5 ms·
> In most other Western countries this would not be illegal in this way. I'm not sure about that. Possession of child pornography is a serious crime in most We
by tomp 12y ago
> In most other Western countries this would not be illegal in this way.
I'm not sure about that. Possession of child pornography is a serious crime in most Western countries, and the courts don't really care about excuses, explanations, or the fact that the crime is victim-less. Actually, in most countries, even non-child porn that looks like child porn is illegal (drawings, computer-generated images, adult actors that look like children, ...).
- giarc 12y agoI don't think the commenter meant possession of child porn is not illegal, I think he/she was referring to two underage children exchanging pictures.
- sejje 12y agoThat's a bit scary. Who gets to decide what it looks like? I'm sure there's many places in the law where discretion is used by someone in authority to determine guilt or innocence, but it still frightens me when I see it.
- jcromartie 12y agoExcept only in the US would this kid face a 5 year mandatory minimum sentence for each image (if it were a federal case). I don't know what he's facing since it's Virginia rather than federal charges.
- rwissmann 12y agoActually, in many countries the courts are much more reasonable with regards to interpretation and application of the law. Not just that, but they care about balance between intent of the law, effect and means. There is no way that say in Germany today the police could get away with trying to induce and photograph a teenage boy's erection for a sexting incident. It is such a fundamental violation of human dignity. I cannot even begin to imagine the press coverage and criminal indictments of the people involved.
- GFischer 12y agoIn a very recent case here in Uruguay, an adult had consensual sex with a 14-year old minor, got her pregnant, and made her take an abortion pill. The girl's mother called the police, and it surfaced that the girl had lied about her age and name to the man, so he was found guilty but his sentence was 45 days probation only (no jail time) and an 120 day restraining order. A search for similar cases in the U.S. surfaces: 10 years jail time, 38 years of jail time, etc..
- nasmorn 12y agoI don't know about the pictures but they could have legally slept with each other in Austria. I have never heard of sexting cases here unless the pictures were made available to a wider public.
- tim333 12y agoI'd challenge you to name a single case in a non US country where one of the participants have been charged with possession of child pornography because two kids sexted each other. I've never heard of one.