3 ms·
The anti-gluten free diet people drive me nuts! No one is forcing anyone to go gluten free. I had dinner last night with friends, one of who has had really bad
by mark_l_watson 12y ago
The anti-gluten free diet people drive me nuts! No one is forcing anyone to go gluten free.
I had dinner last night with friends, one of who has had really bad allergies for many years. Really bad. Starting a year ago, her doctor started removing things from her environment to see what might be causing the problem. You guessed it: when gluten was removed from her diet her allergies cleared up within a month.
My wife and I eat mostly gluten free because we believe that modern wheat (which is really a different food now) causes inflammation in some people. I spend zero time trying to get anyone else to go gluten free, because except for my family I don't much care what other people eat.
So, if you like wheat products, enjoy!
BTW, you have not seen the new documentary "Fed Up" about the food industry then please do so. This is the movie the food industry (super powerful lobby in the USA, probably even more clout than the defense industry) does not want to see, so you may have to exert extra effort to find it playing.
- maxerickson 12y agoThe efforts to keep it out of theaters don't seem to be very effective: http://fedupmovie.com/#/page/see-the-film http://fedupmovie.com/#/page/see-the-film The film the food industry doesn’t want you to see branding seems rather successful.
- mark_l_watson 12y ago+1 Excellent, thanks for that link. BTW, one of the things that I was the most pissed off about after watching the movie is the shameful targeted advertising to toddlers, young children, pre-teens, and teens. This targeted advertising at children is illegal in almost all of the developed world, except the USA. The other big take away from the movie is to not eat sugar, which also means avoiding almost all processed foods. When food became low-fat, the food industrial complex started adding sugar, lots of it. That said, if you like sugar and processed food, then enjoy :-)
- maxerickson 12y ago"Processed food" is such an obnoxious phrase. The popular meaning is clear enough, but it ignores the fact that a modern grocer more or less exists because everything there goes through processing (trimming, washing, butchering, baking, blah blah blah).
- mark_l_watson 12y agoI don't think that you understand what "processed food" means. Trimming the fat from meat or washing fresh vegetables is not making "processed food." Seriously, watch the movie. One of the best documentaries I have ever seen. Now, for people who work in the food industry, I understand why people buying fresh food and cooking it themselves is disturbing to them (less profit for the food industry). Another trick for buying food: use local farmer's markets. A lot of "fresh produce" sold in grocery store chains has been trucked many hundreds or thousands of miles. Buying local is better, in my opinion.
- maxerickson 12y agoRead what I said. The popular meaning is clear enough. My point was that implying that butchery is not processing food is asinine. It's like the mantra that some water has "chemicals" in it. It's useful to say that some water has potentially harmful chemicals in it. It's mindless to say that it has chemicals in it.
- yellowapple 12y agoIt is a true statement, though. Water does have chemicals in it. So does your totally-organic no-sugar-added Chia Cherry Lime Naked smoothie (one of which I just drank, actually; they're quite yummy, albeit a bit overpriced). So does literally everything anyone has ever come in contact with. The whole world is chemicals. This whole "chemical free" mantra should be nonsensical to anyone who has even cursory understanding of chemistry.
- maxerickson 12y ago
- hnnewguy 12y ago>This is the movie the food industry The "food industry"? You mean the same one that's slapping "gluten free" labels on anything and everything, while upping the price to take advantage of all these fad followers? Yeah, I'm sure they are devastated. This is a food marketers dream.
- mark_l_watson 12y agoThe way to go gluten free is to make your own food, mainly fresh vegetables, fruit, and some high quality meat. Maybe it is just my tastes, but getting carbohydrates from cauliflower, carrots, yams, etc. is just tastier. But yes, I agree with you that the food industrial complex has jumped all over the gluten free trend.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- andylei 12y ago> fresh vegetables, fruit, and some high quality meat the food industry sells you all of those things...
- yellowapple 12y agoThat's because "the food industry" is a ridiculously-nebulous term, kind of like "terrorism". It's vague to the point of being misleading, since it ends up including big and small players alike without further qualification (and at that point, you might as well be picking a more descriptive term).
- drcode 12y ago> when gluten was removed from her diet her allergies cleared up within a month. If I was your friend and noticed this change I would also go gluten-free immediately, but I think this sentence really highlights the central problem with the gluten-free fad: This is completely anecdotal evidence and I would be embarrassed to tell everyone "hey I'm gluten free and it works!" just because of a month of lower symptoms that could probably be explained by twenty other things that happened that month. Call me back after she's spent two years randomizing month-to-month plus/minus gluten and tracking her daily symptoms in a log book, then her opinion about the benefits of being gluten free might be interesting to others.
- mark_l_watson 12y agoWell, she was acting under her doctor's supervision :-) You are correct about this being anecdotal. BTW, a friend of mine has developed a system for tracking health data and securely sharing it: https://personalexperiments.org https://personalexperiments.org You might like that.
- bmj 12y agoMy wife and I eat mostly gluten free because we believe that modern wheat (which is really a different food now) causes inflammation in some people. I spend zero time trying to get anyone else to go gluten free, because except for my family I don't much care what other people eat. My family has done the same thing, mostly, and for the same reasons. We are not zealots about it, though, and we don't go crazy when eating out trying to avoid every last grain of flour that might be used to prepare foods. As others have pointed out, the "fad" nature of GF means that many restaurants list "gluten free" options while not necessarily realizing that for celiacs, "gluten free" generally has to mean "not prepared anywhere near food that may contain gluten."
- nmjohn 12y ago> I spend zero time trying to get anyone else to go gluten free, because except for my family I don't much care what other people eat. You aren't the cause of the anti-gluten opinions then. The people who go around touting it in a miracle-drug like manner and constantly tell you that what you eat is wrong, that are the problem. And it is this vocal minority of the group that gets attention and makes it harder on the rest