8 ms·
In ‘sexting’ case, police want to photograph teen in sexually explicit manner
- Jemaclus 12y agoI'm not really sure if I'm in the minority or not, but I really don't see a crime happening here. Maybe you ground them and take away their phones, but, I mean, these kids are under the guardianship of their parents and are presumably in a relationship that both sets of parents have (at the very least) acknowledged. It's not like he just sent her the video out of the blue with no warning. I don't see a crime here, when both parties are in a relationship and both consent to the transaction. I dunno. Maybe I'm naive or something.
- fragsworth 12y agoConsidering how inaccurate news reports tend to be when it's about something you are personally aware of, I'm guessing this article was pretty much written by the defense lawyer in an attempt to paint the prosecutor in a bad light. You have no idea how many important details could have been left out.
- Someone1234 12y agoLike what? The facts of the case are pretty well laid out in the article. What are you suggesting they covered up that could really change our perspective of the case? Even if the two teenagers were sleeping together that wouldn't change most people's perspective of this case, it certainly wouldn't change mine.
- kaonashi 12y agoProbably that the girl's parents are spearheading the prosecution; I wouldn't be surprised if this also had a racial element.
- oldmanjay 12y agoHey now, Virginia is pretty progressive. We legalized same-sex relationships this year!
- fragsworth 12y agoAll I know is people who write these kinds of news reports with obvious motives behind them are strongly incentivized to misrepresent the facts or leave some out entirely. Maybe the boy is being charged with other crimes as well - bad ones, and this charge is expected to get dropped. The story just seems ridiculous as written, and that's usually a sign that there is much more to it than what they wrote.
- duaneb 12y agoWhat could possibly explain injecting a teen at a hospital to induce an erection? It's just plain disgusting even if there is a legal explanation (highly unlikely).
- eloff 12y agoYou're thinking logically, it really is the rest of the world that's crazy in this case. Two teens, in a relationship, who can legally have sex with each other (and likely have) what is the fuss about?
- tomp 12y agoActually, it's mostly the USA, where age of consent is 18 in many states and at the federal level. In the rest of the world, teens can legally fuck :)
- duaneb 12y agoHmm, the federal law might actually apply in this case as it's a text that presumably crosses state lines. However, I grew up in a state where I could legally have sex at 16; even then there were romeo and juliet laws that would allow sex with an older individual if they are close in age. It's a little crazy to find that you can have sex but not over the phone.
- mpthrapp 12y agoI agree. This is a completely victim-less "crime". The part that bothers me the most, however, is that the girlfriend is not being charged too. Explain that. EDIT: Not that I think either of them should be charged, just that if one is, they both should be.
- saraid216 12y agoSexism isn't that hard to explain.
- mpthrapp 12y agoNo, I know that's what it is. I just want to hear the justification from the legal system how it's anything but that (assuming there even is one).
- Steuard 12y agoThe article says that the mother of the girl filed the complaint. It doesn't indicate whether anyone has filed one in the other direction; perhaps the guardians of the boy find the idea of prosecuting this behavior repugnant. (And I think it's common for the authorities to choose not to pursue consensual underage cases in the absence of a complaint.)
- ibejoeb 12y agoThe complaint made by the girl's mother merely made the state aware of the situation. The state is prosecuting. It is free, and some would say obliged, to prosecute the girl as well, since it has the same reason to she has committed a crime.
- clarky07 12y agoI really hope you aren't in the minority. I agree with you. I find it absurd that it's a crime for 2 dating teenagers to be "sexting". The worse part is when one is 18 and the other is 16 or 17 or something (depending on where you live laws are different). The things they be charged with is absurd. And then as a bonus they get to be on the sex predators database for the rest of their lives for having consensual sex with their significant others.
- vlunkr 12y agoI've heard of a few cases where people end up on the sex offender list for things like this. Things that don't sound like a "predator" at all, like being caught with a prostitute. I understand what the list is for, but we need to be careful putting people on it, because you could be ruining their life.
- jack-r-abbit 12y agoI've heard of people getting put on the sex offender list for taking a leak in public. I guess if your wang is out for any reason you are a sexual predator and must be punished as such. stupid.
- jtokoph 12y agoWhile I think most people generally agree, the idea here is that a minor can't legally 'consent' because they supposedly aren't mature enough to make decisions for themselves.
- crisnoble 12y agoIn this case he took a picture (allegedly) of his own penis, so who needed to collect his non-applicable consent?
- leot 12y agoExcept they are, apparently, mature enough to be put in prison for their decisions and actions. Funny how that works.
- wldcordeiro 12y agoIt's a lot like how you can apparently still be liable for your decision if you drive drunk, but if you have sex drunk you were raped in the eyes of the law (two drunk people raped each other?)
- DavidJRobertson 12y ago> (two drunk people raped each other?) Don't be silly, it's always the man's fault.
- Jemaclus 12y agoRight, but in this case, both are minors. Since neither can consent, the consent rests in the hands of the legal guardians -- the parents, and since we can probably assume the parents were aware of the relationship (if not the sexual aspects of it), then that means the parents are ultimately responsible... at least that's my interpretation of it. Either way, a crime has not been committed here, imo.
- adwn 12y ago> Maybe I'm naive or something. No, your opinion falls under "common sense" and "healthy attitude towards sexuality" – two traits that quite a number of members of our species seem to lack.
- chrisgd 12y agoI agree. Though I am a little upset at the mother of the girl for filing charges against the boy. Seems like a drastic step.
- cbhl 12y agoI remember my first girlfriend's mother threatened to call the police unless I would promise to "never see/talk to [her] daughter again". I consider myself lucky, because at least she decided to call my parents first, rather than pressing charges right away.
- 300bps 12y agoThe strangest thing about this is that the boy is considered both the victim and the perpetrator of the crime. The teen is facing two felony charges, for possession of child pornography and manufacturing child pornography The only thing he's being charged with is manufacturing and possessing pictures of himself. These laws obviously exist to protect children from predators and in this case, the district attorney is saying that he is both the child and the predator. It's a preposterous (though not unprecedented) use of these laws. It's quite clear the the mother doesn't approve of this relationship and she is using the law to clamp down on it. There may be something about the relationship that offends some people's sensibilities (ex: interclass or interracial dating) which is providing the DA cover to do this nonsense.
- 21echoes 12y ago> Foster said the case began when the teen’s 15-year-old girlfriend sent photos of herself to the 17-year-old, who in turn sent her the video in question. He possesses the photos of his girlfriend, and he manufactured the photos of himself.
- marvin 12y agoIt isn't certain that he is in possession of anything. Which yields another question: If you receive sexually explicit photos of an underage person on Snapchat, which deletes the photos immediately after you receive them, what child pornography laws did you violate? And could you be prosecuted for it, given that you had no idea what you were about to receive before you opened them?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- fardoche 12y agoYou're not naive. It's just that with pot becoming legal in more and more places, something has to be done to sustain the American terror mindset.
- h4pless 12y agoYou're likely not in the minority by being in the group that would look at this case and think, what a load of nonsensical bullshit, this obviously is contrary to justice and is harming everyone much more than the original "offending" act thereby victimizing all involved regardless of guilt or affiliation to the act. You however would be in the minority if you were upset about the atrocious state of sex laws and their enforcement/sentencing (with mandatory sentencing provisions in most cases) so much so that you felt compelled to support the reform of sex laws and registry requirements (a subject that few would touch with a pole of any length). But you wouldn't be alone. Even Patty Wetterling, board chair of the National Center for Exploited and Missing Children, has stated that "We've cast such a broad net that we're catching a lot of juveniles who did something stupid or different types of offenders who just screwed up.. They are very different from the man who took Jacob" referring to her son who was abducted as a young child. Speaking of which: My Son, the Sex Offender: One Mother's Mission to Fight the Law (http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/my-son-sex-offender-one-mothers-mission-fight-law-n98876 http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/my-son-sex-offender-one-...)
- Someone1234 12y agoI think it is very telling that the girl wasn't also charged. Don't get me wrong, I think it is utterly crazy that ANYONE was charged in this case. It is a victimless crime. But reading between the lines there's a certain puritanical undertone to all of it. In most other Western countries this would not be illegal in this way. But the US is extremely religious and has quite an unhealthy attitude to teenage sex (which ironically results in one of the highest teenage pregnancy rates in the Western world also). I genuinely wonder how the people who preside over cases like this (e.g. cops, prosecutor, even the judge) sleep at night. They're actually doing more harm to everyone (including society) than the supposed "crime."
- bryanlarsen 12y agoThe girl's mother filed a complaint, the boy's mother presumably didn't. So it doesn't necessarily say much that the boy was charged but the girl wasn't. The rest of your comment still stands, though.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- xanderstrike 12y agoHe's being tried for "possession of child pornography and manufacturing child pornography." The article says, in plain text, that she did exactly the same thing. It strongly implies that she initiated. Who reported it is irrelevant, especially since the person reporting was neither of the kids involved. For identical crimes, either both of them should be arrested or neither of them. Anything else is injustice and a failure.
- bitJericho 12y agoIf the boy's mother presses charges they'd implicitly be confirming the allegations.
- bradleyjg 12y ago
- ignu 12y agoTo prove a 17 year-old committed child pornography by recording himself, a bunch of adults are going to stimulate and photograph his penis. Makes sense.
- cwt 12y agoIs it legal to commit a felony to catch a felon? i.e: Forcibly manufacture child porn to prove he manufactured child porn.
- valar_m 12y ago>Is it legal to commit a felony to catch a felon? Happens all the time. For example: http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/fbi-busted-child-porn-site-ran-2-weeks-article-1.1359627 http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/fbi-busted-child-porn-...
- jpindar 12y agoMost acts aren't crimes if police do them as part of their job. They are allowed to assault and kidnap people, take their possessions, possess drugs, break traffic laws, trespass, etc. There are exceptions, it remains to be seen if this is one of them.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- moomin 12y agoSince what they're proposing seems to be straight-up sexual assault, should we not be prosecuting the proposers and their accomplices e.g. the judge. If not, exactly what else is legal if you've got a "search warrant"? Securities Fraud? Drug dealing? Arson? Murder?
- jcromartie 12y agoThe government in this case has completely lost its mind. Let's recap here: A teenage girl sent pictures to her teenage boyfriend. He is now charged with receiving child pornography. The teenage boy sent a video back to his teenage girlfriend. He is now charged with manufacturing child pornography. In order to gather evidence, the government is seeking a warrant to take sexual pictures of the person whose own self-produced picture is considered child pornography. The authorities have stated that they are doing this to warn kids of the dangers of sexting. The dangers are, precisely, that the government is out of their fucking mind and will go to any length to prosecute people over any absurd bullshit it possibly can.
- antidaily 12y agofiguratively but yes, yes it has.
- hoggle 12y agoThese laws are insane and so are the executive authorities and their means of operation. What happened to common sense?
- lazyant 12y ago"Police also arrested the teen and took him to juvenile jail, where Foster said they took photos of the teen’s genitals against his will." - charge the police with creation and possession of child pornography.
- DanBC 12y agoThat was a disturbing detail and I wondered how it was legal for them to do that.
- byerley 12y ago"the case began when the teen’s 15-year-old girlfriend sent photos of herself to the 17-year-old, who in turn sent her the video in question." For fuck's sake. Actual intercourse between the two would be punishable by at most a $250 fine in Virginia since the boy is a minor and the girl is less than three years younger - if anyone was wondering.
- scelerat 12y agoMy first reaction was that the absurdity level is so high, there has to be an ulterior motive for the prosecutor here, to expose how ridiculous it is to prosecute children for normal, healthy (if potentially socially risky) sexual experimentation.
- NDizzle 12y ago17 and 15? Two felonies? Boy am I glad smartphones weren't a thing when I was in high school! I'd be off the wrong end of death row already - along with almost everyone in my graduating class.
- mikestew 12y agoThe idea of taking a male teen and stimulating his penis to erection for the purposes of the prosecution sounds nuts, but the nutty part is that it doesn't sounds nuts to the Assistant Commonwealth's Attorney. Granted, she may just be saying that as a negotiation tactic, but even that is sociopathic. But, man, if I lived in that area I would be running for election come the next round, and I'd beat this story into the ground for the entire campaign. Not that I'd want the job. I've run for office, and thankfully lost thus far. But this is one of those times that it's better to have someone who doesn't know what they're doing (and believe me, there are few less qualified for the job of AG of VA than I) than to let these nutcases continue to run the asylum. In this hypothetical case, were I to lose and the incumbents stayed in, this would be the sign for any VA resident to get the hell out as your neighbors obviously think this is okay. As an aside, "special <penis matching> software". Man, I've heard of some verticals in my day, but I'm hoping that's an outrageously small market. (Of course, the guy they quoted is just bullshitting.)
- spodek 12y agoThe police intend to commit child abuse. There's no other way to put it. (Besides the sexist application of a misguided law)
- mikestew 12y agoI think what the parties involved intend to do is garner votes, fluff their career, or "just follow orders". What those parties are ignoring, either willfully or otherwise, is that they have to commit child abuse in order to achieve those goals. (And, sure, there are probably a few pedophiles in the chain that are looking forward to the implementation of the Assistant Attorney's wishes.)
- jcromartie 12y agoManassas is in northern VA, not that far from DC. It's not exactly a bastion of puritanical fundamentalism or anything. I really shudder to think that this kind of behavior is the sort of thing that would bolster your career there. If there are people there who are ready to vote for officials because they pull shit like this, then I have lost all hope for humanity.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoThis is insane, no doubt, but a bit of context for those who haven't seen this happen before. I was in a very similar situation many years ago before sexting. Most times an 17-year-old dates somebody a year or two younger and everything is fine: nobody cares what they're doing. Parents like the kid, the kids behave well, and nobody is the wiser. Every now and then, however, mom and dad hate the bozo that's dating little Chris. So they try to stop it, but that doesn't work. So they drag the cops in and demand that somebody "do something" Over the years, more and more laws have been set up to "do something", usually about child predation, not this scenario. In most of these cases, the cops try to calm things down by trying to de-escalate. But sometimes this does not work, so the Commonwealth's Attorney throws the book at the older partner. It gets worse when the older kid is 17 because there's a time element to it. You charge them as a 17-year-old, they've got a chance to have it all expunged when they reach adulthood. You charge them as an 18-year-old, the mess just gets bigger. Meanwhile the parents (and perhaps the community) is out for blood. I was lucky in that no charges were pressed, but parents can get very angry -- like come over to your house and shoot you angry. The law in this case is probably the lesser of two evils. I imagine the way the cops want it to play out is that the DA charges the adult with 57 felonies, the kid gets a lawyer, they strike a deal and reduce them all to a misdemeanor and probabtion with the condition that the dating pair stay apart. Parents are happy, society is happy. I'm not saying I agree with any of this. It's completely nuts. And you can always run into a true believer DA who really is on a crusade. Quite frankly this erect penis nonsense sounds like that might be what we have here. And that's a freaking scary situation. But most of the time this is just a case of using a hammer to kill a fly that keeps landing on your knee. Having said all of that, the law is insane and must be fixed. Just wanted to point out that sometimes these things don't look as completely crazy from the inside as they do from the outside.
- nmrm 12y ago> Parents are happy, society is happy. Except the kid, who will now have to live with legally sanctioned sexual assault.
- downandout 12y agoThe case is absurd. The prosecutor in the case is trying to make a name for himself, and unfortunately in our system that is completely legal. However, requesting, issuing, and following this order could quite easily fall under conspiracy to produce child pornography. The prosecutor that made the request, any doctors involved, the judge that signed the order, and the police involved in carrying it out could potentially all be federally indicted and/or sued for this. They are immune from prosecution and lawsuits except in cases of blatantly illegal conduct, where this clearly falls.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- tokenizerrr 12y agoHow is this not rape and manufacturing child pornography (by the police)? If they intend to forcefully give him an erection and take naked pictures of him, it sure sounds like it.
- jrockway 12y agoSo he's being charged with "producing child pornography" but the poronography is of himself? That can't be the law's intent. This is wrong on so many levels that I'm getting a headache.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- PeterGriffin 12y agoSo, we're all very very angry and we'll... do what about it? Nothing. This is hardly the first time this happens. There are about half a dozen cases of this kind in mainstream media every year. Plenty more go unreported. Nothing changes, because everyone feels comfortable being outraged talking about it, but they wouldn't touch the problem with a 20 foot pole when it comes to acting about it.
- csense 12y agoI can't think of a more unreasonable search and seizure. If this is "search" is carried out, I would want to see every one of the participating officers and medical personnel go to jail for rape.
- whiddershins 12y agoSo, basically, in order to protect him from himself, they are going to engage in many of the abusive behaviors child pornography laws are intended to protect children from, and then put him in jail.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoAfter reading that I got outraged like everyone else, but thinking about this again, I believe @fragsworth downthread has a good point [0]. Because what is more likely - that the prosecution went batshit insane, or that the journalist is plain lying to us, omitting relevant details in order to spin it into a small scandal? Hint: think of every time a story was reported about something you had first-hand knowledge about. There's a widely known scandal in my country that is often repeated as an argument for the great injustice of our IRS. The story, as told by national TV and paper, is that a baker was ruthlessly taxed (and subsequently put out of business) for leftover bread that he gave to an orphanage for free instead throwing it away. "Oh, the evil government is punishing good people", cried the nation. It grew into such a big media mess that the IRS decided to publish a detailed report from tax control of this baker. Apparently, apart from giving food to poor, he was also running a tax avoidance scheme on half of his merchandise, stealing tons of money. So please just keep in mind that spreading blatant lies is the basic principle news publishing nowdays. [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8010752 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8010752