3 ms·
Well, and this is just a crazy idea here, you could just decide as a society that citizen gun ownership is kind of pointlessly dangerous, with a close to statis
by XorNot 12y ago
Well, and this is just a crazy idea here, you could just decide as a society that citizen gun ownership is kind of pointlessly dangerous, with a close to statistically insignificant rate of self-defense usage, and instead move back to a model of an actual well-regulated militia.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoThat statement just implies that you're bad at understanding flaws in studies. Does this mean you should be banned from voting?
- anigbrowl 12y agoWe could, but I'm trying to take an 'all other factors being equal' approach so as to minimize the number of assumptions required, and so considered the second amendment issues in terms of how they're currently interpreted rather than how that interpretation might change.
- vacri 12y ago110 years after the adoption of the second amendment, the US 'militia' was defined as 'all men up to the age of 49'. 'Well-regulated' also means healthy and in good order, in the context of the time. This would suggest that all adult American males (up to 49) should engage in regular training to work as militia units - a militia made up of whatever random yahoos show up with no training is not "well-regulated", using either the modern or antique meanings of the term.