3 ms·
Two people who want jobs need two cars in America, if the stories on HN about the state of public transport are remotely true. It's bad enough in Germany where
by mschuster91 12y ago
Two people who want jobs need two cars in America, if the stories on HN about the state of public transport are remotely true.
It's bad enough in Germany where nearly every employer expects "mobility" (i.e. driver's license+car), and that with our quite generous mass transit. US is definitely worse.
- xrange 12y agoFrom the byline: >Darlena Cunha is a former television producer turned stay-at-home mom to twin girls. ...maybe someone from the Boston area can chime in on the state of public transportation.
- Jtsummers 12y agoThis article is about their situation from 2008/2009.
- ohashi 12y agoYou must be confused. Stay-at-home mom doesn't mean can't leave the home. In many parts of America, you cannot go or get anywhere without a car. That includes basic things, like grocery shopping.
- xrange 12y agoI guess I don't want to belabor this too much, and maybe this tags me as an old geezer, but I have personally known families with children, who only owned one automobile. One person can drive the other person to work, and then drive the car around for the rest of the day, and then pick them up after work. Of course we don't know their particular details, like maybe they've got a 50 mile one way commute (which in itself would be crazy for a $25k/yr job).
- Jtsummers 12y ago2 children, just born, underweight. So really, let's just disturb them twice a day so Dad can take Mom to work and home again. Oh, and this is 2008/2009 when lots of people were truly happy to have any job, especially after one of their two incomes just disappeared unexpectedly (layoff, not firing). Mom can't take the car to work herself because Dad might need it for errands or medical issues with the kids. They owned the Mercedes (and no debt was mentioned for the unreliable Honda). Why sell assets that are paying for themselves in terms of actual money (getting her to work), and relieving emotional/financial stress (confidence that they aren't totally fucked if one car fails).
- HeyLaughingBoy 12y agomaybe they've got a 50 mile one way commute (which in itself would be crazy for a $25k/yr job). There are many people here in Minnesota who drive comparable distances to make less money. When you live in the sticks and the closest job is a gas station 30 miles away that pays minimum wage, you're pretty much screwed.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- GabrielF00 12y agoThe husband had a job in Hartford (about 100 miles from Boston), so I'm assuming that they lived somewhere between Hartford and Boston. I've lived in both cities. Boston itself has very good public transportation for a US city. Hartford has mediocre public transit - it would be very difficult to live in Hartford without a car. If you're living in a suburb between the two cities you absolutely need to have a car.
- greenpresident 12y agoAs to the employer expectations in Germany: I found this really ridiculous for teachers in training who are expected to own a car to get to the school they work at but are paid 1200€ pre-tax which does not get you very far. You also lose your student ticket for public transport, so going by train is less of an option.
- duaneb 12y agoI don't need a car at all for my job, but i live in a city. It depends heavily on your situation, but if you do live in an urban environment with public transit you could even get away with no cars.
- SheepSlapper 12y agoVery few cities in the US have public transit that's "good enough" to not have a car. When I lived in the Bay Area I didn't have a car, which was mostly ok. I would walk 30 minutes to a BART station and then be in the city in no time. The grocery store was only a few blocks away, so as long as I made a few trips a week (since I could only carry so much) it was fine. But I just moved back to Washington, and there's no way you could do without a car here. The busses only cover about half the city, and they're few and far between (and they only run until 10pm). I'm 10 minutes away from a grocery store by car, so walking is out of the question. Cities that aren't packed full of people don't have a reason to invest in their public transit systems, because the payoff isn't worth the cost (there's just too much space to cover for so few people).