3 ms·
> It is completely rational for people to notice that corruption is highly correlated to certain locations in the world What you just 'notice' is anecdotal and
by jrochkind1 12y ago
> It is completely rational for people to notice that corruption is highly correlated to certain locations in the world
What you just 'notice' is anecdotal and biased by, um, your biases. It's not a correlation until you actually demonstrate it in a validly constructed analysis.
Of course, the trick is that legitimate attempts at validly constructed analyses are also effected by biases of the analyzers. When your conclusion is something that 'everyone knows' (but not neccesarily based on legit analyzed evidence), I think it's especially at risk of confirmation bias (when you try to muster the legit analyzed evidence).
It would be very interesting to find historical examples in the US of something that, for a while, scientists simply believed in, and believed that valid objective scientific experiments have shown to be so -- but then later the scientific community came to the opposite consensus. (ESP in the early 20th century might be one example, believe it or not. Look it up!) Science isn't quite as foolproof as one might like or assume.
- judk 12y agoFor example, the scientific "fact" that Caucasians are a superior races than Negros and Mongoloids.
- jrochkind1 12y agoYeah, good point, I don't know why you got downvoted -- at one point, that was consensus science -- and there was all sorts of scientific research, the overwhelming majority of scientific evidence, that people believed demonstrated it. At the moment, consensus science is that there isn't even such a valid object of inquiry as 'race', so you can't even make claims about it. (Although this is changing in interesting ways too, post-genomics)