5 ms·
This was always an idiotic premise. The Federal money laundering statute refers to 'monetary instruments' which it then defines: (i) coin or currency of the U
by mikeyouse 12y ago
This was always an idiotic premise. The Federal money laundering statute refers to 'monetary instruments' which it then defines:
(i) coin or currency of the United States or of any other country, travelers’ checks, personal checks, bank checks, and money orders,
or
(ii) investment securities or negotiable instruments, in bearer form or otherwise in such form that title thereto passes upon delivery;
If you could convince a judge that Bitcoin wasn't currency, it would still qualify as an investment security / negotiable instrument by just about any definition.
- natrius 12y agoIf Bitcoin is a security, is it debt? Is it equity? Is it a derivative of those? If Bitcoin is a negotiable interest, who is the counterparty? Bitcoin is neither of those things. It's currency, but not the currency of any country.
- jrockway 12y agoIt doesn't matter. If I give you a piece of paper with a picture of a spider on it in exchange for something, as far as the court is concerned the piece of paper with the picture of the spider on it is money. (The underlying reason is that barter transactions are as taxable as cash transactions. Doesn't matter what you're bartering for what.)
- natrius 12y agoI agree that it's money. I agree that Silk Road facilitated money laundering. The plain text of the law in question doesn't cover Bitcoin, though. That doesn't mean the ruling was wrong.
- jrockway 12y agoThe other thing to keep in mind, especially for programmer types, is that the law is not a computer program. There is certainly argument around wording in law, no doubt, but the courts do try to consider the intent when making a ruling. ("Well, this is currency, but not the currency of Another Country, so... case dismissed." That might happen, but it also might not, because it's pretty clear that the author of the law wasn't imagining cryptocurrency when drafting it.)
- enraged_camel 12y ago>>The plain text of the law in question doesn't cover Bitcoin, though. You mean the lawmakers did not predict the future and write the law to cover crypto-currencies? Mind-boggling. Totally.
- icebraining 12y agoThe EU had had a law (well, directive) covering electronic money for almost a decade when Bitcoin appeared.
- gamblor956 12y agoBitcoin is a "negotiable instrument[]...in such form that title thereto passes upon delivery." A negotiable instrument can be but is not limited to debt instruments; the counterparty is simply whoever you transact with. Private municipal currency, for example, is not currency under the statute but is a monetary instrument because it is a negotiable instrument.
- Terr_ 12y agoIt's a security. It's equity in a consensus mathematical construct.
- Drakim 12y agoI'm pretty confused over that even an idiot would try to argue this case. It's something that has "coins" in it's name, and is touted as "the internet money of the future" and that is being used in substitute for regular money when buying wares all over the world. If that isn't money, is ANYTHING money? Could one not just as well argue that dollars are just ink on paper, and therefore not money?
- jdong 12y agoStill worth arguing. Much more to gain than to lose here.
- kaonashi 12y agoMoney is a loosely-defined word that ends up being a huge sticking point in economic conversations because people end up using different definitions. One thing Bitcoin is not is a unit of account; it is nobodies liability the way that dollars, treasuries or reserves are a liability of the issuer. When I think money, I think balance sheet; and by that criterion, Bitcoin is not money. It's a currency and an asset.
- late2part 12y agoThis is a very concise point. Modern Federal Reserve Notes are debt instruments.
- ahomescu1 12y agoGermany seems to disagree with your point: http://www.spiegel.de/international/business/germany-declares-bitcoins-to-be-a-unit-of-account-a-917525.html http://www.spiegel.de/international/business/germany-declare... Edit: Wikipedia gives the following requirements for "unit of account": To function as a 'unit of account', whatever is being used as money must be: Divisible into smaller units without loss of value; precious metals can be coined from bars, or melted down into bars again. Fungible: that is, one unit or piece must be perceived as equivalent to any other, which is why diamonds, works of art or real estate are not suitable as money. A specific weight, or measure, or size to be verifiably countable. For instance, coins are often milled with a reeded edge, so that any removal of material from the coin (lowering its commodity value) will be easy to detect. Except for having a specific weight, Bitcoin has these: 1 Bitcoin is the same as any other, and it can be broken into 0.5, 0.1 and even 0.0001 Bitcoins.