonable way for the state to control behavior that involves negative externalities. I think almost everyone agrees that governments shouldn't allow factories to be created in residential areas, or allow drivers to drive without liability insurance.
- tptacek 12y agoCareful: ancaps, hardly an Internet endangered species, definitely don't agree with this.
- zachlipton 12y agoAnd we don't necessarily have to take every single view seriously. The vast majority of people don't want a massive polluting factory built next to their single-family home. The fact that a few people disagree doesn't mean that every project get bogged down in a discussion of the legitimacy of zoning as a concept.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoAncaps simply have more efficient ways of keeping the polluting factories away from homes than existing zoning processes can achieve.
- alexeisadeski3 12y ago>I think almost everyone agrees that governments shouldn't allow factories to be created in residential areas, or allow drivers to drive without liability insurance. Zoning is not needed for the former.
- tfinniga 12y agoOn the other hand, the limit on taxi medallions protects a common resource, room on the streets. Maybe the balance isn't right, but you're going to need some artificial limitation or else you're going to have a classic tragedy of the commons.
- nickff 12y agoThere does not need to be an "artificial limitation" to protect every 'commons'.[1] Many have made the case that services like Uber and Lyft actually free up street space, and allow more people to get to work faster, because less parking spaces are required, and these services usually allow ride-sharing, which is banned (or effectively prevented) by many cities which license taxis and taxi companies. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elinor_Ostrom http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elinor_Ostrom
- tfinniga 12y agoThanks for the link to Elinor Ostrom. It seems like what she was saying is that if the people who own and use the common resource have the ability to create rules and enforce them, then they can avoid a tragedy of the commons. I'd totally agree with that, you need some way to govern the resource. About freeing up street space, I'd be curious to see some kind of statistics about how many lyft drivers were headed that way anyway and just pick up passengers vs. how many are providing a taxi-like service. Is there a way in the lyft or uber software as a driver to say that you're only looking for passengers going from one location to another location? It seems like slugging is more likely to provide those benefits.
- nickff 12y agoUsing ownership of a resource to give an incentive for preservation and long-term thinking has its roots at least as far back as Armen A. Alchian.[1] Ostrom's achievement was finding that many cultures had alternative solutions, and that these solutions were very effective. I am sorry to say that I do not have the statistics that you are looking for. [1] http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/PropertyRights.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/PropertyRights.html
- sliverstorm 12y agoNot necessarily a failure. One of the purposes of medallions is to control the number of taxis on the road. It's a conscious choice, and the fallout is accepted in exchange for less taxi congestion.
- wutbrodo 12y agoI think you misunderstand what surge pricing _is_. Part of the reason Uber can't recruit more drivers is that the price isn't worth it for them; and for all the times where they don't _need_ more drivers, this is completely fine. When there is a sudden need for more drivers, they can quickly recruit more by raising the prices...this is exactly what surge pricing is.
- w4 12y agoModeless is actually in agreement with you, as I understand it. The distinction they're making is a bit of a fine one, but they're basically saying Uber ought to allocate all of the increase from the surge pricing to drivers rather than taking a cut. By not taking a cut Uber would more efficiently incentivize drivers to get out and take rides, and more rapidly affect an increase in supply and the corresponding price rebalancing. This would also have the happy side effect of making surge pricing wholly defensible, since Uber sees no benefit from it. Whether or not that is feasible under Uber's business model is, of course, a totally different question.
- eridius 12y agoWhat incentive is there for Uber to do this? Remember, they're a for-profit company, not a public service. If Uber didn't take a surge pricing cut, then the only reason they have to use surge pricing is to maximize the number of rides on the road. And that's certainly something they could do, as more rides == more money. But they'd be leaving money on the table that way, and as a for-profit company, there's very little incentive to do that. You stated that it would make surge pricing more defensible, which is basically the only reasonable incentive I can think of, but obviously Uber believes that it's in their interests to make more money than to have a stronger moral defense for surge pricing. So I guess the real question is, for those of you who believe Uber should behave this way (and, w4, I recognize that you're merely explaining modeless's argument, not claiming you agree with it), do you believe Uber should be expected to behave this way, given that they are a for-profit company, or do you believe that it is merely the *right thing to do (for some ambiguously-defined moralistic definition of "right")? I suspect that what you really believe is that it's what you personally think should happen, because it would result in lower surge prices for the same supply, and you would like to pay less money. And that's not a very compelling argument.
- nawitus 12y agoAnd that's caused by lack of competition.
- josu 12y agoFrom an economics perspective there was money left on the table an Uber is taking it, and that's the end of it. However, economics will also tell you that this doesn't seem to be an equilibrium situation, and therefore competitors will start entering the market until Uber's profits are razor thin, unless the regulators get in the way and screw the whole pricing scheme up.
- natrius 12y agoStart an Uber competitor that only gives surge pricing charges to drivers. Your rates should be lower. As long as monopoly abuses are prevented, this problem will work itself out.
- eridius 12y agoAt first glance you seem to have a reasonable point, but it actually doesn't work out. Surge pricing doesn't merely raise supply to meet demand, it also suppresses demand to meet supply. In the latter case, there are fewer rides going around than there would with an infinite supply, so if Uber doesn't take a cut of the surge pricing themselves, then they're missing out on money they would have had without the suppressed demand. Perhaps you think they deserve to make less money, but as wutbrodo pointed out, the lack of supply at these times does not mean Uber has failed at recruiting drivers. After all, having extra drivers sitting around idle is not helpful to anyone (not to Uber, not to the drivers themselves, and not to the passengers). The only mechanism Uber has for putting more drivers on the road when demand increases is to adjust prices. Theoretically they could merely reduce their cut to put more drivers on the road without increasing the cost to passengers, but there's no incentive for them to do that. Ultimately, what you said would make sense if drivers were actually Uber employees that operated at the direction of Uber. In that scenario, Uber could order more drivers onto the road without surge pricing. But that's not the case, drivers are voluntary contractors that make the decision themselves about whether to start working. The only tool Uber has to influence how many drivers start working is to increase their pay, and the only way to do that* is to turn on surge pricing. And since surge pricing acts to reduce demand in addition to increasing supply, the only way Uber itself has an incentive to use surge pricing is if Uber itself gets more money that way (which means taking a cut of the surge-boosted price instead of the original price). I'll grant you that if Uber was a regulated service operating on behalf of the public, then perhaps it makes sense to penalize them for not adequately meeting demand. And in such a scenario, surge pricing can't be justified anyway, so the natural penalty of not filling as many rides as there is demand for would suffice. But Uber is a for-profit company, offering what is essentially a luxury good, and the only arguments that really have any bearing on Uber's behavior are economic ones. it's possible that there are times when it makes sense to do that, e.g. when surge pricing is already on and raising it further will suppress demand enough that they won't make as much money. It's possible that reducing their cut could increase driver supply enough to make up for the difference (due to more rides happening). But I don't know if this is ever true in practice. *short of reducing their cut, as mentioned previously, but there's no incentive to do this instead of surge pricing