10 ms·
Uber Makes Economists Sad
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ollysb 12y ago>> that price gouging actually makes everyone better off by ensuring greater supply and allocating the supply to (approximately) those with the greatest demand I think the issue is that it's not those with the "greatest demand" but those with "the greatest demand and can afford higher prices" i.e. the service isn't equally available to people during surge pricing, it skews heavily towards the wealthier, "(approximately)" massively understates the significance of this.
- shurcooL 12y agoYou have a good point, but is there a problem with it being more available to wealthier people? Everything else being equal, say person A watches Breaking Bad for 7 hours and works for 1, having less money in pocket compared to person B who worked 8 hours that same day. Should both people have equal spending ability?
- monochr 12y agoThere might or might not be a moral case for this. But to say that this allows the market to act like Marx's utopia of to each according to their need is not only wrong, but a lie anyone with the minimum one week in an undergraduate economics course should see.
- phaer 12y agoIn most parts of society, wealth has little to do with the time spent working.
- zachlipton 12y agoDo you honestly think that poorer people are poorer because they sit around watching Breaking Bad all day? Have you perhaps ever met someone who works hard at three jobs at minimum wage and can't make ends meet, especially in an incredibly expensive city like NYC? I mean what planet are you living on?
- Vik1ng 12y agoYeah this it also allows you to be sure that you will be able to get a taxi on New Year’s Eve as long as you’re willing to pay extra. was already possible. But "extra" here doesn't mean a few bucks, but a shitload of money. You could already hire a personal driver, if you were willing to pay for it.
- cma 12y agoThe idea is a rich guy can still quickly get to the beautician during a disaster. He's earned this right and is basically just cashing in on years of hard work skimming off the top of workers's 401K trading fees--these workers were forced to select from a few mutual funds chosen based on family ties with the executives, but he worked damn hard to be born to the right board member. Highest bidder would work great and allow excellent prioritization if everyone had roughly the same means. This is a bit like economist worship of the Coase Theorem--it completely falls apart when you factor in marginal utility of additional dollars to individuals at different levels of wealth.
- icebraining 12y agoAn actually rich guy will just call his driver.
- SilasX 12y agoI sympathize with the resentment of those who got unfair advantages from exploiting others, but preventing goods from being economized based on price signals entirely is not the right response. From the fact that some wealth is unjustly acquired, it doesn't follow that we should expect everything to cost the same and be allocated by queuing.
- tptacek 12y agoNo, that's not the idea. If surge pricing was in effect all the time --- if travel pricing was always an auction and drivers were kept scarce to keep prices up --- then Uber rides would be a service for the rich. But disasters are rare, and the surge multiple is merely the equivalent of several Uber rides instead of one. Meanwhile, the alternative to surge pricing is a high likelihood of not getting a ride at all, because disasters suppress demand. It's hard to see the class-warrior logic in this situation. (Later, you edited your comment) It's a caricature to suggest that "Coase" is, to economists, a license to apply the free market to every public policy problem. Meanwhile: you have to actually make the case that there's a distributional problem with surge pricing for Uber rides. If the alternative is no rides at all, then surge pricing makes some people --- not all of them rich --- better off while making nobody worse off.
- jayd16 12y agoBut this is true even without surge pricing.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoRicher people can afford more stuff, more news at 11.
- declan 12y ago> it skews heavily towards the wealthier I'd say it skews heavily toward those with the greatest demand, as the previous post said. If you have average financial resources and needed to get to the hospital in the middle of a snowstorm, you stood a better chance under Uber's previous model that allowed a market-clearing price. Now that some NY politicians have outlawed that process, the price that they permit will be below the market-clearing price and the likelihood of shortages will increase. Put another way, Uber drivers will (sensibly) venture out in snowstorms only if they can make significant $$$. Hope you're well enough to walk to that hospital! Thanks, Albany! (Note I'm not an interested party here: I own a late-model car, I don't live in NYC, and I've used Uber and similar services < 5 times this year. But someone was wrong on the Internet and clearly needed to be corrected.) :)
- untog 12y agoNew York didn't kill surge pricing. They limited how high surge pricing can go during emergencies. A pretty huge difference. Uber will not totally eliminate dynamic pricing during emergencies but will instead cap how high its rates can go based on what it charged consumers over the previous two months. http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2014/07/08/uber_price_gouging_not_during_emergencies_in_new_york.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/moneybox/2014/07/08/uber_price_go...
- shurcooL 12y agoWhat are the minimum requirements for a situation to be considered an emergency?
- anateus 12y agoFrom the AG's announcement (and Uber's announcement promises to abide by this definition): New York’s law against price gouging (General Business Law §396-r), was passed in the winter of 1978-79 in response to escalating heating oil prices. It defines an “abnormal disruption of the market” as “any change in the market, whether actual or imminently threatened, resulting from stress of weather, convulsion of nature, failure or shortage of electric power or other source of energy, strike, civil disorder, war, military action, national or local emergency, or other cause of an abnormal disruption of the market which results in the declaration of a state of emergency by the governor.”
- omni 12y agoSo now they can't do surge pricing when it rains? The main reason I like Uber in NYC is because it is impossible to get a taxi when it's raining. Seems like this would ruin a big chunk of their value proposition.
- morley 12y agoIt doesn't say they can't do surge pricing; they just have a cap on how high it can go during an emergency.
- anateus 12y agoIs a (potentially dramatically) smaller set of riders of more evenly distributed financial means strictly better than more riders that skew richer? Egalitarian distribution is in some ways a social good (it's a good antidote to the hedonic treadmill for just one thing). But at what smaller size does this more equal ridership become strictly worse than a bigger less-equal ridership?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- epistasis 12y agoTechnical aside: this page took forever to load, after being laid out. Is that due to a WebFont issue? Too much stuff dumped into the onload handler? It's been over 60 seconds of blank, laid out page now and I still can't see the content. This is pretty much worst case when it comes to web technologies. Show the text first, let the extras come in slowly. Showing everything except the text is pretty horrific.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rdl 12y agoAt 8x, I would have considered driving for UberX myself during events (although probably not NYE, just due to drunk driver risk).
- pbreit 12y agoAnd that is exactly the point.
- modeless 12y agoThe problem with Uber surge pricing is that it's not just the drivers who get paid more; Uber gets paid more too. That doesn't make sense because surge pricing is actually indicative of a failure on Uber's part (they weren't able to recruit enough drivers). From an economics perspective, all of the surge price increase should go to the drivers and Uber should be paid the same or even less. That would also make surge pricing much easier for Uber to defend politically.
- UK-AL 12y agoTheres no point recruiting drivers for 1-2 hour surges.
- Phlarp 12y agoBut there is a point in incentivizing a larger percentage of the total number of drivers in a given area into accepting rides during 1-2 hour surges.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoWow.
- bedhead 12y agoNo, Uber didn't fail anyone. To the extent there's a failure somewhere, it's the monopoly the municipality holds on taxi medallions, which artificially limits supply of taxis overall.
- tptacek 12y agoMunicipalities and states hold "monopolies" on licenses of all sorts; the argument that says medallions are bad public policy because they're monopolistic applies equally to many other forms of licensure, for instance zoning.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoYes, yes it does. If Uber could help usher in the end of some of the other government monopolies, we'd be looking at some huge steps forward.
- toby 12y agoSerious question -- there appear to be common two ways of allocating scarce resources in situations like this: either through price, or through semi-random who-gets-through first (see also online ticket sales). Why do people think the latter is "more fair"? Are there any interesting alternative methods of allocation that are equally lightweight?
- alexeisadeski3 12y ago>Why do people think the latter is "more fair"? I have no idea what unfortunate psychological characteristic of the human brain leads so many to oppose price gouging and markets, but here is some tangential discussion: http://bleedingheartlibertarians.com/2013/10/price-gouging-and-the-poor/ http://bleedingheartlibertarians.com/2013/10/price-gouging-a...
- austinhutch 12y agoMore people have access to the second method. Many people would rather have a 25% chance of getting through and paying the lower price than not being able to afford a ticket at all.
- declan 12y ago> there appear to be common two ways of allocating scarce resources in situations like this: either through price, or... But the quantity of the resource (Uber drivers) is not fixed. If you allow a higher surge price, you get more drivers.
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoThis mis-characterizes the Economist's wonder at price mechanisms - as though this one characteristic in a vacuum should be a shining example of the "invisible hand" (subtext mine). The key market assumption that is missing that would make this a wholly positive pricing activity, is that the marginally increased demand also comes with a marginally increased supply at a marginally higher cost, which it doesn't in these cases. The supply market does not expand in order to cover more customers in most cases, with everyone paying a slight penalty for the transaction/logistical cost, all it does is take a saturated supply market and price out the lower tier. So if Uber was able to dispatch MORE drivers for a slightly higher cost at surge times (arguably easier with Uber than with traditional taxi companies), that would actually be closer to the Pareto efficiency that economists like. Perhaps I am wrong but it doesn't look like that is what happens in the case of Uber.
- icebraining 12y agoWhy do you think Uber doesn't dispatch more drivers? As far as I know, one of the reasons for the surge pricing is to get more Uber drivers on the street, increasing the supply.
- iand 12y agoThat may be the intention, but where's the evidence that it actually has that effect? Do they publish stats of number of drivers on shift vs pricing? I work for a similar business and I've seen evidence that supply is not all that elastic.
- potatolicious 12y agoOne of the stated reasons. We've yet to see any evidence that this effect actually occurs and is significant. This is the same company that tried to eliminate its competition by ordering cars and canceling them at the last moment. I like their product enough, but their business practice track record suggests that they are not on the up and up. Particularly in NYC where surge isn't just long events like New Year's - surge kicks in during half hour rainstorms as well. I highly doubt there's any significant supply change in that kind of time frame - in which case Uber is simply price gouging without any of the claimed positive supply effect.
- pbreit 12y agoThe author appears to have little or no grasp of human psychology. People object to cash being the only tool utilized to increase supply which is totally reasonable. Why doesn't Uber try =any= other incentives? There's not a huge difference between "no one getting ice" and "a few rich people getting ice". That is what people object to and it has nothing to do with politics. Also, my read of Uber's agreement was that it would only cap surge pricing during natural disaster-type problems based on some formula for recent surges. So the economists will only miss studying true price gouging.
- icebraining 12y agoWhich other incentives?
- orbifold 12y agoLowering or increasing the cut that Uber takes for example.
- w4 12y agoWhy would a rational actor take a reduced profit in the face of increased demand for their product?
- icebraining 12y agoUber's cut is just 20%, so the effect would be relatively low unless they wanted to dramatically lower the average pay of the drivers.
- wutbrodo 12y ago> There's not a huge difference between "no one getting ice" and "a few rich people getting ice". The idea behind demand pricing is that people who need it the most will be the most willing to pay; pricing is the only real general mechanism we have to express need/desire. With Uber, I sometimes take Ubers even though my destination is straight down a bus line (to avoid waiting at the bus stop, if the weather is bad, etc). If the price was high enough, I may decide to just take the bus, which means the Uber is freed up for someone taking a trip that's less amenable to purely taking transit. You are of course right that this effect is distorted by the fact that the wealthier you are, the less valuable money becomes, so you're willing to pay more for things that are less important. It just seemed like you were being a little reductive and ignoring the actual intent (and partial result) of demand pricing.
- rayiner 12y agoIt's absolutely no surprise that the majority of people might prefer a particular resource to be allocated by lottery instead of auction, because they can't afford to outbid the wealthy minority for those resources. There is a lot of social conditioning in our society to accept auctioning as normal for resources like land and housing, but for things like taxis or tickets auctioning hasn't been practical to date so the socialization isn't there and this more basic preference, arguably rational for the average person, shows through. You see similar attitudes in many other areas. E.g. when it comes to spectrum auctions, people complain that the big telecom firms just get even richer by buying up all the spectrum. Well sure, that's what happens in markets. Those with the most money buy all the resources.
- icebraining 12y agoIt's absolutely no surprise that the majority of people might prefer a particular resource to be allocated by lottery instead of auction, because they can't afford to outbid the wealthy minority for those resources. That would be rational if the supply was fixed; but since it isn't (the number of drivers increase with the surge pricing), it's far from clear whether the average person is negatively affected by the temporary price increase (as far as I know, surge prices usually last a very short time).
- Vik1ng 12y ago(the number of drivers increase with the surge pricing) I doubt there would be suddenly tens of thousands of additional drivers more after the WC final on Sundary in Germany to drive all the people home from the bars and public viewing locations, when more than 80% of the population is watching the game. (as far as I know, surge prices usually last a very short time) Well, that's already sucks enought, when it's late in the night and you want to get home. Might as well wait until I can get public transport in the morning...
- alwaysdoit 12y agoHaving talked with many Lyft drivers about it, the drivers are definitely aware of what times pay better rates and many of them choose to schedule their workdays around it. I don't know if it works for one off events like the WC but it definitely increases supply during evenings and late nights.
- monochr 12y agoPrice discrimination only matches supply to greatest demand if everyone has the same income. But I then again this is Bloomberg so I'd be shocked if I saw any real economics on their website.
- scrame 12y agoBy the same logic, I'm sure that rent control makes economists sad, too. However, if that didn't exist, NY and SF would just be real estate speculation ghost towns.
- tg3 12y agoI'm not sure that SF's current real estate situation is much better.
- tptacek 12y agoI think that sentiment is pretty far from uncontroversial amongst economists of all stripes. Here's a survey paper: http://econjwatch.org/articles/rent-control-do-economists-agree http://econjwatch.org/articles/rent-control-do-economists-ag... Here's what Matthew Yglesias --- hardly a standard-bearer for libertarian economics --- has to say about it: http://beyondchron.org/matthew-yglesias-is-right-the-rent-is-too-damn-high/ http://beyondchron.org/matthew-yglesias-is-right-the-rent-is... (Yglesias is not an economist but is a decent proxy, since this is kind of his "beat").
- wutbrodo 12y agoFor the life of me, I don't understand why we don't replace rent control with means-tested cash grants if we really care about displacement (and pay for it out of a Land Value Tax, but that can be an orthogonal issue). The way we have it now, we're screwing arbitrary renters (including poor ones) that happen to move between apts more often, to pay arbitrary renters that happen to move less often (including rich ones). I don't understand how anyone could say it's good policy with a straight face.
- declan 12y agoExcerpt from that survey paper you cited, which reports that economists agree that "rent control is bad": ...I find that the preponderance of the literature points toward the conclusion that rent control introduces inefficiencies in housing markets. Moreover, the literature on the whole does not sustain any plausible redemption in terms of redistribution. The literature on the whole may be fairly said to show that rent control is bad, yet as of 2001, about 140 jurisdictions persist in some form of the intervention...
- tptacek 12y agoIf you want to hear two libertarian-leaning econ professors talking about Uber, including some novel arguments against it (they both support Uber, of course, particularly the surge pricing), check out this week's EconTalk: http://www.econtalk.org/ http://www.econtalk.org/
- w1ntermute 12y agoDirect link: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/07/michael_munger.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2014/07/michael_munger.html The episode is pretty good. It's fun to listen to economists' perspective on these services after being absorbed in the tech.
- tptacek 12y agoI liked it fine, but I found the economics to be extremely predictable and the public policy analysis to be very shallow. For instance, Airbnb is to Mike Munger an unalloyed good; I found myself yelling at the car radio "but what about the mob hotels?" You knew Roberts and Munger were going to like Uber, and, of course, they do.
- w1ntermute 12y agoI think that was to be expected, based on the fact that they are both professed libertarians. There are other episodes where the guest doesn't share Roberts' ideologies though.
- nilsimsa 12y agoPerhaps we can get some special surge pricing setup for only the economists.
- colinbartlett 12y agoI live in New York and use Uber a lot. Last week during the tropical storm, I opened the app to use it but found the surge pricing to be too rich for my blood. I hopped on the train instead (it was only 2 blocks away anyway). Surge pricing works! That car I would have used stayed available for someone that needed it a lot more than I did.
- prutschman 12y agoThat car I would have used stayed available for someone that needed it a lot more than I did. That car stayed available for someone willing to pay more money. Between two people of roughly equal means, that's a good proxy for "needs it more." Between two people of vastly disparate means it's not.
- herge 12y agoAre there these large armies of people who can afford and pay for taxis over public transportation at 1x but not exceptionally during a topical storm at 5x or 10x? A taxi is already a luxury good.
- dandelany 12y agoAre there large armies of people who make >$100k/year but <$1M? Yes.
- herge 12y ago200 dollars is not a big emergency expense for someone who makes more than $100k per year.
- dandelany 12y agoDepending on your definition of emergency, it is when you live in NYC and your rent costs $2k/month. If by emergency you mean "hurricane" - sure. But surge pricing happens every time there's a rainstorm.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoPrice Gouging and the Poor - relevant http://bleedingheartlibertarians.com/2013/10/price-gouging-and-the-poor/ http://bleedingheartlibertarians.com/2013/10/price-gouging-a...
- contingencies 12y agoThe root of the problem is the question of whether social values should have weight in a situation of limited supply, ie. when taken to its extreme: should one person be allowed to fuck up the whole planet because they have more monopoly money, thereby destroying the whole species and all future generations. Conventional capitalists will say yes without thinking, then spout whatever view-confirming stuff they can find (like this URL). Market-libertarians say a market will evolve to cater for the resource impacted that all people value, though we haven't actually seen that happen yet (observe the failure of the carbon credit scheme). Socialists say yes, we should treat one another with respect because fundamentally we're all in this together. All views have some credence.
- alexeisadeski3 12y agoNo, that is not the root of the problem at all. The root of the problem is that humans have evolved anti-market biases that served us well when living in tribal communes but which are Pareto inefficient when living in large billion person societies.
- contingencies 12y agoI'd call that a capitalist view. In all its brevity, it exhibits one of the absolute top fallacies of capitalist thinking when in "have evolved anti-market biases" you allude to markets being some kind of 'natural' state of affairs. This falsity was neatly summed up by George Soros: Classical economics is based on a false analogy with Newtonian physics... by which he means, if you listen to or read any of his numerous interviews, that there is no 'equilibrium' and self-regulating nature of the market is fundamentally more a well-spun, oft-repeated tale than a self-evident truth. Further smackdown can be applied through reading Debt: The First 5000 Years (which conventional capitalist economists positively hate). Leaving that aside, you'll note that I alluded to the ugly truth (the world is inherently limited; ie. there's sure to be critical resource shortages given current trajectories). From my perspective, any so-called anti-market bias will evolve right about the time we see mass starvations due to stupid short-sighted environmental management, potable water shortages, etc. - ie. if you think we've got anti-market bias now ... my wager is that you'll be shocked at how hollow the notion becomes in the relatively near future. But the view does have some credence, ie. some forms of decision-making don't scale. But the obvious answer to that, far from assuming a self-evident path of decoupling historically present social, environmental, cultural and other local factors from economic decision-making across an inherently globalized god-like market that will deliver us from all ills as you imply (clearly, it won't), is perhaps to evolve newer and more subtle modes of collective decision-making that include market-like consideration of these factors and scale more effectively. That would be more like the market-libertarian view.
- judk 12y agoThis article misrepresents the facts, and the headline is false in two different ways. (False claim about surge pricing, unsupported claim about "economists") The linked Slate article is more accurate. Mods, please switch the link to point to the more accurate less blogspammy Slate source.
- dbingham 12y agoThe problem with this is that the people who get the rides in surge pricing are not the ones with the most demand, but those with the most resources. It's an inherently classist system. The surge price, to that rich person coming out of work to catch a cab to that upscale restaurant for dinner is pennies. But the surge price to the single mother who desperately needs the cab to get to school to pick up her kids on time before the school closes and they have to walk home in the rain with out jackets is breaking the bank. This does not make things "better for everyone" as the article argues. It only ensures that the wealthy always have it good, instead of having to compete for the limited service with everyone else. And it doesn't give the rides to those who truly need them most.
- drcode 12y ago> single mother who desperately needs the cab to get to school to pick up her kids Now, the single mother can get a very reasonable price on an Uber car that isn't available (because she didn't win the lottery.) Yay for solving the class problem!
- dkural 12y agoSo let's do this for housing as well. Let's assign the best houses by lottery for a fixed price so that the poor mother of two has a fair chance, as opposed to a rich person housing their lover on the side. I think symbolic legislation around feel-good examples like cabs allows society to maintain the fiction that somehow it's not already completely capitalistic. It's like a safety valve.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoComplaining about pricing of cabs is rich people wanting their bit of capitalism to feel fair to them. For many people a cab is something you use when all other transport options have failed and you need to get somewhere now even if it means eating just beans on toast for the next week.
- crygin 12y agoYes. I had a friend once who took a cab to work when her bus didn't arrive, even though it meant she would have a net negative income for that day, so she wouldn't lose her job.
- josu 12y ago>drivers couldn’t be lured out of their warm beds on a cold and needy night. This is not only about warm beds, it's about risk and reward. A snowstorm increases the chances of getting into a car crash by many factors, and if the reward (surge pricing) isn't big enough, drivers won't be willing to risk it.
- dntrkv 12y agoI don't have a problem with surge pricing, but what I do have a problem with is when a driver cancels my ride so they can get a higher surge rate. Example, I was in LA trying to go from Downtown to Venice, I got an Uber for 1.75x normal rate. Waited about 10 minutes while watching the driver head in a different direction on the map, and then all of a sudden, they cancel. I go back to reserver another driver, and what do you know, it's now 3.25x rate. That shouldn't be allowed. You should be locked into the first rate that you request a driver at. If the driver cancels, and the area now has a higher surge rate, Uber should recoup the difference in cost from the drivers next trip because they fucked a customer over.
- w4 12y agoYeah, that's completely horseshit. At a minimum the rate ought to stay locked in for you by virtue of the agreement to take your fare, and the difference should come from the offending driver's next fare as a disincentive.
- mox1 12y agoYou always have the option of not choosing Uber.... You can even start a blog and inform others of this practice. Finally, you can complain to everyone you know and encourage people not to use Uber... Or just ask the government for more legislature I guess...
- w4 12y agoOr, a customer service flaw that disincentives use of Uber's service due to the unreliability of their contractors could be addressed by Uber, as a cost to those unreliable contractors, as I suggested. What part of my post (or any other posts I've made on this topic, for that matter) suggests I feel government legislation would be appropriate here? EDIT: Furthermore, this is already something Uber does with their star rating system. This would just be a logical extension of that.
- eridius 12y agoDid you file a complaint with Uber? As far as I'm aware, what that driver did is a violation of Uber policies (both canceling without a good reason, and waiting 10 minutes before said cancellation). I think that Uber should proactively check up on all driver cancellations, but they probably only check up on complaints, so go ahead and complain when that happens. If people complain when their drivers cancel, drivers won't cancel anymore (without a valid reason). The only way they can get away with it is if you say nothing.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- foobarqux 12y agoWhy are economists who defend surge pricing not pushing for "real" markets where drivers set prices?
- tezka 12y agoAn important yet neglected aspect of surge pricing model is that it fails to correctly account for decrease in demand. As such, one can probably argue that fixed prices capture the real market better in the expectation sense.
- qq66 12y agoPart of me things that this could have been avoided with better messaging and product design. Instead of calling it "surge pricing," they should have said, "There are no Ubers available. Your expected wait for an Uber is 110 minutes. Would you like to offer a bonus to your driver?" Then you could select a bonus, and drivers could choose to pick you up or not pick you up based on whether they thought the bonus was enough.
- pistle 12y agoIt creates supply! (It doesn't. It stratifies the haves from the have-nots efficiently.) Ice after a storm? Definitely let market forces dictate who keeps insulin cold and who sips chilly mint julips. This is the underlying issue with Uber and blind disruption of regulatory frameworks. Regulatory initiatives often get propelled with moral issues. They then get calcified and twisted by economic forces. Disruption of those economic entrenchments is laudable. Avoiding the acknowledgement of the collateral damage to the moral reasons for existing regulatory systems creates obstacles to acceptance. Fix that last bit and market forces can play freely.
- SilasX 12y agoDo you object generally to scarcer goods costing more, or is there a more narrow (and preferably reasonable) standard by which you think this kind of effect should be suppressed? For example, I'm sure you don't object to higher-quality goods costing more?
- eridius 12y ago> It creates supply! (It doesn't. It stratifies the haves from the have-nots efficiently.) Are you disputing that surge pricing increases supply? It should be trivially obvious that it does. Your "moral" arguments only apply if you treat Uber as the sole provider of transportation. If Uber ever starts actually supplanting cabs, your argument will have some merit, but cab companies have not died off. They have a real competitor now, which I think is a good thing, and in markets like SF where the cab companies woefully underserved the population it's now actually possible to reasonably get a ride. But the cabs still exist, with the same regulations as before. If Uber disappeared overnight, the supply of cabs would not increase. The supply of overall transportation during a storm certainly would not increase. Given that Uber is an addition to the existing transportation infrastructure, and not a replacement, what exactly is the justification for claiming that Uber needs to abide by the same pricing regulation that regular cab companies obey? There's a good argument for why safety regulations should apply to Uber, but that doesn't apply to things like pricing. Regulation of pricing for cab companies is not a natural consequence of the fact that the cab companies are in the business of transportation; it's a consequence of the fact that cab companies are seen as providing basic public infrastructure. Do you view Uber as basic public infrastructure? I don't, and I don't see how you can make a compelling argument for that position.