4 ms·
Without answering your question -- I'm not sure of the answer -- I think the more important question is: How exactly do you 'know' that (hypothetically) 9 out
by jrochkind1 12y ago
Without answering your question -- I'm not sure of the answer -- I think the more important question is:
How exactly do you 'know' that (hypothetically) 9 out of 10 authors from Laos are corrupt?
How have you demonstrated/discovered this? (hypothetically, I realize this is just a hypothetical example). How sure are you that your findings weren't accidentally effected by biases, effecting your research design or approach to accidentally confirm your biases?
- sliverstorm 12y agoWell, you could trivially compare "debunk rates". When I plotted percentage of debunked papers by country of origin, it was clear Elbonian papers are debunked 3x as often as anywhere else With that kind of a wide net, I would think the main sampling errors would be things like "Only studied physics papers" or "forgot to gather data from Journal Y". The findings could be impacted, certainly, but hopefully still trustworthy enough to be actionable?
- jrochkind1 12y agoThere are things you can study. I'm not sure any of them would tell you "9 out of 10 authors from X are corrupt."