9 ms·
Maybe I'm missing something... (I'm newerish here), but it seems to imply there are more HN users who do want NSA coverage more often and more prominent, as evi
by Alupis 12y ago
Maybe I'm missing something... (I'm newerish here), but it seems to imply there are more HN users who do want NSA coverage more often and more prominent, as evidenced by the need for any "weighing down" at all, no?
Why not allow it to be organic? If it's true that most are being flagged down, then that will be the same regardless of any added weight.
I can understand the want to avoid obsessive flame wars, but simply suppressing important articles isn't going to do that. I understand this weight has been in place for a year now - perhaps the weight should be removed as a trial, and see what happens...?
- dang 12y agoI think what you may be missing is that HN is and always has been determined by more than just voting. Voting, user flagging, and active moderation have always been in the mix (well, flagging was added after a year or so). > simply suppressing important articles isn't going to do that What important articles have been suppressed? Please don't cite the one from last night. It wasn't suppressed, except insofar as users flagged it. > Perhaps the weight should be removed as a trial, and see what happens Yes, that might be a good idea.
- Alupis 12y agoPerhaps in addition to a trial period of removing the weight, you can try increasing the reply cooldown for deeply nested conversations (more-so than it currently is) that are in threads whose subject contain the triggered keywords. This way, you can slow down/stop flame wars in NSA articles without having to weigh it down.
- tptacek 12y ago(I don't care if the "NSA penalty" is removed from HN). If the site were solely moderated by voting, it would be Reddit. "No cat pictures" is practically the founding charter of the site: it was started as "Startup News", specifically to be a place that was germane to startup founders that would not be overrun by flavor-of-the-moment content. "Startup News" became "Hacker News", with a broader focus, but it didn't turn into "Everything News", which is why the site has guidelines. Obviously, NSA content is trickier than cat pictures, because much of it (even I'll concede) is very relevant. However, the fifth or sixth game-of-telephone take on every NSA story isn't relevant. Neither, I'd say, are stories about the NSA that touch merely on the political implications of NSA surveillance. This is one of the oldest arguments about moderation on the site. We had it over TSA stories (when I was one of the people voting those stories up!), and we had it (believe it or not) about Ron Paul. There's always a six-degrees-of-startup-relevance to be played with any current events story. If you can't make Justin Bieber's egging conviction relevant to startup founders, you're just not being creative enough.